Tag Archives: age of consent

Trust, consent and the limits of criminal law – why a staggered age of consent is the wrong instrument

Embed from Getty Images

Gladstone’s line still holds: liberalism is trust of the people tempered by prudence. The current discussion of a staggered age of consent tests that directly. It is less a debate about the exact age at which sex becomes lawful and more a debate about when the state recognises someone as capable of making decisions and accepting responsibility for them.

I would keep a single age of consent—at 17—and resist making that capacity conditional on the age of the other person. Once the threshold is crossed, the presumption should be that the individual can consent. Any further restriction needs a clear justification. A staggered rule treats the age-of-consent law as a convenient proxy for problems that already have, or should have, their own legal home.

Keep the three functions separate

Three different questions are in play. They should not be collapsed into one another.

First, non-consensual sex—rape and sexual assault. These offences already exist and turn on whether consent was present. Age can be relevant evidence. It is not the offence itself. If the worry is that consent was not real, the right place to look is the existing law of sexual offences.

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged and | 4 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Owen Driscoll
    So I did trim elements to bring the word count down. This is about legislation and state power. The relationship to the state changes when you become an adu...
  • FS People
    So you are still proposing raising the age of consent to 17?...
  • Matt (Bristol)
    Your choice to restrict liberty in one direction (moving threshold up, criminalising sexual activity of 16 and 17 year olds with each other but leaving sexual r...
  • FS People
    I see people trying to claim that Brand and his Ilk were part of “lad culture” which allowed him to hide this is ridiculous. Lad culture was a 90s phenomeno...
  • Chloe
    As is now - a 15/17 year old wouldn't cross the CPS's desk , neither would a 19/15 year old in all honesty. Where on earth do you set a boundary. I'd just turne...