Lyon: EU must justify spending increases

george-lyon-mep-15Commenting on the European Commission request for an additional 11.2 billion euros in an amending budget, senior Liberal Democrat MEP George Lyon, Vice-President of the European Parliament’s Budget Committee, said:

It is hard to understand how the Commission can justify this increase in the EU budget, long before bills from Member States are even through the door.

At this stage the Commission has no definite idea of what the final payment claims will be for EU projects and will not know until later in the autumn what size the bills from Member States to the EU budget are likely to be.

This ‘big-bang’ announcement from the Commission is premature and the Commissioner has to explain how on earth it has arrived at these figures.

The EU cannot always be the Oliver Twist of international organisations. Simply asking for more is not good enough. The Commission needs to explain why it believes it needs such a huge increase in the 2013 budget when it is only three months into the spending year.

1.5bn Euros, which would be the UK’s share of this money, is not exactly pocket change.

At a tough time for ordinary families and citizens across Europe, EU spending cannot be out of touch with the problems of the real world and people deserve some more answers.

* Newshound: bringing you the best Lib Dem commentary in print, on air or online.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in News.


  • I am pleased to see this attitude from one of our Liberal Democrats MEPs. It is distinctly at odds with the views expressed by Sarah Ludford MEP, who comes across as an apologist for EU profligacy.

  • Simon McGrath 29th Mar '13 - 12:56pm

    Excellent to see one of our Euro MEPs showing that being pro Europe doesn’t nessasrily mean supporting everything Brussels does.
    But why so we send money to Brussels only for them to ‘give’ back to us in the first place ?

  • Sarah Ludford 29th Mar '13 - 1:51pm

    ‘Graham’ claims that ‘Sarah Ludford MEP…comes across as an apologist for EU profligacy’.

    Can he explain that comment? It has no basis in fact whatsoever, as I’ve consistently backed EU budget constraint eg,; and which reports a speech I made last November saying: ‘It is politically impossible to argue to EU citizens under pressure and losing their jobs that the EU budget should rise. So a freeze is the EU-friendly policy.’

    In particular votes I have voted as advised by my budget expert colleague George Lyon, as I think he will attest. (I made one accidental mistake in the vote at ther last plenary, which was corrected).

  • Pushing for restraint in EU spending should not be done reluctantly, in a tone of lament and as a concession to political necessity – because it is ‘politically impossible’ to justify increases to hard-pressed voters – but out of genuine conviction that the EU needs to live in the real world and cut its coat accordingly.

    Do those Lib Dem MEPs who warned that the idea of a real-terms cut in the EU budget was a non-starter continue to believe it is folly, or is this now justified on the grounds of political necessity?

  • Sarah Ludford 30th Mar '13 - 10:18am

    I asked ‘Graham’ yesterday for an explanation of his comment that ‘Sarah Ludford MEP…comes across as an apologist for EU profligacy’. I have demonstrated that it is not true. I’m sufficiently annoyed – as well as puzzled – to ask that he please now justify or withdraw it.

  • Alex Macfie 30th Mar '13 - 1:39pm

    Decisions made by MEPs voting in parliament are *part* of what “Brussels” does. Being an MEP means deciding EU policy, so of course it does not make sense for an MEP, whatever their political leaning, to “support everything Brussels does”. They help DECIDE IT!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Chris Moore
    Mick, our record at holding by-elections in the current political generation, i.e. last 25 years, has been distorted by the wipe out in 2015, at which point we ...
  • Mick Taylor
    I reject emphatically the idea that Corbyn was as toxic for Labour as militant. He actually did quite well in 2017 and only started doing badly when the entire ...
  • Mick Taylor
    @Roger Billins. I was 12 when the Liberals won Orpington and helped with the campaign. Eric held the seat for 8 years and then lost it in the disastrous electio...
  • John Marriott
    @David Raw Thanks for thinking of me. I’ve been on a bit of a self imposed sabbatical from LDV, which looks like being permanent. I think I’ve ruffled too ...
  • Tristan Ward
    @Paul Barker "everyone is running down the Solid Labour win in Wakefield" Seems about right to me: 12.75 % compared to our 30% swing 39% turnout (be...