Trust, consent and the limits of criminal law – why a staggered age of consent is the wrong instrument

Embed from Getty Images

Gladstone’s line still holds: liberalism is trust of the people tempered by prudence. The current discussion of a staggered age of consent tests that directly. It is less a debate about the exact age at which sex becomes lawful and more a debate about when the state recognises someone as capable of making decisions and accepting responsibility for them.

I would keep a single age of consent—at 17—and resist making that capacity conditional on the age of the other person. Once the threshold is crossed, the presumption should be that the individual can consent. Any further restriction needs a clear justification. A staggered rule treats the age-of-consent law as a convenient proxy for problems that already have, or should have, their own legal home.

Keep the three functions separate

Three different questions are in play. They should not be collapsed into one another.

First, non-consensual sex—rape and sexual assault. These offences already exist and turn on whether consent was present. Age can be relevant evidence. It is not the offence itself. If the worry is that consent was not real, the right place to look is the existing law of sexual offences.

Second, abuse of trust or position. Someone in a position of authority, dependency or control can exploit that position. The law already recognises certain positions of trust with 16- and 17-year-olds. Where those provisions are too narrow, they can be tightened. The limit is straightforward: the definitions have to stay clear. An offence that rests on vague ideas of “imbalance” or “exploitation” hands too much discretion to prosecutors and courts. Protection against private power should not create arbitrary public power.

If exploitation is hard to prove in practice, the proper response is to clarify the abuse-of-trust offence, not to rewrite the age-of-consent rule so that an age gap itself becomes the crime. Difficulty of prosecution is not the same thing as the absence of an offence. And consensual sex that someone later regrets is not, by itself, a criminal matter.

Third, the age of consent proper. Its job is to mark the point at which the state recognises general capacity. It is not a residual bucket for every concern the other two offences do not catch. Once that recognition is given, either the person is treated as capable or they are not. A rule that says you may consent with some adults but not others needs a justification that goes beyond the desire for a bright protective line.

What a staggered rule still has to explain

Those who want to stagger capacity by the partner’s age have to answer a few awkward questions.

If an age gap is a good enough proxy for exploitation that it should criminalise otherwise consensual sex, why do we not treat other legal capacities the same way? We do not make the right to vote, marry or give medical consent depend on the age of someone else. A staggered sexual rule treats sex as uniquely different. That difference has to be spelled out.

What exactly is the wrong? If it is lack of consent, we already have offences for that. If it is abuse of a position of trust, we can strengthen that offence—provided we keep the language precise. If it is neither, then the staggered rule is creating a new crime whose substance is simply the age difference. That needs its own defence, and it has to explain why later regret does not become the test.

Why put the proxy in the capacity rule rather than fix the abuse-of-trust provisions? Evidentiary difficulty is a reason to improve the offence that targets the abuse, not a reason to change what counts as capacity.

Prudence still applies

Evidence of harm can properly influence where we set the single age. Patterns of violence or particular risks might justify a higher threshold than we would otherwise choose. They do not justify making capacity itself depend on who the partner is. Trust tempered by prudence means looking at what the existing law already does, keeping the categories distinct, and thinking about how any new power will be used later. Protective aims do not excuse vague drafting or the habit of using one offence to solve the problems of another.

The burden sits with those who want the staggered rule. They need to show why an age difference should stand in for proof of non-consent or abuse of trust, and why sexual capacity should be conditional when other adult capacities are not. It is not for everyone else to prove that every relationship above a single age is harmless.

Liberalism should prefer clear rules, limited discretion and a presumption of trust in the individual. A single age of consent, with abuse of trust addressed in its own properly defined offence, fits that approach better than a rule which makes legal capacity turn on the age of the other person. Trust of the people, tempered by prudence, remains the more reliable guide.

* Owen Driscoll is a member of Epping and Harlow Liberal Democrats.

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

4 Comments

  • As is now – a 15/17 year old wouldn’t cross the CPS’s desk , neither would a 19/15 year old in all honesty. Where on earth do you set a boundary. I’d just turned eighteen when I married my husband who had just been demobbed at 21. Looking at my mum & nans marraige certs 18/23 18/24 …The more you look at it the more complex it becomes.
    Prosecuting a 19 year old going with a 16 year old ?

  • Matt (Bristol) 17th Nov '26 - 1:37pm

    Your choice to restrict liberty in one direction (moving threshold up, criminalising sexual activity of 16 and 17 year olds with each other but leaving sexual relationships with any older adult for a 17-year-old, still technically in law a minor) undercuts your argument somewhat here.

    I’m not sure Gladstone (whose views on sexuality were largely secret and riven by guilt about his own urges, but probably would have skewed conservative, yet whose government dragged its feet somewhat on the law in 1885 which raised the age of consent from 12 to 16, where it has sat ever since) is your best intellectual or historical defence here, either: even if we accept his argument, this is a debate about what is ‘prudent’. You accept something needs to change…

  • So you are still proposing raising the age of consent to 17?

  • Owen Driscoll 17th Nov '26 - 2:53pm

    So I did trim elements to bring the word count down.

    This is about legislation and state power. The relationship to the state changes when you become an adult. It should not be paternalistic, it should start with a presumption of trust.

    This could be 17, I am not wedded to it – it could be either side. But that is where my inclination is – coming from a top down principle of determining adulthood – voting age, age of consent, drinking age etc – unless there is a clear bottom up reasoning to diverge from a consistent age.

    Yes I am proposing moving the age of consent up – particularly when social media, violence against women discussions are occurring – times are different. There is a material change that to me warrants a move in the age of consent going up.

    Yes I have invoked Gladstone – for me i actually prevent to bring in Cicero as well and make it trust tempered by memoria, intelligentia and providentia. But it is simple to understand – default to trust unless there is good reason to differ.

    And yes I do believe a 16/17 relationship is worse than a 17/25 for example in the social media and pornography age. The age at which trust is granted should be raised. But you cannot baby adults. If I am defining 17 as an adult.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Owen Driscoll
    So I did trim elements to bring the word count down. This is about legislation and state power. The relationship to the state changes when you become an adu...
  • FS People
    So you are still proposing raising the age of consent to 17?...
  • Matt (Bristol)
    Your choice to restrict liberty in one direction (moving threshold up, criminalising sexual activity of 16 and 17 year olds with each other but leaving sexual r...
  • FS People
    I see people trying to claim that Brand and his Ilk were part of “lad culture” which allowed him to hide this is ridiculous. Lad culture was a 90s phenomeno...
  • Chloe
    As is now - a 15/17 year old wouldn't cross the CPS's desk , neither would a 19/15 year old in all honesty. Where on earth do you set a boundary. I'd just turne...