Author Archives: Jonathan Russell

The Independent View: A reformed Prevent could tackle extremism more effectively

The government’s counter-extremism strategy, Prevent, is often criticised. Some say it acts like a thought-police, criminalises Islam and over-securitises places like schools. Others claim there is not enough buy in from Muslim communities, that it funds non-violent Islamists to tackle jihadists, or that it is not the government’s job to challenge ideology. Neither criticism is absolutely fair, but as criticised as Prevent is, it undoubtedly serves an important function and is here to stay.

While all terrorists are extremists, the vast majority of extremists do not use terrorism as a viable strategy, and a liberal and democratic nation cannot and should not deal with all extremists in the same way as it deals with terrorists. But catching terrorists who “love death as you love life” is a difficult proposition for the police or the security services when they’re keen to go down fighting and cause as much destruction as possible while they do it. Only dealing with extremism once it becomes violent and illegal is a high stakes game where the penalty for losing is the death of large numbers of innocent civilians. Tackling extremism of all kinds before it becomes violent can reduce the civilian casualties, reduce the number of violent extremists that have to be dealt with, and has the secondary benefit of challenging non-violent behaviour that nonetheless has a negative impact on British society.

Posted in Op-eds and The Independent View | Tagged , and | 10 Comments

The Independent View: Positively fighting back online

Circuit Bending Orchestra: Lara Grant at Diana Eng's Fairytale FWith the seemingly endless news of global and domestic extremism –  whether about the 250 girls kidnapped in Nigeria, the 500 Britons reportedly waging jihad in Syria, or the worrying allegations made against several Birmingham schools – it is rare that a report devoted to countering extremism should fill us with positivity. However, research released last week by Quilliam about the state of online extremism should encourage us all, not …

Posted in Op-eds and The Independent View | Tagged , , , and | 3 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarJohn Barrett 27th Jan - 12:35pm
    A much smaller example of costs rising and the project being reduced in size was when Edinburgh decided to build a tram network at a...
  • User AvatarKatharine Pindar 27th Jan - 12:27pm
    Thanks, Jenny and John, but just a bit more on the Social Contract idea first. Philip Alston, the UN Rapporteur, wrote in his initial Statement...
  • User AvatarJohn Barrett 27th Jan - 12:18pm
    The time for a change in the law has arrived. I appreciate that there will be different requirements for different circumstances, but this should not...
  • User AvatarPeter Martin 27th Jan - 11:42am
    @ John Probert, Expensive housing isn't a phenomenon that's been imposed on us by forces beyond our control. As wages and salaries have risen it's...
  • User AvatarJohn Roffey 27th Jan - 11:21am
    Keir Starmer is pressing for a Federal UK: Keir Starmer: only a federal UK 'can repair shattered trust in politics' Labour leadership frontrunner calls for...
  • User AvatarNonconformistradical 27th Jan - 11:19am
    @Paul Murray I don't dispute the issue of liberty - however I do feel you are being complacent about the technology. The 3rd reference I...