Ed Davey on the Budget: British people need real change and fast

You can watch Ed Davey’s response to the Budget statement here. The full text is below. He wants to see more radical action to encourage growth and the most important thing is try to repair the damage brought about by Brexit. His main message is that we need some jam today and can’t wait another 5-10 years for it.

Here is his response in full:

It is always a pleasure to follow the Chair of the Treasury Committee, the hon. Member for Hackney South and Shoreditch (Dame Meg Hillier). I am glad she committed to looking at the devil in the detail of this Budget, because when one looks at the fine print there are quite a few things for her Committee to scrutinise. In particular, I hope that she will look at the very disappointing growth forecasts, because I think this Budget will be defined more by Labour’s red lines on Europe and the Conservatives’ Brexit red tape than by faster growth.

At the root of so much of what has gone wrong in our country—the cost of living crisis, higher taxes, broken public services, empty high streets, and the lack of jobs and opportunity—is the lack of economic growth. Our economy is being held back. British business is being held back. It is being held back above all by the terrible damage of the Conservatives’ Brexit deal: a deal, let us never forget, that was backed by the leader of Reform and voted for by Labour—a deal that put up pointless new barriers to trade, tied up British firms in extra costs and red tape, and pushed up prices on our supermarket shelves.

As I was saying, our economy is being held back by Brexit, so the biggest single thing the Government could do to fix our economy is to fix our trading relationship with Europe and take us back into the single market and a customs union, giving us the growth and the money to cut people’s taxes.

Unless and until a Government have the courage to do just what I have outlined, I am afraid that any Budget will only be tinkering around the edges, because it will not provide the growth our country so desperately needs.

The Prime Minister, to be fair, has rightly talked about the economic damage caused by Brexit, but in answer to my questions he still refuses to drop Labour’s red lines set down by Keir Starmer more than five years ago. The world has changed so much since then and it is long past time that Labour policy changed with the world. I welcome the Prime Minister talking more openly this week about the need to move forward on Europe, but can I say to the Chancellor and the Prime Minister that it is just too urgent to wait until the next Parliament? Today’s Budget shows why.

I remember when 2% growth was nothing special. When we were in government that was the average, but since we left the EU, it has been less than half that—less than 1% growth a year. Today’s forecasts show things starting slowly to move in the right direction, but they still show growth well below 2% every year for the next five years. What used to be average growth now feels like a pipe dream, so we need a real growth plan with Europe at its heart: a plan that only our party has set out—an economic plan to make Britain richer, safer and stronger.

Our plan would also tackle one of the great hidden tax injustices not just of this Budget, but of every Conservative and Labour Budget since 2021: frozen income tax thresholds. They are a stealth tax rise that has dragged millions of the lowest paid into paying income tax and millions of ordinary people—nurses, teachers, police officers—into the higher 40p tax band. Millions are paying higher taxes for the cost of Government economic failure. I have to say to the Chancellor that this Budget, which freezes the income tax allowance of people in work while raising the personal allowance for some pensioners, is not the answer. Income tax thresholds should rise for everyone—the fairest tax cut possible—letting people keep more of what they earn, rewarding hard work and giving individuals more power in our economy. That is a profoundly Liberal thing to do. If we grow the economy by trading more with Europe, we can afford to do that—a real plan to turn the economy around and cut taxes fairly.

Our plan would also tackle one of the biggest headaches the Chancellor is facing in this Budget: the cost of Government borrowing. We clearly cannot go on spending £1 in every £12 just on interest payments on the national debt. That is money that should be going on schools, on hospitals, or back into people’s pockets. We just cannot go on with the Government borrowing money at interest rates of over 5%. Some of the cost is down to global factors, as the Chancellor talked about, and a lot of it is down to Donald Trump’s war with Iran, but there is no doubt that the bond markets would look more favourably on the UK if our growth prospects were better. Just as for growing the economy, the single biggest thing the Government could do to cut their own borrowing costs, and the interest rates faced by homeowners and businesses, would be to take up our growth plan, and join the single market and customs union.

Just look at the alternative put forward by the terrible twins of British politics, the Conservatives and Reform. They are in a bidding war of unfunded fantasy promises. We have seen where that sort of fiscal irresponsibility ends; Liz Truss’s mini-Budget sent mortgage rates rising. Yet now we face the threat of a Tory-Reform Government doing it all over again. The British people simply cannot afford that.

That brings me back to the cost of living. Why are so many bills going up again? Because Donald Trump chose to start his idiotic war with Iran, which has pushed up our energy bills and hiked diesel and petrol prices to painful levels. When that war began, the Conservatives and Reform were lining up to say that Britain should be backing President Trump. Just imagine if they had been in charge. We would have been dragged into fighting a war that no one wants and paying for it with even higher bills and higher taxes. Britain needs a Government who stand up for British interests, not one who make us ever more dependent on an unreliable, out-of-control American President.

With Donald Trump pushing up petrol and diesel prices, the Chancellor’s freeze on fuel duty is welcome, but it is not enough. I urge him to look again at our emergency transport package, which would cut prices at the pumps by 12p a litre and bring down the cost of travel by bus, train and electric vehicle, too—a real breathing space for families and businesses. With energy bills forecast to rise by more than 25% in January, the Chancellor’s promise to break the link between gas prices and electricity bills cannot come soon enough, but he is right to reject the siren song from those on the Conservative and Reform Benches who want Britain to be even more dependent on dirty fossil fuels and their volatile prices. Once again, they are copying Donald Trump, and their energy plan would be a disaster for our environment, our economy and for everyone struggling with the cost of living. The right answer is to invest instead in clean home-grown renewable power, energy efficiency and battery storage, so that the prices we pay do not depend on Trump’s latest Truth Social post, but instead come down quickly as technology continues to slash the cost of renewable energy and of batteries.

