A letter from……Catalonia

As the UK plans a referendum on Scottish independence, those of us watching from Spain can only look on in envy at the orderly and civilised process led by the Secretary of State for Scotland. Here in Catalonia, Northern Spain, similar demand exists for an independent state, but the two sides have chosen indignation and confrontation instead of a serious debate.

The last two years have been tough for all EU governing parties and Spain has unique problems, with its sky-high unemployment levels, corruption and a rickety banking system. But this month Catalans will go to the polls in a general election called for entirely cynical reasons.

Catalonia is ruled by a Liberal Democrat sister party, Convergència Democràtica de Catalunya (who is in permanent coalition with Unió to form CiU). However, in its reaction to the economic crisis, the Catalan government has proved itself unworthy of the Liberal label.

While there is obviously an urgent need for public sector cuts in all regions of Spain, CiU has chosen to hit public health and education particularly hard. Meanwhile, one of its first acts when elected was to abolish inheritance tax, costing 102 million euros per year. CiU has time and again demonstrated its ‘true blue’ conservative instincts to entrench privilege for the rich.

The proposed independence referendum gives CiU the perfect excuse to deflect questions on its own record in government. President Artur Mas has been able to shed the image of a ruthless cutter and protector of privilege and present himself as the voice of a repressed nation. So far so cynical.

From Madrid we have a mixture of reactions. Some have chosen to stick their heads in the sand – a referendum of this nature isn’t permitted in the constitution and therefore cannot happen. Others have taken a hard-line approach, with sections of the army voicing their willingness to send in the troops if necessary. Neither reaction is helpful. In the long-term Spain cannot deny its people the right to self-determination.

Adding fuel to the fire is that in the Spanish government, run by the Partido Popular, we have the worst kind of unreconstructed right-wingers. The PP seems obsessed with trying to reverse the liberal reforms enacted by the previous Socialist government. While they just lost a case brought before the Constitutional Court to reverse right of gay couples to marry, they still have a change in the abortion law within their sights.

All this means there are few people making a positive case for Spain. While many Catalans have allowed themselves to get carried away with the idea that with independence all their problems would be solved, few cool heads are on hand to point out the economic and political risks inherent in such a move. Business leaders pointing out that an independent Catalonia, obsessed with authoritarian language politics, will be unattractive to foreign investment are largely ignored.

It’s sad to see Spain’s political class continuously failing to serve the interests of the people. Either they’re manipulating the hopes and fears of the voters to deflect attention from their own failings, or they are ducking difficult decisions that might actually do the country some good. I live in hope that we can emulate the Scottish desire to have a full debate on the real pros and cons of independence before a monumental and irreversible decision is taken.

* Martin Petts is a Liberal Democrat member living in Barcelona, Spain

Read more by or more about , , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Peter Harvey 14th Nov '12 - 12:28pm

    The whole debate overlooks one very important point. Independence for Catalonia or Scotland will mean leaving the EU and applying as a new member, and membership is by no means guaranteed as it must be approved unanimously. Spain will veto Scotland because of Catalonia and the Basque Country, anyone else might easily veto Catalonia, and anyway, accession of any new state requires a referendum in France. There is no doubt at all about this (see here: http://www.barder.com/3804) so it just won’t happen, however much Mas and Salmond huff and puff to thjeir respective voters.

    And, despite Catalan paranoia (eagerly fed by the financial markets) as in your quote, the days have long gone when a Spanish lieutenant-colonel could make a credible threat. It’s 30 years since Tejero tried and failed spectaculalry.

  • Helen Dudden 14th Nov '12 - 9:52pm

    As I go to the country on a regular basis, I understand the hardship and the need to have some stable situations. It is very easy to make comments, but all I hear, and see, is a country with problems that need to be resolved.

  • Tom Robinson 15th Nov '12 - 10:49am

    Peter Harvey. Scotland will not be removed from the EU as long as both Scotland and the majority of EU members wish it to be a member. That is the realpolitick of the matter.

    Everything else is unionist propaganda.

  • I applaud your criticism to the approach of the Spanish Gov. to the problem, but I’m afraid you’ve repeated two common insults the madrid press and politicians constantly throw our way:

    1: Easily-manipulated catalans want independence because they’ve been told it will magically fix every problem, forever:
    That independence will be very difficult, will be traumatic, and will be damaging in the short term is something we all are aware of. Every secessionist politician mentions that there will be difficulties to overcome, and that prosperity will take time and hard work, but the madrid press always chooses to omit that, reporting only the positive predictions giving an image of us wearing rose-tinted goggles. Fear not, we are not being sold magic fixes, we are being sold a promise of hardship and hope.

    2: The authoritarian Catalans want to force their language down everyone’s throats and eliminate Spanish:
    Well, one thing is true, we do want all of our public schools to be primarily in Catalan. Is that so strange? It’s our language. Spanish is also our language, but here, it’s secondary. I guess this is the unacceptable part. Spaniards cannot tolerate their language being second to a regional one that should by rights be a cute folkloric thing, instead of the main language. I’m primarily a Spanish speaker, so my first language is Spanish, and my second is Catalan. This does not present a conflict with the fact that the language of this place is Catalan. The use has been diluted by massive immigration encouraged by Franco, and the Catalan government has always aimed to reverse that trend, and make its knowledge and use universal again, but not exclusive. So far it’s being a success, and it has the overwhelming support of the majority of Catalans, those born here, those born outside, and the descendants of those born outside. This does not change the fact that we all know perfect Spanish, and once we’re independent our kids will continue to learn perfect Spanish, because it also is our language.

    When we hear news from madrid that range from claims that many of us don’t know spanish, to claims that kids who don’t speak catalan are not allowed to go to the toilet, we get pretty angry. What kind of people do you think we are? Well, you tell us every day. You think we are dumb, easily manipulated, selfish, neo-fascists. And you wonder why we want to leave.

  • James from Durham 15th Nov '12 - 4:05pm

    The EU will allow the accession of Catalonia and Scotland. Their narrative insists on bigger and deeper. A reduction in the EU would contradict that. If the French voted against, they would call another one in a few months until the “right” answer was obtained.

  • Tony Collins 15th Nov '12 - 6:12pm

    Peter Harvey- you are flat wrong I’m afraid, despite you saying “There is no doubt at all about this”. Scotland has been a member for 40 and will continue to be a member- there is no precedent for a country being ejected from the EU and I doubt very much the EU would in any way attempt to eject it’s largest oil and gas producer and a newly independent country which has stated its desire to work constructively with the EU in contrast to the obstinance of the remainder of the increasingly hostile and irrelevant England & others block. Use some logic before the ridiculous assertions please.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Steve Trevethan
    Might the root problems of yesterday’s childish and selfish behaviours be found in the extremely unsuited design of the House of Commons, the lout behaviour o...
  • Jeff
    expats 21st Feb '24 - 8:24am: I looked at the ‘trading giants’ listed… This makes my point perfectly. As with other Brexit benefits, the...
  • Neil Fawcett
    @Paul Barker - she clearly didn't hide them very well. Another member spotted that she had made some abhorrent posts on social media and put in a complaint. As ...
  • Nick Baird
    Imperfect as it is, our democracy is the sum of its parts, and one of those parts is Opposition Day debates. The second largest party gets 17 of those per parl...
  • Nigel Jones
    So good to have Layla representing us in Foreign Policy, especially on this issue. A pity she did not have time to say more, especially to put things in perspec...