Coalition to rule out ‘pay as you throw’ waste charge – but why do they think it’s their job?

The Guardian reports:

Ministers are expected to announce that they are scrapping Labour plans to introduce “pay as you throw” rubbish schemes. Eric Pickles, the communities secretary, and Caroline Spelman, the environment secretary, will confirm that they will end schemes in which people are charged for household waste collections or for producing too much rubbish.

In one sense this is a bit of a non-story. Labour didn’t, despite the Guardian’s misleading report, plan to introduce ‘pay as you throw’ rubbish schemes – what they did was enable councils to pilot such schemes if they wished. Unsurprisingly, not least given the furore surrounding fortnightly landfill collections which had the Daily Mail foaming at the mouth a couple of years ago, no council decided to be the first to opt-in.

And there are of course many practical difficulties associated with ‘pay as you throw’ – fears of invasion of privacy, cost, increase in fly-tipping, etc. ‘Pay as you throw’ was a typically New Labour authoritarian measure. Credit where it’s due, the Tories’ preferred ‘recycling reward’ scheme, piloted by Windsor and Maidenhead council, in which residents are paid for boosting their home recycling seems to be a far more liberal (and successful) approach to reducing landfill.

My only problem is this: why does the government feel it’s any of their business to tell local authorities how to run their rubbish and recycling services? These are local council services, and responsibility should be left with them – if a council, whether Labour, Lib Dem or Tory, wants to try out ‘pay as you throw’ why should central government try and stop them? It’s a matter between the council and its residents, who have the power to mete out their punishment at the ballot box if they don’t like it.

Nick Clegg has commented that the Lib-Con coalition has found itself surprisingly united on the issue of ‘localism’ – placing local people more in control of their own lives. Yet the Tories persist with interfering in the basic services which councils run, and are standing by their poorly thought through pledge to freeze council tax – another assault on local councils to set budgets and run services as they wish rather than as Whitehall wishes.

As so often with the Tories, their localism is very surface, and seems to amount to little more than telling local authorities to copy the policies of Tory councils they approve of.

Read more by or more about , , , or .
This entry was posted in News.


  • Paul McKeown 7th Jun '10 - 10:43am

    The quickest was to reduce levels of household waste would be to force manufacturers and retailers not to sell products with unnecessary packaging.

  • Paul Griffiths 7th Jun '10 - 6:51pm

    Agree. Conservatives seem totally clueless when it comes to localism.

  • So why shouldn’t Local Authorities be able to choose their own voting systems. PR by STV in the UK was first introduced in a Private Bill – The Sligo Town Corporation Act of 1910.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Peter Martin
    @ Katharine, I'm sorry your thread was diverted on to internal issues of the Labour Party. For some strange reason Joe chose to dig up an obscure 80's SWP ar...
  • Peter Martin
    @ Joe, The BBC article doesn't get it right on Trotskyist entryism. Many people have joined the Party to promote Socialist policies which includes widespread...
  • Joseph Bourke
    Katharine, Ed Davey floated the idea of funding a universal basic income with coronavirus debt-for-shares plan last summer
  • Margaret
    @Paul Fisher As of July 2019 complaints and disciplinary matters have been in the hands of the new system. The English state and regional parties no longer hav...
  • Katharine Pindar
    Gentlemen, after these enjoyable excursions into the creditable history of the coalition government of the Second World War and the succeeding Attlee government...
Thu 11th Mar 2021