Peter Black AM: Welsh Liberal Democrat leadership race to begin soon?

At some time on the weekend of the 11th to 12th October the current leader of the Welsh Liberal Democrats, Mike German, will stand up to make a speech to our national conference and conclude it by announcing that he is to stand down from that position with immediate effect.

Although Mike only assumed the mantle of party leader just under a year ago, he has led the Welsh Assembly Liberal Democrat group from day one. He will therefore have served nine years in the post, ten if you count the leadership role he was elected to in the run-up to the 1999 Assembly elections.

In that time Mike has taken the party into government as part of the 2000-2003 Welsh Liberal Democrat-Labour Partnership Government and led us through three Assembly elections.

It would be churlish on my part if I did not take this opportunity to acknowledge the contribution that Mike has made to the party in Wales. He was a councillor for many years and joint leader of Cardiff City Council. He ran a number of our general election campaigns and guided the party’s campaigning efforts in the run up to the 1999 elections, including our contribution to the 1997 Assembly Referendum campaign. He more than deserved the OBE he received for services to politics.

However, after the 2007 Assembly elections the Welsh Party found that they had made no progress on 1999 and 2003 in terms of seats. Mike attempted to lead us into a rainbow coalition with Plaid and the Tories, but failed to convince key members of the party of the wisdom of that move, including a third of the Assembly group, three quarters of the Welsh MPs, most of our Lords and the Welsh National Executive. By the time of the special conference vote, which accepted the coalition arrangement, it was too late to salvage the deal.

Mike announced to the Autumn Conference that he was intending to stand down as soon as possible after the local Council elections in May 2008. He was rewarded with our best ever local government election results across Wales, though these were largely down to the hard work and effort of our activists on the ground and the national swing against Labour. However, he then reneged on his promise and decided to stay until October 2008 which takes us to where we are now.

The race for leader has not really started. I know that I will not be a candidate and it is likely that Montgomeryshire AM, Mick Bates will sit out this contest as well. Inevitably then, the Welsh Liberal Democrats will become the first party in Wales to elect a woman as Assembly Leader, and if Conference merges the two posts, as leader of the Welsh Party too.

This is important, not only because it places a woman into a high profile post but it offers the party a unique selling point that distinguishes us from the grey-haired leaders of old. What is more important is that who we choose as our next leader will have the opportunity to break with the past and offer a new vision for the future.

We need to broaden our appeal. The advent of the Assembly has seen Cardiff dominate much of our politics and left whole regions of Wales feeling ignored and neglected. Our choice of leader can demonstrate that we recognise that and want to do something about it.

People want change and they want leaders who will offer it to them. That is one reason why we need to look to a new generation for our leadership. But above all it is the reason why we need to change our rhetoric as a party and focus our campaigning on the needs of individual communities as well as Wales as a whole.

The limited powers available to the Welsh Assembly has meant that all the parties have focussed on gimmicks and giveaways as a means to distinguish themselves from the others. Some of these, such as free bus passes for the elderly, have had a purpose. But others, such as free laptops for school children, grants for first time buyers, and even our own free toothbrushes for youngsters, have been more symbolic than valid policy goals. The downside is that they have all cost money and that has meant less for key services such as health and education.

I would like to see the Welsh Liberal Democrats going into the next Assembly elections as the ‘no frills party’, emphasising our commitment to invest in basic services and getting them up to scratch instead of indulging in giveaway gimmicks. We cannot afford to continue to allow our health and education services to fall behind those of our neighbours in terms of funding and outputs. We cannot neglect the need to invest in public transport rather than fancy new dual carriageways which quickly fill up with cars. And we cannot ignore the needs of those seeking their first home only to find that there is nothing they can afford in the area they want to live in.

Whoever is elected as Welsh Liberal Democrat Leader will have a short opportunity to grab the attention of the public by taking the party in a new direction. They will be able to outline a vision of a party committed to empowering communities, improving our liberties and our democratic processes and of investing in key services. We can be the no-frills party fighting for local communities, a party that will provide the change we need.

* Peter Black is the Welsh Liberal Democrat Assembly Member for South Wales West and is not a candidate for his party’s leadership.

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in Op-eds and Wales.


  • and I hope, if you are a candidate and are elected leader, you will be prepared tolerate such criticism as you have been prepared to dish out to Mr German.

  • GregoryHouse 27th Aug '08 - 7:06pm

    An excellent and very interesting article. But given your reputation for canny politics, Peter, how much should I read into your belief that the next Welsh LibDem leader needs to “do something about” Cardiff-centric ideas? Should I start betting against Jenny Randerson, AM for, er, Cardiff Central? Surely you realise what might be inferred from what you wrote…

  • anonymous lib dem 27th Aug '08 - 9:27pm

    There is an excellent video on youtube
    which relates to this article nicely.

  • GregoryHouse 28th Aug '08 - 11:50am

    Well I guess that answers my question!

  • Young and talented in what way Peter? You do like them young don’t you?

  • “Young and talented” – well, not as young as when she was first elected (none of us are !) but Kisty Williams’s abilities have cerainly impressed me from very soon after her first being elected.

  • I’m disapointed that Kirsty couldn’t have written the article herself instead of dispatching her wing man.

    She has to come out some time.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Alex Macfie
    @David Raw: So? They were exclusively Lib Dem ~ Tory battleground seats (we lost seats to Labour in 1997), won by us when the Conservatives were self-destructin...
  • nigel hunter
    Roland you mean GBnews is in trouble so they have to 'stir it' to get an audience?...
  • Roland
    >” I’d expect Floella to be polite but highly critical of the delays in compensating victims of the Home Office and, indeed, those administering the Sche...
  • Cassie
    'Not all farmers are rich...' Indeed. The average income of lowland grazing livestock farms in 2022-23 was £21,600. Upland farms lost £10,400 on average fr...
  • Roland
    Re. Lee Anderson Been here before not that long ago… This is about creating “news” for GBnews.....