Another day’s Labour for the Government

Hot on the heels of failing to kill the Government’s truly egregious Immigration Bill, which rolls out the Hostile Environment on an industrial scale, Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour party approaches the Brexit votes tonight in disarray.

But first, a reminder of last night.

I mean, really. A reminder of that happened. Labour were originally down to abstain but after cries of disbelief from senior Labour figures on Twitter, they decided to make it a one-line whip on Twitter. Hardly a face-saving exercise.

You might remember that Mr Corbyn has been loudly refusing to meet Theresa May unless she takes No Deal off the table.

So, when one of his own side comes up with an idea that would prevent us from leaving without a deal on 29th March, you would think he would support it. That was certainly the mood music over the weekend.

But no. The Guardian reports this morning that they are growing cold on that idea.

Opposition? Not so much. 

Every day, Corbyn finds a way to enable the excesses of the worst, most dangerous Government of my lifetime.

May’s Government has thrown its support behind the amendment which does away with the backstop completely and puts us outside the EU with no guarantee we’ll be able to honour our treaty obligations over the Irish border. Do they expect that unicorns will just turn up to patrol it?

Tonight’s votes are unlikely to make the way ahead that much clearer. I suspect our People’s Vote one won’t even get voted on. That would be the sensible thing if we can’t get it through.

But then, Parliament hasn’t been known for being sensible. There is, however, a majority of sensible people in there. Will they make that break and put country before party and get control of this process before it’s too late? I’m not holding my breath.

* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings

Read more by or more about , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Nonsense Caron, the mans a political genius, his apologists tell us that constantly. Why in an election his personality and backbone will shine through. I suspect they are wrong, his shiny newness is tarnished, his apologists are constantly on the back foot, twisting and turning to justify Labour’s last misstep under his leadership. Why even Owen Jones has chastised Labour

    The abstention has been dropped, and the Labour leadership are voting against the Immigration Bill and are committed to amend BUT it’s still a 1 line Whip; it should be a 3 line Whip. Labour have to follow their instincts and more passionately fight for migrants.

    Lord that must have hurt Jeremy and Co, tis the equivalent of being savaged by your pet gerbil.

  • Labour are a protectionist party. The unions will never tolerate open borders or job offshoring. “British jobs for British workers” remember – and that was in the days of Brown, let alone Miliband or Corbyn.

  • Bernard Aris 29th Jan '19 - 11:04am

    Labour is at the same time
    1) showing its glaring difference with the continental socialdemocratic tradition (which evolved fom moderately Marxist to Progressive-pargmatic), where belief in and fidelity to the EU always was strong. The homespun Fabian ideology of Labour (Fabius was a general waiting and waiting until an opportunity arose, like Corbyn on Brexit) never fitted in that tradition.

    2) but now Labour is, like its Danish counterpart (where Neil Kinnocks son and daughter-in-law are prominent) slipping into xenophobic populism with a leftist twist. Their (the Danes’) resistance to Nazi occupation a long forgotten memory.

    I am deeply disappointed in Staerner, who I just had grown to admire as the least wacky Labour front-bencher.

    Now give me Hillary Benn anytime!

  • Peter Martin 29th Jan '19 - 11:25am

    @ Bernard Aris,

    Why would you say the European Social Democrats are doing so badly?

    Is it the fault of the Social Democrats for losing the confidence of their erstwhile supporters?

    Or is it the fault of their former voters for not wanting what the Social Democrats say they should want?

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarGeorge Kendall 4th Jun - 9:23am
    I strongly agree with Tom Purvis. The election review warned that we talk about things that interest us, "at the expense of constantly thinking about...
  • User AvatarMatt (Bristol) 4th Jun - 9:01am
    Matthew Huntbach / James Fowler The idea of moving into the gap left by the Tories (which isn't imho a straight right/left issue) is problematised...
  • User AvatarMatt (Bristol) 4th Jun - 8:51am
    As much as I want eye-catching and coherent policies from a leader, I mainly want the nous to shape a party with a coherent ideology...
  • User AvatarJames Fowler 4th Jun - 8:42am
    @ Matthew - interesting points, thank you.
  • User AvatarFrank West 4th Jun - 8:01am
    If you are happy to pay UK income tax and capital gains on your overseas money then you should have the right to vote, if...
  • User AvatarChristopher Curtis 4th Jun - 8:00am
    I agree with these comments too. It’s vital that we choose a leader to do the job of leading the party, and performance in detailed,...