Our place to talk – an independent website for supporters of the Liberal Democrat party in the UK.

The most-read independent website by and for Lib Dem supporters. Not paid for by trade unions or millionaires.

Advert

Tag Archives: nation building

An Afghanistan catastrophe, Part 1 (of 2)

By Paul Reynolds | Mon 23rd August 2021 - 3:23 pm

It is tempting for UK political figures unfamiliar with the wars in Afghanistan, to view recent events as a ‘surprise loss for the West’ that is ‘all the fault of President Biden’. Neither is true. I will attempt a summary.

The war was ‘lost’ many years ago. Talebs and other insurgents controlled a majority of the country after the first five years. By the end of 2009 ICOS (Western-funded) reported that the Talebs had a controlling presence in 97% of the country, and had de facto control of Districts representing almost two thirds of territory.

Certainly when I first arrived in 2008 the Talebs controlled the road from central Kabul and the Compound to the airport, requiring a dangerous circuitous route. Driving to Jalalabad or Kandahar, there were Taleb road blocks, some taking ‘fees’. The game was already over. Why?

Continue reading »

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged afghanistan | 3 Comments

Most Read

Op-eds

Is Ed Davey toast? (Caron Lindsay)
A plea from a member – more ambition and less equine pacification please… (Nick Baird)
Will the real Green party that cared about people and planet please stand up? (Kobe Bibbon)
We need better conversations on AI and the environment (Josh Matthews)
How to spot a Racist (Ben Rich)

Advert

Recent Comments

Peter Davies
At the local elections, we went up in the parliamentry seats we hold and down in the ones we don't. At conference you could sense the divide between members in ...
Tim Rogers
Please everybody slow down and calm down. SirEd has kind of been put on notice that he needs to up his game. The problem is less what we say but that we say not...
Martin Pierce
I think Ed should be worried if Caron is saying this. She is not quick to temper on such matters. As others have said though, my worry is not so much that Ed is...
Hywel
Tim Farron said "most polls suggest we’ll hold or even add to those record numbers of MPs" In fact not one MRP this year has shown an increased number of L...
Sarah
Ed should take the frustration and stagnation of the party as a sign and do the honorable thing. He should announce a leadership election in the new year that h...