Tag Archives: digital single market

The Digital Single Market should enable users and innovators, and not constrain freedom

In the rather dry text of the Proposal for a DIRECTIVE OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL on copyright in the Digital Single Market there lurks, behind the good intentions, an information restricting and illiberal set of proposals. The infamous Article 13. The objections of the technically informed and creative internet users were ignored last June by the majority in the European Parliament who passed the proposal by a sizable majority and the final vote on the directive is immanent.

Article 13 risks being nothing more than an act of corporate welfare; with big business standing to gain while individuals see little benefit and potential disadvantage. The argument that this legislation primarily benefits the creatives and other innovators, who produce content that is currently being shared on the internet without permission, is flawed. 

More often than not, copyright of such content is not owned by the creators themselves but large corporations, such as Universal Music Group, who then pay artists a percentage of the profits made from the copyrighted material. It should be the responsibility of these corporations to ensure that their artists are fairly remunerated for their work, and that responsibility should not be shifted unfairly onto platform providers such as Facebook or YouTube. In addition, there are wider, perhaps unintended consequences. According to cryptographer and security expert Bruce Schneier, “Aside from the harm from the provisions of Article 13, this infrastructure can be easily repurposed by government and corporations – and further entrenches ubiquitous surveillance into the fabric of the Internet.”

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged | 4 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarPeter Martin 21st Feb - 10:46am
    @ Tahir, There's lot of 'what ifs' that could arise in the next few months which can only properly be analysed by game theory. Game...
  • User AvatarHelen Dudden 21st Feb - 10:30am
    I would leave it in the hands of those, who know more about the subject. Like many others, I have said no.
  • User AvatarJayne Mansfield 21st Feb - 10:27am
    @ expats, I don't doubt Heidi Allen's sincerity, I said nothing about her judgement. She is relatively new to politics and probably did not have...
  • User AvatarMichael Romberg 21st Feb - 10:14am
    If Brexit happens, the vagueness and non-binding nature of the political declaration means that it's all to play for on the future relationship. No point...
  • User Avatarexpats 21st Feb - 10:02am
    David Raw 20th Feb '19 - 10:15pm.............Well, expats, just for once we’ll have to disagree..... No problem, David. We, and Jayne, agree on far more...
  • User AvatarSandra Hammett 21st Feb - 10:01am
    Serious question: Could any ardent Coaltion apologists explain to me why those now in the Independent group didn't join the LibDems? What possible issues can...