Author Archives: Miranda Pinch

Opinion: Freedom of speech?

Southampton University is under attack: it is planning a conference on ‘International Law and the State of Israel: Legitimacy, Responsibility and Exceptionalism’  in April.  Paris University has been forced to cancel a conference entitled: ‘Israel Apartheid is real’.

I have recently attended two conferences on Islam, one of which also came under threat.

So when is free speech permissible and when not?

At my local university I have been shocked at the racist and Islamophobic comments made in talks and seminars by those who support Israel unreservedly.  Had I made similar comments about Jews and Judaism, I would have been thrown out.  Islam is no more homogenous than Judaism or Christianity  and the way it is practised is as much cultural, political and historical as any other. When I condemn Saudi Arabia or ISIS I am not condemning Islam as a whole, nor do I delegitimize Saudi as a State. On the contrary I am often defending Islam. When I criticise Israel, as a Jew myself, I am not attacking Judaism, I am criticising a regime that gives Judaism a bad name and when I criticise the USA, I am often criticising those who give Christianity a bad name.

Posted in Op-eds | Tagged | 24 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarDavid Raw 22nd Nov - 8:32pm
    Just watched Question Time. Oh, dear. I'm afraid it was a car crash.
  • User AvatarMartin 22nd Nov - 7:29pm
    Jayne Mansfield: You have misunderstood me. When I wrote "They do claim (in Fantasy Land as you put it) that they would negotiate a Brexit...
  • User AvatarRichard Underhill 22nd Nov - 6:56pm
    Naomi Long is the leader of the Alliance Party of Northern Ireland. She defeated the DUP leader in 2010, first past the post, and became...
  • User AvatarKevin Mahoney 22nd Nov - 6:09pm
    As one of the hopefully large number of people who are both Lib Dems and Doctor Who fans, I'd say that the ad is well-targeted.
  • User AvatarPeter Watson 22nd Nov - 5:33pm
    @Charles Pragnell "6.1 million signed the petition to revoke article fifty ... at least 5 million votes, more than 2 million polled in 2017" That's...
  • User Avatarnvelope2003 22nd Nov - 5:26pm
    £1.6 billion could buy quite a lot of improvements to the railways which would make them more attractive to the potential users. There are still...