PMQs: PIP or pip-squeak?

This week Prime Minister’s Questions contained a discussion of the military action in Libya. The need for Arab involvement in the task force was emphasized. Ed Miliband asked for David Cameron to clarify the position on the targeting of Colonel Gaddafi. The Prime Minister didn’t clarify it.

Ed Miliband then made a good point which David Cameron tersely swotted aside with worrying brevity. Miliband asked why the government is taking away the mobility component of the disability living allowance for those in care homes. That sounds a bit convoluted but if you look here you can read what it means in practice. The Prime Minister’s glib response was that the new personal independence payment (PIP) will fill the breach. But you can read here the real concerns of disability charities about this “reform”, which is perceived to be costly in terms of assessment in order to achieve an arbitrary 20% reduction in cost.

Other snippets were:

  • Whipwatch: The Tory whips got the Tories to ask about “spending money we don’t have” several times. The Labour whips got Labour MPs to say how wonderful the NHS is and that Cameron is distorting its record for his own ends.
  • Researcherwatch: Well done to the researcher who dredged up these facts for the PM to spout: We “are 72nd on wastefulness of Government spending, behind Kazakhstan and Cambodia; 108th on Government debt, behind Malawi, Lesotho and, yes, you’ve guessed it, Libya; on the soundness of banks, we are 133rd. Our banks, under Labour, were less sound than those in Serbia, Estonia, Madagascar and Chad.” I think Cameron really is over-egging the pudding now.
  • Jo Swinson (LibDem) asked about the consequences of the Japanese nuclear emergency for the proposed UK nuclear power station programme.
  • Sheffield Forgemasters “has been encouraged to bid under the regional growth fund”.
  • Duncan Hames (LibDem) asked whether there will be reserved places for locally elected people on GP consortia boards. Rather obliquely, the Prime Minister replied only to say: “One of the ways we can make the NHS more accountable is through the better combination of the NHS and local government.” I’m not sure that really answered the question.
  • The Prime Minister does not always read the Morning Star. Well, I never.
Read more by .
This entry was posted in PMQs.


  • MacK (Labour) 25th Mar '11 - 9:28am

    Paul, I think that Cameron’s advisers have been reading the comments on Lib Dem voice and have decided that his strategy against Ed Miliband’s short, incisive opening question must be to respond with a clever, short dismissive answer instead of his usual apoplectic harrangue. But someone should have told him that that will only work if the response is unambiguous. It would seem that Flashman has no idea what his own legislation will do to mobility allowance, just as he appeared not to know that his NHS reforms would bring the NHS under European competition law for the first time. By the way, post budget it seems that some commentators have suggested that mobility allowance will still be removed from those in care homes. Does anyone know what the real policy is?

  • ‘Flashman has no idea what his own legislation will do to mobility allowance, just as he appeared not to know that his NHS reforms would bring the NHS under European competition law for the first time.’

    Flashman doesn’t do detail – it irritates him apparently. He has plebs to deal with the finer points and flag-up anything that doesn’t look right.

    Come on, he’s got better things to do like sell weapons to the Saudi and Bahrain governments to use against protesters.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarRoger 22nd Aug - 11:19pm
    David at No !, and our "speaker', David Warren. I very much agree with both of you, apart from a quibble with David, who disagrees...
  • User AvatarTCO 22nd Aug - 11:14pm
    @William Francis "Technically Cable wanted to replace fees with a graduate tax ( a policy supported by the NUS at the time)." The present policy...
  • User AvatarTCO 22nd Aug - 11:12pm
    @Katherine Pindar if it's rude to point out that an anti-Semitic, terrorist apologist with a self-declared Marxist chancellor and a public school Stalinist pulling his...
  • User AvatarRichard Underhill 22nd Aug - 10:50pm
    Johnny McDermott: We have a Scottish leader, who knows the SNP. Paul Barker: Yes we should stick to our principles. David Evershed 22nd Aug '19...
  • User AvatarPatrick 22nd Aug - 10:17pm
    There is a new interesting possibility. UK’s vote in EU meetings will be delegated by power of attorney to Finland. I'm not quite sure how...
  • User AvatarGeoffrey Dron 22nd Aug - 10:14pm
    @Mick Taylor Wrong thread? Would not re-entry mean adopting euro? Anyway, I'm assuming worst case scenario, but if euro it is and there have been...
Sat 24th Aug 2019
Thu 29th Aug 2019
Mon 9th Sep 2019