Claire Tyler writes: Children need better access to mental health care

Mental health care in this country needs radical transformation.  Both adult and children’s mental health services continue to be plagued by long waiting times, lack of access to treatment and chronic staff shortages. For children, the average wait between their first symptoms developing and being able to access treatment is estimated to be a horrifying 10 years. Once a referral has been made, The Children’s Society estimate that young people wait an average of 58 days until they are assessed and then a further 41 days until they begin treatment. 

In a recent survey, a thousand GPs across the country expressed their concerns about access to Children’s Mental Health Services. It found that 78% of GPs are worried that too few of their young patients can get treatment for mental ill-health and a staggering 99% of them feared that under 18 years old will come to harm as a direct result of these delays in care. 

For many of these children, the only way to access the care they need is for their mental health to deteriorate to crisis point or to turn to private care. In fact, almost two-fifths of GPs surveyed said they would recommend patients whose families can afford it to go private. It is completely unacceptable that we have such a growing divide between those who can pay for treatment and others who are left waiting.  Seventy years after the creation of the NHS, families should not be forced to pay for the mental healthcare their children so desperately need.  

The publication of the NHS Long Term Plan has provided an important opportunity to hold the Government to account over mental health provision. Last week I led a debate in the Lords on children’s access to mental health treatment and also spoke in a wider debate on the Long Term Plan.  In both debates, I was clear that without urgent action to enlarge the workforce, as well as sustained investment in social care and public health, the Plan would be destined to fail. 

That is not to say there is nothing to welcome in the Long Term Plan. As well as a focus on prevention, it contains some ambitious aspirations for improving mental health services, including increased funding and a target of ensuring that one hundred per cent of children needing specialist mental health care are able to access it. These are clearly steps in the right direction.   What worries me is less what the Plan contains and more what it does not.

For example, the Plan contains precious little detail of how the NHS will recruit and retain a workforce large enough to deliver 100% access for children’s mental health services. It has been estimated that to treat all children and young people with mental health problems we would need over 20,000 additional staff. This will be a huge challenge, given that the workforce is shrinking – there are 6% less child and adolescent psychiatrists in the NHS than there were 4 years ago.  Factor Brexit into the equation and it becomes clear that there will need to be a huge effort to recruit the staff needed to transform services.

This is why I asked an oral question in the Lords this week on whether the Government would consider funding a mental health careers campaign aimed at secondary school, college and university students.  By showing students, particularly in related subjects such as psychology, that they can have fulfilling careers in mental health professions, we can help build the workforce and improve mental health treatment for all who need it. I was promised a written response which I eagerly anticipate – but frankly I’m not holding my breath! 

* Claire Tyler, Baroness Tyler of Enfield, has been in the House of Lords since 2011, taking an active role in the areas of health and social care, welfare reform, social mobility, well-being, children and family policy, machinery of government and the voluntary sector. She is the Liberal Democrat member of the Lords Select Committee on Social Mobility, and co-chair of the APPG on Social Mobility

Read more by or more about , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Sue Sutherland 10th Feb '19 - 1:14pm

    Can anyone tell me where psychotherapy and counselling fit into this plan? I think children who are just finding life too demanding, rather than having a specific mental health problem, need to be able to take advantage of these kinds of services. I’m thinking of young carers, for example, but there are other cases where children need this kind of help rather than psychiatry.

  • The most obvious steps which need to be taken to improve mental health are concerned with improving the lives of millions of people. We can start with making houses available to those who need them. We can ensure that we rapidly end poverty by paying a living wage. We can stop putting needless stress on children in schools by stopping meaningless testing of children and testing schools by a discredited Ofsted system.
    Some will cost money, some will save money.
    In other words we can recognise that prevention is better than cure. That does not mean that we ignore I’ll people, but that our priority should be to work with people to ensure that they don’t become ill.

  • Sue Sutherland 11th Feb '19 - 12:11pm

    Of course you are right Tom and David. Many years ago Margaret Thatcher suppressed the Black report which established a correlation between poor housing and physical ill health and now we have a government which couldn’t be doing better at causing mental health problems if it was their declared policy.
    No wonder people voted for Brexit in the belief it would make their lives better. I despair that our party hasn’t taken up the cause of the poorest in our society because many of the services that they rely on have been cut. Hatred and misery thrive when humans are competing for scarce resources which the poorest are having to do in our wealthy country in the 21st century. How can we stand by and let this happen?

  • Peter Hirst 11th Feb '19 - 4:57pm

    What we need is a completely new educational programme on the nature of thought and what a huge part it plays in our mental life.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Andrew Tampion
    Mr Chambers. Is that the best you can do? If so I think you're more likely to be a bot than me. Mr Macfie. I don't know how people will vote if there is a "Rej...
  • Alex Macfie
    @Andrew Tampion: I find the idea that voters would vote in line with the outcome of a previous vote extremely fanciful. I mean, does anyone seriously say they'r...
  • Zachary Adam Barker
    "Russia’s aggression was reckless and ultimately indefensible. But the West’s reneging on promises to halt eastward expansion of NATO in the wake of the col...
  • Peter Chambers
    @Andrew Tampion > To anticipate I assume you include the £350 Billion on a Bus. So the figure was £200 Billion or whatever. Do you really think that would...
  • Ex-LD Leeds
    Turkey was going to join the EU by 2020....