Dear Theresa, You’re either hopelessly out of touch or not being straight with us

On 19th October 2017, we received a letter from Theresa May, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, ahead of her meeting with the European Council as part of the UK’s Brexit negotiations. Given that she had taken the trouble to write to us, we thought it only polite to reply. This is our response.

Dear Theresa,

Thank you for your letter explaining what you are doing to secure the rights of European Union citizens living in the United Kingdom and of UK citizens living in other EU member states. We were relieved to hear that you are taking this issue so seriously. Because your actions and those of your government since the referendum in June 2016 have given a very different impression.

You say that the rights of EU and UK citizens are your first priority. This is reassuring. But it would be slightly more reassuring, we feel, if it had not taken you sixteen months to come to this conclusion. You have left three million EU citizens living in the UK and over a million UK citizens living elsewhere in the EU in a state of increasing anxiety. And you have done nothing.

The freedom of European Union citizens to live and work without hindrance in any of the twenty eight member states has been one of the most positive and profound impacts of our collective European endeavour. As a married couple of one British citizen (Simon) and one German national (Natalie), it has formed the bedrock of our shared life together. And of the future plans that now lie in tatters. And we are not alone.

The three million EU citizens living in the UK work hard, pay their taxes and contribute to our society. They are our doctors and our nurses. They are our office workers, our builders and our taxi drivers. They crew our fishing boats, they look after our elderly and, yes, they pick our strawberries. But your inaction has created a climate where they no longer feel welcome. Where they fear for their future.

And it is not just these individuals who are affected, Theresa. You have left their – often British – spouses, their children, their friends and their employers in a state of enduring limbo, too. Punctured with vile threats from various members of your government about complex registration procedures, loss of rights, compulsory fingerprinting, exorbitant fees and more. Oh, and with your Home Office writing to numerous EU citizens demanding that they make immediate preparations to leave the UK.

You could so easily have given reassurance to these people that their rights would be protected. Or at the very least that they were not about to be rounded up by the goon squad. But you chose not to. While our family and our friends have shown nothing but love, kindness and compassion, our government has done nothing. And for that, Theresa, we are afraid that we cannot forgive you.

You complain that your government has been accused of treating EU citizens living in the UK as ‘bargaining chips’ in your negotiations with the European Union. Yet it was Liam Fox, your very own Secretary of State for International Trade (and our constituency MP), who claimed that EU citizens in the UK are ‘one of our main cards’ in negotiating a Brexit deal. So please forgive us if we find your protestations somewhat disingenuous.

You also seem a little optimistic about the current status of the negotiations between the UK and the EU.

You imply in your letter that a formal agreement is almost complete, with only minor issues left to negotiate. But that is patently not true. You must surely recognise this. There is no agreement. And there is no immediate prospect of one.

So you are, in our view, either hopelessly out of touch with your own government or not being entirely straight with us. Or, quite possibly, both.

But let us be honest, Theresa. Your letter is not really aimed at us. You have not given a monkey’s about our rights until now. You have only written to us because the European Union is furious at your lack of action in this area and you are trying desperately to dig yourself out of the colossal Brexit black hole that you, David Davis, Liam Fox, Boris Johnson and others have created.

You are not ‘putting people first’, as you claim. You are putting your government first. You are putting yourself first. You are putting your party’s ideological loathing of all things European ahead of the future of your country and of those who have chosen to call it their home.

You are right that we are seeking certainty about the future. But the only certainty here is that you and your government have failed at every turn. And one letter is not going to change that.

Yours sincerely,

Natalie Fey & Simon Perks.

* Natalie Fey is a lecturer in chemistry at a Russell Group university. Simon Perks runs a specialist management consultancy practice. They have been married for 18 years and live in Somerset with Molly, their Labrador dog. You can find them on Twitter at @nataliefey_NLS and @simonperks respectively.

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

7 Comments

  • Michael Cole 23rd Oct '17 - 10:44am

    I shall be interested to see May’s reply (if any).

  • Richard Underhill 23rd Oct '17 - 11:09am

    We try to be careful about precision in language. So should you.
    As British citizens, born in the UK of British parents, my wife and I also became EU citizens, and regret that your decision to invoke Article 50 will strip us of rights that we treasure. Leave if you want to, but do not take us with you. If you wonder why the defeat in the 2016 referendum caused a widespread emotional reaction, this is part of why. We are not even bargaining chips.

  • I notice no condemnation of the EU for refusing to enter early talks along these lines. While I certainly sympathise with people stuck in in limbo and hope for a deal as soon as possible, the hypocrisy of just blaming the UK often leads to a shake of the head.

  • Nonconformistradical 23rd Oct '17 - 4:55pm

    “And given that it’s the UK that has got us into this position, I feel that it is incumbent on our government to at least try to sort things out.”

    Seconded

  • I agree with the piece above as it is terrible for everyone to see such poor attitudes and poor government in our country. The vast majority of UK citizens never, ever, thought our government could be so callous. But unfortunately the government’s replies to those seeking to stay in UK is typical of Tory government as we have seen before – because they cannot control themselves as you will see every week at PMQs. They really are the nasty party we always knew.
    Adversarial politics by Tories is shocking at the best of times but now it is aimed at our EU friends and pro-EU Brits alike. We feel as you do, we are in it with you, we want our pre-Brexit country back. May we say sorry to you. This is not UK, it’s Tories.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarGeoffrey Dron 18th Aug - 12:24am
    To get a GNU, needs a successful VONC against the current government. Getting even three Tory names to support the motion would be a major...
  • User AvatarChris Key 17th Aug - 10:17pm
    Simon Hebditch - superb analysis and totally agree about falling into a trap. We should have given the idea a circumspect welcome without committing to...
  • User AvatarJohn Marriott 17th Aug - 10:03pm
    @Dilettante Eye “Social disobedience”, “Civil Disorder”? Surely that could equally happen in a No Deal worst case scenario? And you know who would get the...
  • User AvatarChristian 17th Aug - 9:55pm
    Jo Swinson should double down now and call out Corbyn for not putting the country first. She should say his recklessness risks a damaging no...
  • User AvatarAndy 17th Aug - 9:43pm
    Jo Swinson has thrown a wrench in the works by challenging Corbyn to prove he's got the numbers, but can she show the votes for...
  • User AvatarRobin Bennett 17th Aug - 9:40pm
    This is a helpful article. I hope and pray for HK's status to remain undisturbed and, like David Warren, that democracy will spread into China....
Sun 18th Aug 2019
Sat 24th Aug 2019
Thu 29th Aug 2019
Mon 9th Sep 2019