Author Archives: James Vincent

If – that awkward little notion

If Britain does undergo ‘hard Brexit’, what do we do next? If said ‘hard Brexit’ results in a consistent and high-reaching economic growth, what do we say? “Unlikely”, “highly implausible”, “outright impossible” might be the instinctive or well-thought through response of an expert (of the armchair or academic variety). But humour me. If something happens contrary to our expectations, how do we respond?

It’s a relevant topic, given the year we’ve had. The idea that the referendum would result in Brexit was surprising (though, for me personally, not shocking). The idea that Donald Trump would be elected President of the US really was shocking. In both cases, the presumption of many was that they could not lose; that a variety of factors and self-evident prepositions resulted in an inevitable conclusion. I do not want to raise here why your or my presumptions were right or wrong, but how we should respond when we are mistaken.

It seems to me that the underlying condition that arose in 2016 was how headstrong everyone became. Every political hue became convinced that everything they asserted was undeniable, unless you were a blithering idiot (or deplorable). Facts became relative, and forecasts became cast-iron; unless of course, I disagreed with them. When did we lose the respect for our rivals, saying “this is what I propose, but I accept you have an alternative”?

Posted in Op-eds | Tagged and | 11 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Carl Pierce
    When i was 12 years old - 49 years ago the teacher asked the class what one thing would you like to change ? When it was my turn i said bring in PR. My view ha...
  • Roland
    @Peter - I agree with your point which seems to apply to many sectors, especially those sectors that previously had been state controlled/owned eg. Energy, wate...
  • Chris Cory
    This article gives me real hope. So much of our politics is about winning. Beating the other lot because we all know that we have all the answers and they kno...
  • Robert Knight
    The statistic that you carefully avoided was the 22000 Iranian uranium centrifuges, the largest number manufactured and operated by any country, that have been ...
  • Alex Macfie
    @theakes: No, we didn't "win" under FPTP in 2024, we broke even (with a share of seats roughly equal to our share of the vote. Just because the system worked fo...