Tag Archives: nation building

An Afghanistan catastrophe, Part 1 (of 2)

It is tempting for UK political figures unfamiliar with the wars in Afghanistan, to view recent events as a ‘surprise loss for the West’ that is ‘all the fault of President Biden’. Neither is true. I will attempt a summary.

The war was ‘lost’ many years ago. Talebs and other insurgents controlled a majority of the country after the first five years. By the end of 2009 ICOS (Western-funded) reported that the Talebs had a controlling presence in 97% of the country, and had de facto control of Districts representing almost two thirds of territory.

Certainly when I first arrived in 2008 the Talebs controlled the road from central Kabul and the Compound to the airport, requiring a dangerous circuitous route. Driving to Jalalabad or Kandahar, there were Taleb road blocks, some taking ‘fees’. The game was already over. Why?

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged | 3 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Craig Levene
    Just about sums up Labours negotiating skills.. https://x.com/afneil/status/2124197800116408634?a=FZUpBQRayPPJ-WTDSzw&s=19...
  • Chloe
    Opinion wasn't on the ballot ..Two choices were ... Following its assessment process, the commission has recommended that the question should be amended to: �...
  • George Potter
    David Raw, I'm sorry that the bit on the second page about my CV and Experience wasn't helpful to you, but it does mention that I've been a councillor in Guildf...
  • Cj Williams
    Alex Macfie. You make the point that the list is 'mostly' American and then explain how corrupt tech companies are in the USA. 'Mostly' implies that under the ...
  • expats
    David Allen 21st Nov '26 - 5:16pm..., I don’t think you can have more than two options on a referendum ballot... In fact there were umpteen 'Leave' options...