Opinion: Liberal Youth Scotland campaigns for honest lets

Brace yourself — you’re about the hear the SNP getting some praise.

Are you sitting down? Good.

Over the summer, the SNP announced something that student groups like the NUS and groups such as Shelter and the CAB had been calling for a long time. They announced that they would issue a clarification on the illegality of any fees that tenants were being charged by landlords, other than a security deposit and their rent. See here.

The Rent (Scotland) Act 1984 says that “Any person who, as a condition of the grant, renewal or continuance of a protected tenancy, requires, in addition to the rent, the payment of any premium or the making of any loan (whether secured or unsecured) shall be guilty of an offence.” However, this section is ignored by a large number of landlords, and tenants can be charged anything between £50 and several hundred pounds per person. Letting agencies cited “confusion” over the 1984 Act’s meaning as their reason for charging.

Consequently, Housing Minister Keith Brown announced that they would issue a clarification of this section in the most uncertain terms — everything that isn’t rent or a security deposit IS a premium.

However, Liberal Youth Scotland would like the SNP to go a couple of steps further.

Our Honest Lets campaign calls on the SNP to legislate on this issue, to swiftly and decisively stamp out this illegal practice. It is highly unlikely that a clarification itself will have the effect desired, when competition for housing is so high.

Liberal Youth Scotland are therefore calling for the following measures to be put in place:

  • Mystery shopper’ style checks, to identify those landlords breaking the law
  • A process for swift and easy removal of Accredited Landlord status from those found to be guilty.
  •  A quick and simple process for tenants to reclaim fees that have been charged illegally, backdated to any tenancy started within the last ten years.
  • An education campaign making tenants more aware of their rights, and empowering them to refuse illegal fees.

There will be ongoing debate on this in Scottish politics, and hopefully the Scottish Parliament, so to that end LYS are bringing a motion to Scottish Lib Dem Conference this coming Saturday calling for this to be the party’s position in the coming debate. We believe this motion crucially gives our parliamentarians the tools they need to negotiate and debate in the Scottish Parliament on this issue, and bring about a package of measures which make this a historic moment for Scottish housing law.

If you are joining us in Dunfermline, we would hope you support our motion. If you have any questions or doubt, come and speak to us in the exhibition!

If not, then you can still help!  Please sign up to the campaign by clicking here!

* Callum Leslie is standing for Chair in the Liberal Youth elections

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • The Scottish Government have laid before Parliament an SSI which changes the definition of premium. As for further measures – there is the housing consultation on the future of the private rented sector – have you made these comments as a response to the consultation?

    A quick and simple process for tenants to recover fees? Small claims is pretty straightforward and relatively quick.

  • Commenting reminder: Please remember to respect our moderation policy which basically asks people to be polite, be on topic and be honest (ie don’t pretend to be more than one person or to be someone you are not) – that includes not posting substantially the same comment repeatedly across different threads.

    As you can see from other comments published on the site, wide-ranging and robust debate is fine (including comments critical of the party or the site). However, we do ask for little bit of civility – and the chances are you’ll find that makes your points a little more effective at persuading others anyway!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Chris Moore
    And all those wicked profits not only are used in capital expenditure - what businesses invest with profits? Shock horror. That has to stop. But also they pa...
  • Chris Moore
    Joe, how rational you are! It's all down to how greedy those wicked oil men are every year....
  • Joe Bourke
    Shell's large losses in 2021 were the result of a giant write-down in the investment value of the company's oil fields and prospects following the anticipated s...
  • Jenny Barnes
    it's unfortunate that it's far less easy to move gas around: either you need a pipeline (Nordstream!) or an LNG train to liquefy it for ship transport, and of c...
  • Peter Davies
    Almost all taxes raise less than you would expect. The upside of that is the people they hit are not as much worse off (because their changes in behaviour are l...