Tag Archives: ian macwhirter

The Herald: “All power to the Lib Dems for standing up for our liberties”

Willie Rennie - Some rights reserved by Liberal DemocratsHerald columnist Ian Macwhirter is not known for writing nice things about Liberal Democrats. In fact, I think it actually causes him pain to do so. It is always welcome when someone who is not your biggest fan says nice things about you. He was very complimentary about Willie Rennie the other day. As someone pointed out on my Facebook when I posted this originally, “All Power to…. is not the most civil-liberties friendly headline, but it’s appreciated nonetheless.

As James Baker wrote a few weeks ago, the Scottish Government were trying to sneak in plans for what is effectively a massive ID database capable of even more surveillance than that set up by Labour. Once Willie got to hear about it, he set about questioning it and used a rare Liberal Democrat opposition day debate in Parliament to highlight the issue. He called for the creation of such a database to be the subject of primary legislation. He was never going to win, because, you know, SNP overall majority and all that – and they don’t take kindly to rebellion or even criticism from their parliamentarians – but he inflicted a bloody nose on the Deputy First Minister John Swinney.

Macwhirter wrote:

I think now we have an answer to what the LibDems are for: they’re the only major party, Greens aside, that really takes issues of civil liberties seriously, as we saw yesterday with their debate on the Scottish Government’s plans effectively to create a national identity database.Leader Willie Rennie’s motion to stop the measure being rushed through without proper parliamentary scrutiny succeeded by 65 votes to 60 in the Scottish Parliament after an intelligent and thoughtful debate; a rare occasion on which Deputy First Minister John Swinney was sent back to think again

We need parties that keep a vigilant eye on government. Labour has never quite got this privacy thing having been, for most of its existence, a party very much of and for the big state. The Tories are supposed to be the party of the individual but their law’n’order populism, hostility to immigration and preoccupation with state security have made them suckers for any agency – police, spooks, tax authorities and so on – that wants to snoop into our affairs.

The Tories seem to recognise threats to civil liberties when in opposition. Their spokeswoman Liz Smith MSP is opposing the latest plans from the Scottish Government as “identity cards by the back door”.

The SNP are similarly schizophrenic. They opposed the introduction of a national identity database in 2005 when it was proposed by Tony Blair’s Labour government. But once the Nationalists got into government they started succumbing to the same pressures to tighten up all round and, of course, to praise our wonderful police, as Nicola Sturgeon did last week.

That would be the same wonderful police, by the way, whose senior management are, for the second time, being hauled back before a parliamentary committee for failing to deliver what they said they would. On both stop and search and armed police they have not kept their word and their chief constable has not shown an acceptable attitude towards scrutiny.

Posted in News | Also tagged , , , and | 10 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarTeeJay 19th Sep - 10:37pm
    Marxist, Hamas-loving, bogeyman Corbyn’ is a gift that appears never to stop giving. But it could rapidly lose value for the Tories if the Lib...
  • User AvatarBill le Breton 19th Sep - 10:36pm
    3rd and final piece of the jigsaw. Jo should demand Labour join the Revoke pledge when it decides it's policy at Conference.
  • User Avatarjohn king 19th Sep - 10:32pm
    Very good to read your candid account. Your experience to some extent mirrors my own. I had a top job leading a team treating and...
  • User AvatarPaul Barker 19th Sep - 10:26pm
    Looking at Andrew Teales previews on Britain Elects I can only see one likely "Gain" & that should really be a Hold, The Tory Candidate...
  • User AvatarAlex Macfie 19th Sep - 10:19pm
    Michael BG: There is nothing at all undemocratic about saying we'll do X if we win outright, then doing X if we do. It doesn't...
  • User AvatarSpencer Hagard 19th Sep - 10:09pm
    Labour polling consistently in 2nd place since Johnson became PM has suited the Tories well. ‘Marxist, Hamas-loving, bogeyman Corbyn’ is a gift that appears never...
Thu 10th Oct 2019