Michael Moore MP writes…Standard Life, the most significant intervention in the Independence Referendum so far?

sl_logoOne of the most significant statements so far in the referendum debate has been from Standard Life. With over 4 million customers across the UK and thousands of employees in Scotland, their intervention matters to all of us.

Standard Life has been headquartered in Scotland for 189 years, so, it is clearly very important when they announce that they are putting in place contingency plans to relocate funds, people and operations to England if we vote for independence with many issues unresolved.

For people like me who want to see the UK continue, it seemed to be a pragmatic statement which recognised the huge uncertainties involved in independence and Standard Life’s obligation to minimise them for their customers, shareholders and employees.

But nationalists saw it rather differently – even amongst themselves. The First Minister claimed the company’s statement supported his position. The Finance Secretary said that it posed lots of questions for the UK rather than the Scottish Government.

To clarify, it is worth looking at what the company actually said in the financial statements it is obliged to produce annually for shareholders. The company’s chief executive, David Nish, posed a whole host of questions about the consequences of any constitutional change.

His five big issues are – the currency an independent Scotland would use; whether agreement and ratification of an independent Scotland’s membership to the European Union would be achieved by the target date; the shape and role of the monetary system; the arrangements for financial regulation and consumer protection; and the approach to individual taxation, especially around savings and pensions as a consequence of any constitutional change.

That’s a chunky list of issues as seen by one of Scotland’s largest companies. You will judge for yourself whose case this challenges most significantly.

But that was not the end of it – the sting in the tail was the statement that “we have started to establish additional registered companies to operate outside Scotland, into which we could transfer parts of our operations if it was necessary to do so.”  There, in sober terms, was a clear statement of what is at stake this September.

The financial services sector remains one of the most important industries in Scotland and the rest of the UK. Financial services contributed £8.8 billion to the Scottish economy in 2010. The sector directly employs 85,000 people in Scotland directly. It provides the banking and investment services that individuals, households and businesses rely on every day; insurance for protection when things go wrong; and pensions and long-term savings products to support people as they grow older.

The UK is widely recognised as a global leader in financial services. Scotland’s vibrant financial sector is an important contributor to this strong UK position, and also benefits from its global reputation.  We have to protect it.

* Michael Moore was the Liberal Democrat MP for Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk from 1997-2015 and Secretary of State for Scotland from 2010-2013.

Read more by .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Eddie Sammon 11th Mar '14 - 12:59pm

    I had been banging on about the dreaded effect that political fragmentation can have on professional services businesses, so it was nice to see a big company hit this message home. Others warned about parochialism.

    Professionals study English and Welsh law and a bit of Scottish too, but it gets to the point where many people won’t bother getting qualified in Scottish law.

    As I said, I think independence always has to be on the table, but I just don’t think it is the best thing for Scotland right now. I’m also not an expert on the issues.

  • “Scotland’s vibrant financial sector is an important contributor to this strong UK position”

    Cough. Indeed, Scotland’s vibrant financial sector almost brought the UK economy to its knees. Fred the Shred, Royal Bank of Scotland, Bank of Scotland, Halifax, London Scottish Bank, Dunfermline Building Society ……… there’s a few vibrant Scottish names that made a truly important contribution to the wider UK economy. Some people have short memories.

  • Denis Mollison 11th Mar '14 - 4:04pm

    Didn’t Standard Life threaten to leave Scotland in the run-up to the 1997 Referendum?

    In which case, why are they still here?

  • We dont want Standard Life (in England). I support the Union but I’m getting sick of big companies playing politics. Given how the banks fared in the credit crunch I find it hard to believe that Scottish based financial institutions have a contingency plan for night following day. Scottish politicians should tell companies to back off. People have votes, companies dont, and they shouldn’t be able to own their own politicians via directorships either.

  • Barry Fleet 12th Mar '14 - 6:06pm

    Ian Sanderson is quite right. Standard Life are just being prudent and sensible.
    We cannot expect them not to plan for all eventualities, that would be careless with the policyholders funds and shareholder entitlements.

  • Laurence Scott-Macka 13th Mar '14 - 3:32pm

    Its time the Liberal Democrats put forward true home rule and got behind the SNP in support of YES. The only policy difference between hoe rule and Independence is Foreign Policy and Defence. After Iraq, Westminster should not have those either. Scotland needs its best now. Come on Michael Moore the coalition have dumped you for Mr Mad and Angry but gets quite scared in front of big bad Nicola, MP for Orkney. But we the people of Scotland need you, we have have our George Washington, but we need our Madison. Please come out and support the cause. Today the Lib deems poll 5% in Scotland, unless they support YES they are finished and wee need your talent. Get behind Yes give our country its wings to soar.

  • Laurence Scott-Macka 13th Mar '14 - 3:34pm

    Oh and if corporation tax is 3% less in Scotland they will not be going anywhere. Look are Ireland they have VMware EMC Microsoft Apple etc Why 12% Corporation Tax and great deductibles.

    Its just Unionist Lies and the Liberal Democrats as the party of home rule should have nothing to do with it.

    Let Scotland be free!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarDilettante Eye 27th Jan - 8:42am
    I guess this article will be atypical of the next twelve months of ‘let’s be grumpy’ for the sake of grumpiness that we can expect...
  • User AvatarMack 27th Jan - 8:41am
    The effectiveness of the technology should increase over time, but that doesn't mean that there isn't a wider public debate to be had on the...
  • User Avatarexpats 27th Jan - 8:36am
    Nick Collins 26th Jan '20 - 6:49pm.................. But I still have the problem of how best to deface the brexit half quid.............. I'm filing them...
  • User AvatarAndrew Daer 27th Jan - 8:29am
    The full election data is here https://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/ResearchBriefing/Summary/CBP-8749
  • User AvatarAndrew Daer 27th Jan - 8:17am
    Also of interest are the 33 seats where Labour came second, and our vote was greater than the Conservative margin of victory; had we (admittedly...
  • User AvatarAndrew Tampion 27th Jan - 7:43am
    HS2 has always seemed to me to be a Londoner's solution to thec rest of the countries transport problems and if built would benefit London...