Young people – we must end the era of regulation obsession

Embed from Getty Images

Each day brings another headline: employer National Insurance contributions increasing, smartphone bans in schools, proposals to monitor young people’s online activity more closely. This weekend we took economic illiteracy to an impressively stupid height and now we have the suggestion of further regulatory burdens on businesses that want to employ 16 and 17-year-olds in part-time work.

On the surface, these may seem like isolated policy decisions. In reality, they point to a deeper and more troubling trend in modern government: the growing tendency to view young people not as emerging adults capable of responsibility, but as vulnerable dependents who require constant protection.

The result is a slow but steady infantilisation of an entire generation.

At precisely the moment when Britain faces stagnant productivity, stubborn skills shortages and sluggish economic growth, Labour appear determined to make it harder, not easier, for young people to gain the experiences that prepare them for the world of work. Every new regulation may be motivated by good intentions, but intentions do not create opportunity. Employers do, economic growth does and incentivising risk does.

For many people of a certain age, a Saturday job was a rite of passage. My first one was in a chip shop (I was terrible), my second one was teaching windsurfing (I was markedly better).

Whether stacking shelves, washing dishes, delivering newspapers or serving customers, those first jobs taught lessons that no classroom could replicate. Young people learned punctuality, responsibility, customer service, teamwork and the simple reality that if you wanted to earn money, you had to turn up and work for it. However in order to turn up, the jobs had to be there and when you have regulatory obsession, then businesses have no desire to take a risk.

Today, however, we seem increasingly uncomfortable with allowing young people to encounter risk, responsibility or independence. We speak endlessly about preparing students for employment while simultaneously creating barriers that discourage businesses from employing them in the first place. Faced with rising NIC and minimum wage costs and cumbersome compliance obligations many employers will simply conclude that hiring an adult is easier than taking on a teenager.

That may be rational from a business perspective, but it creates a long-term problem for society.

The transition from childhood to adulthood is not something that happens overnight at eighteen. It is a gradual process, developed through responsibility and experience. Remove those opportunities and we should not be surprised when young adults arrive at university or in the workplace lacking confidence, resilience and practical skills.

This contradiction is visible across decision making by a Labour government who have spent all of five minutes in the private sector.

Young people are told they are too vulnerable to work certain jobs, too young to make certain decisions, and too at risk to be exposed to disagreement online. Yet at the same time, we expect them to leave education and navigate an increasingly complex labour market with little practical experience of the real world.

Protection has become the default answer to every problem.

The irony is that many of the challenges Labour seek to address would be better solved through greater responsibility rather than less. A teenager working part-time in a local business gains exposure to adults, develops communication skills and begins to understand professional expectations. They learn to deal with difficult customers, conflicting priorities and workplace discipline. Those experiences build character in a way that cannot be replicated through nanny state interventionism.

None of this is an argument for abandoning safeguarding or winding back sensible employment protections. Young people should be protected from exploitation, dangerous working conditions and abuse. But there is a significant difference between protecting young people from harm and protecting them from life itself.

As of present the government seems obsessed with regulation to the detriment of young people’s ability to actually grow up.

Economic growth ultimately depends upon human capital. It depends upon people acquiring skills, experience and confidence. Every barrier placed between young people and meaningful work delays that process. Every regulation that persuades an employer not to hire a sixteen-year-old removes a valuable opportunity for someone to gain the habits and mindset that underpin future success.

Britain cannot regulate its way to prosperity, a notion that seems entirely lost on Labour.

However, if we genuinely want a generation that is capable, resilient and economically productive, we need to trust young people with responsibility. That means encouraging employers to create opportunities rather than burdening them with additional bureaucracy.

It means recognising that a Saturday job is not exploitation, but education of a different kind. It means accepting that developing capable adults requires allowing young people to act like adults before they officially become one. It means allowing young people to make those mistakes that many people make in their first job.

If we are serious about ending the NEET crisis, stimulating economic growth and actually giving young people a fighting chance, then we must reverse the idea that government always knows best. We must also move away from the idea that the answer to yet every problem our society faces is “more government”. By allowing Labour to act like an overbearing nanny-state, we are setting the future workforce up to fail.

* Callum Robertson is a teacher and member of the Federal Board. He is a Watford Borough Councillor.

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • FS People
    So you are still proposing raising the age of consent to 17?...
  • Matt (Bristol)
    Your choice to restrict liberty in one direction (moving threshold up, criminalising sexual activity of 16 and 17 year olds with each other but leaving sexual r...
  • FS People
    I see people trying to claim that Brand and his Ilk were part of “lad culture” which allowed him to hide this is ridiculous. Lad culture was a 90s phenomeno...
  • Chloe
    As is now - a 15/17 year old wouldn't cross the CPS's desk , neither would a 19/15 year old in all honesty. Where on earth do you set a boundary. I'd just turne...
  • David Vigar
    I agree that government needs to understand neurodivergent people more but I don’t think a dedicated minister is feasible. We already have a minister for ment...