What’s being debated in our members’ forum this week?

members forum wordleLibDemVoice has two parallel sites. The first is our public blog, the thing you’re reading now. The second is our private members’ forum, which only current Lib Dem members can access.

If you’re a member and want to chat with fellow party members about any issue that’s on your mind, then why not sign up? In addition, you’ll be included in our regular surveys’ of party members’ views.

Here’s some of the most active discussions this past 10 days:

Why not join in the debate and share your views? (But please remember to stick to our comment policy — and that no forum is ever 100% private!)

Read more by .
This entry was posted in Site news.


  • Eddie Sammon 11th Oct '14 - 5:39pm

    Can we get on with bombing IS in Syria? Turkey’s response has taught me that you can’t rely on regional powers for these things, despite what waffle Douglas Alexander is spouting in the Guardian.

  • Eddie,

    Did you mean “we”???

    Or did you mean that someone else should get on and do all this bombing for you?

    At home in Southport I guess you are comfortable calling for the bombing and destruction of another country a long way away. The innocent civilians in Syria may not feel as comfortable as you as they are the ones who will die, or have their homes and businesses destroyed, or see their children blown apart or maimed by shrapnel.

    Those civilians will be written off as “collateral damage”, a price worth paying,

    The UK and the USA has spent most of the last 25 years bombing Iraq and now you want the RAF to get on and bomb Syria. I guess you must think that the bombing of Iraq since 1990 has been such a stunning success that the people of Syria will be delighted to have a similar privilege extended to them?

    Bombing is such a simple and easy solution.
    Ever thought that the situation in Syria might be a bit more complex than that.

  • Eddie Sammon 11th Oct '14 - 6:29pm

    Hi John, I just think we shouldn’t let Kobane get taken. I agree very much with Ming on this. Doing nothing isn’t going to save lives either, but I’d rather support the ones who look alright than just sit back as if they are all as bad as each other.

    Douglas Alexander’s piece seemed to be neither supporting nor opposing airstrikes in Syria, but I really think now is the time for action, rather than hesitation.

    As you know, I don’t back military action all the time, but I have been saddened by the way the media has moved Kobane/Kobani down the pecking order whilst prioritising Farage knocking on doors.

    I am also aware of the slightly bad taste in calling for military action whilst not going yourself, which is why I’ve been thinking of joining the reserves again, but I’ll probably just have to make sure I don’t shout too loudly.

  • Eddie

    If you check it out in Wikipedia the town of Kobani is only 100 years old. A railway town on a German built raiway in Ottoman times The people were mainly refugees from earlier wars The French Mandate ran Syria but did not do much for Kobani. At one time there was a large proportion of Armenians escaping an earlier genocide who mainly moved on again in the 1960s to the then Soviet Union. Recently it has been mainly Kurdish. The Turks have not been the Kurds’ best friends for the last hundred years either within Turkey or anywhere else. It is not so very long ago that Turkish armed forces would cross the border to chase down Kurdish “terrorists”, the Peshmerga who are now apparently everyone’s best friends because they are prepared to take on the Daesh, the guys with the black flags.

    Until the civil war started in Syria a few years ago this unremarkable town got by and nobody in the UK even if they had a clue who the Kurds were would have been able to tell uyou which bit of Syria was mainly Kurdish. Most people in the USA probably could not find Syria on a map.

    In 2014 we all love the Kurds and saving this small town from the nutters with the black flags fills our TV News every night. But in the 1920s Britain was happily bombing the Kurds for not paying their taxes quickly enough and Winston Churchill had to be held back from using chemical weapons against Kurdish civilians.

    Nothing in the hundred year history of this title place leads me to believe that continued bombing by the RAF is going to make things much better.

  • Eddie Sammon 12th Oct '14 - 11:46am

    Hi John, but we’ve had successful military operations in the past too. The police use force, so why is the military so much different? Having said that, I am interested in doing what we can to reduce civilian deaths. I don’t think these can be prevented 100%, but I’m not comfortable with what Israel did and just bombed civilian areas extensively, paralysing at least one child. However, it has to be said, that Churchill also did this during WW2. I am skeptical as how these help to win wars. Peace needs to be won by seeing to be fair, not through fear.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Roland
    Attach an Apple Air Tag to your sign, whilst it won’t stop the sign being removed, you stand a good chance of locating where it’s been taken to…...
  • John Marriott
    @Peter Martin Under PR I reckon that, with their current opinion poll rating of around 12%, the Lib Dems might expect to get around 78 seats at Westminster. @...
  • David Blake
    Many years ago, my girlfriend at the time was living in a flat owned by the local Conservatives. One weekend all the power went out. The fusebox was in the ba...
  • Tom Hannigan
    The 3 main parties in Ireland frequently nominate more than one candidate in our multi seat constituencies which can have 3,4 or 5 seats. It depends on what you...
  • Peter Martin
    @ Andrew, You seem to be somewhat contradictory on your "solidarity fund". Whatever you want to call it it will mean that if someone moves to Germany fro...