Liberal Democrat Secretary of State for Scotland Michael Moore told an audience in Edinburgh today that the SNP must stop talking about the process, must stop trying to get the UK Government to negotiate the terms under which Scotland could separate from the UK and get on with setting out their case.
We cannot have the Scottish Government fast forwarding through all the difficult bits to their longed for ending where they clinch a referendum victory.
People want to know what independence would mean for them, their families, and their communities.
Planning the summits and designing the constitutional apparatus is like framing and hanging a picture that is yet to be painted. No matter how gilded and fancy the frame, the missing image is the essential part. I know that it is also the most difficult part for the SNP. But, to be blunt, that is their problem. They must treat the people with respect and start painting the independence picture.
He announced that the UK Government would be publishing a series of papers showing what Scotland gains from being part of the UK:
We have a great and wide consular network with over 14,000 people in nearly 270 diplomatic offices, projecting our values around the globe and looking after Scots abroad. And as an integral part of the UK Scotland benefits from significant levels of influence in the EU, UN, G8 and other international institutions. But it’s not just on the international level that you can see the integration and benefits that being part of our shared United Kingdom brings. We also have close social, cultural and family ties across the UK.
More than 800,000 Scots live and work in other parts of the UK. Each year, around 50,000 people move to Scotland from the rest of the UK. One common passport, one national insurance system and one shared tax system that allows the free movement of people, goods and investment. Together providing a level of prosperity that is greater than the sum of its parts.
There is no-one in this debate who says Scotland couldn’t go it alone. What we – and those who share our view – are saying is it is better for Scotland and the rest of the UK to stay together in our United Kingdom.
He added that the debate must involve all of Scotland, not just politicians and business people:
I want charities, voluntary organisations, and social enterprises to be at the heart of this great debate. You have a crucial role to play. But most of all, you must help each and every voter in Scotland to seek out the evidence and find the information that will allow them to reach an informed decision in the referendum.
Although there is very long way to go before the referendum, the SNP has seen support for independence fall in recent months. A new poll suggests that barely a quarter of Scots currently back a split. While that should not give any cause for complacency to the Better Together campaign, especially given the high number of undecideds, Yes Scotland is bound to be frustrated that it’s actually going backwards the more the prospect of independence is discussed. It’s so much easier for them to shift the discussion to process and negotiation rather than the substantive issues that separation would create. It would be a shame if they and the SNP gave into the temptation to do so.
* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to our feed
Sign-up for our daily email digest
Market Harborough goes bananas on Carnival day
You have no idea if the Spending Review boosted growth
Developing your new business pipeline
Weekly Road Report - West End Ward #dundeewestend
Wales set to lose most from disabled benefit cuts
Thelma Davies
Simon R
Suzanne Fletcher
Cassie
Nonconformistradical
2 Comments
The Westminster-led no campaign is lurching from crisis to crisis today as former Labour First Minister Henry McLeish blasted them for their negative message and failure to present any sort of vision of a positive future for Scotland. Mr McLeish roundly criticised the no campaign’s promotion of an “unreformed union”.
This follows on from the announcement of Labour’s cuts commission that is being driven by their Scottish leader Johann Lamont that will outline the cuts that Labour will impose on Scotland should they be returned to power after a no vote by Scotland on independence. Included in Labour’s unionist cuts are likely to be key policies that were achieved by the Liberal Democrat s in government in Scotland such as an end to FE and HE tuition fees.
Only last week Conservatives announced their proposals to cut benefits for people in “the north” which would hit the least well off Scots hardest should unionists have their way and Scotland fail to vote Yes in 2014…
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/conservative/9782816/Tory-manifesto-blueprint-lower-benefits-for-Northerners-and-longer-school-days.html
The creation of the welfare state was one of the key Liberal victories in the last century and was achieved in the teeth of fierce opposition by privileged tories.
These key Liberal achievements in Scotland are put at risk by continued membership of the UK and can only be safeguarded by a yes vote for Scottish independence in 2014.
Michael Moore cannot give a cast iron guarantee that in the event of a no vote these policies will not be visited on Scotland against its will. Nor can he guarantee that after a no vote, Scotland will remain part of the EU if England votes to leave in an in-out referendum. Indeed, it is the uncertainty involved with remaining in an increasingly isolated UK that poses a huge risk to Scottish jobs and prosperity. Only a yes vote for independence will leave decisions affecting Scotland in the hands of the Scottish people.
Our Party inherits a long and proud record of support for Home Rule and the break-up of the UK; in this we have been tragically resisted by the Conservative and Unionist Party, aided by some “Liberal Unionists” up to the point of fighting a civil war.; and in spite of all the subterfuge and bluster Cathleen ni Houlihan still weeps for her stolen fourth field and so that conflict continues. Unionism still infiltrates our Party, and the usual suspects carry on singing the old anti-democratic, anti-nationalist refrain over Scotland as they did with Ireland. instead of seeking by generosity and support to heal old wounds and assist at the re-birth of a great and free Scottish Nation. There are no bombs in Central London and Manchester, the Scots continue with a civilised and reasoned campaign and call for assistance and recognition. Their reward? The same misrepresentation and the same abuse from the same tired old ideas of the past., the same refusal of help.
Few people these days will take seriously any “pledges” from the current leadership (witness the shifty hair-splitting going on over an EU referendum) but as Party members surely we can stand shoulder to shoulder against any anti-people parliamentary clique on this issue?.