Tag Archives: neoliberal

Liberals and Neo-Liberals

Professor David Howarth, formerly LibDem MP for Cambridge, contributes to the new Social Liberal Forum book with a powerful, closely argued essay on Liberal economics. This an extract:

Here is a puzzle: if JS Mill, JM Keynes and James Meade were all Liberals and economists, what is a ‘neo-liberal’ economist? One might have thought that it would be someone who updated their thought to consider new facts and new problems.

In a highly successful example of propaganda and disinformation, ‘neoliberal’ has come to mean the doctrines of Friedrich Hayek or Milton Friedman. But those doctrines are anything but ‘neo’. They hark back to the era before Mill. We need to rectify names. Instead of ‘neo-liberals’ the followers of Hayek and Friedman might be called ‘paleo-partial liberals’.

The next step is to reclaim the Liberal tradition. That was the avowed aim of the editors of the Orange Book, but what some of them seemed to mean was not updating Mill, Keynes and Meade but abandoning them in favour of paleo-partial liberalism. Admittedly the diagnosis was not entirely wrong. The Liberal Democrats, as a political party, had wandered a long way from the Liberal tradition and had succumbed to various forms of conventional wisdom.

But the most distinctive feature of Liberal policy was its stance on corporate governance. From Mill onwards, through the Yellow Book to support for codetermination, Liberals argued for a different way of organising firms, not as hierarchical structures dominated by the owners of capital but as partnerships between labour and capital, incorporating democratic representation. James Meade provided a continuation and deepening of this tradition that should have formed the basis of the merged party’s position.

Posted in Books | Also tagged and | 48 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarJack Graham 26th Sep - 4:15pm
    I would imagine the first thing you will do is eat your hat. The second thing you will do is to add Brexit to the...
  • User AvatarCatherine Jane Crosland 26th Sep - 4:14pm
    This is the discussion that the party should have been having ever since the referendum result. But could I go a bit off topic, and...
  • User AvatarSean Hyland 26th Sep - 4:09pm
    I recall a campaign from some years back that sought to change the spelling to dysabled. The view was that the use of " dys"...
  • User AvatarOnceALibDem 26th Sep - 4:09pm
    There is a danger of hyping up the idea of instant calamity on March 30th in that if it doesn't happen it will undermine people's...
  • User Avatarfrankie 26th Sep - 3:55pm
    We will live in intresting times and many polticians will be attemptting to avoid blame by shouting "Look an EU rabbit". This may well work...
  • User AvatarJenny Barnes 26th Sep - 3:19pm
    expats "The last ‘real’ leader was Nick Clegg, " If that's a real leader, we're better off without one.