In a world where Trump is deserting Ukraine, praising Putin and selling out on European security, we must move far more quickly on defence. When the Defence Secretary says we must be ready for war within 1,000 days, our armed forces cannot wait years for the investment they desperately need now. The Chancellor’s announcement of some extra funding is welcome as far as it goes, but why has he not taken up our plan for defence bonds to invest £20 billion in Britain’s defence over the next two years? And since he has ruled out joining Canada’s defence bank, will he now take up our plan and push for a European rearmament bank that goes so much further than what he announced today? Instead of signing up to one country’s version, surely the right answer is to bring our allies together behind a shared vision of defence investment to protect our continent from Putin.

The defence of our country needs serious answers like these, not fantasy pledges like the Conservatives’ “iron dome”, which they say is not an iron dome—except when it is. What a shambles! No wonder they left Britain’s armed forces in such a mess, something for which they have not yet apologised.

It will not surprise the House to hear that we on the Liberal Democrat Benches are delighted to hear talk of fiscal devolution. Taking money and power out of a few hands in Whitehall and giving it to communities to make their own decisions is something that we, as Liberals, have always championed.

There is a right way to do devolution and a wrong way, so we will have three tests for the Government’s plan as it develops. First, does it give councils enough money to fulfil the responsibilities they are being given? Secondly, does it reach beyond mayors to councils and communities everywhere? Thirdly, is it fair, so that those areas that are already struggling do not find themselves with even less? Done properly, this could be the start of something really big; done badly, it is simply passing the buck.

The same goes for welfare reform. Of course it needs to be done, but it needs to be done right: cutting the bill by helping people into work and giving people the care and support they need so that they can work, like fixing carer’s allowance to help people juggle care with work. I am glad that the Chancellor has listened to carers on the need to scrap the unfair cliff edge of carer’s allowance. As I said to the Prime Minister earlier, this cannot wait another four years, and we cannot see a 100% tax rate on working carers. I urge the Chancellor and the Prime Minister to look at our alternative plan instead, which we put forward to Liz Sayce when she did her review. I hope to bring it to the meeting that the Prime Minister has promised.

Whether on carer’s allowance or other benefits, let us reform welfare right, so that the system helps people into work and then rewards them for working. The country needs this new Chancellor and Prime Minister to succeed, because the livelihoods of everyone in our country are at stake. The Liberal Democrats will work constructively with the Government wherever we can. We will oppose them when they get things wrong, of course, but we will also support them when they get things right and push them to go further when they are too timid.

In that spirit, I say to the Chancellor that this Budget is far too timid. The Government have recognised the scale of the challenge, but like Keir Starmer before them, they still have not risen to it. They have not fixed the terrible damage that they did with their tax rises, from the family farm tax to the jobs tax. I urge them to be bolder—be bolder on energy and defence; be bolder on devolution, and get it right; be bolder on cutting income tax; and be bolder on Europe and growth—because after so many years of pain, so many years of being held back, the British people need real change, and fast.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

17 Comments

  • Big Tall Tim 28th Oct '26 - 11:32pm

    Excellent stuff Ed. Very well said

  • Mick Taylor 29th Oct '26 - 7:17am

    OK, as far as it goes, but it would be better if it stopped pretending that Neo-Liberal economics à la Thatcher is correct.
    We’re not facing bankruptcy, haven’t maxed out a theoretical credit card and pursuing a growth agenda, will destroy the planet. No country issuing its own currency can go broke. Inflation has to be controlled, but the fantasy that that the budget of UK plc is like a household is nonsense. No household issues its own currency.
    We could remove a most tax exemptions and collect due tax. UK citizens should be liable for tax, wherever they live (as in the US) minus any proven taxes paid elsewhere and UK citizenship could be dependent on meeting tax liabilities. People have every right to leave the UK permanently, but they should pay an exit tax as some countries already provide for.
    Ed is half right on welfare, but it’s high time we reminded voters that apart from pensioners (who have paid for pensions) many on welfare are there temporarily and have paid in before drawing out. At least some on benefits are unable to work and many NEETS and others are not working because of AI and the changeover to more automation. There is plenty of work that could and should be done, though much of it is not because it is hard and low paid. Examples include care, seasonal farm work and the NHS. With an ageing population this will only increase.

  • Jenny Barnes 29th Oct '26 - 7:28am

    Today’s pensions are paid from today’s taxes.

  • Jenny Barnes 29th Oct '26 - 7:30am

    2% pa growth needs 2%pa increase in energy use: doubling every 35 years…

  • If we are going to link citizenship to taxes, I would also link benefit entitlement to citizenship. If you are not a British Citizen then you don’t get benefits. Migrants are welcome so long as they are completely self sufficient.

    Poll after Poll shows that voters of all parties think that Immigration (voters say it is too high) and Welfare (voters say it is too high) both need to come down.

    Failure to listen to the voters led to Brexit.

  • Jason Connor 29th Oct '26 - 9:16am

    Partly but Brexit also came about as many towns and areas were left behind and lacked inward investment or regeneration. Or there was a perception despite the ESF.

    Pensioners have already paid taxes when of working age.
    Whereas also agreeing with Mick Taylor, there is much in Ed Davey’s speech I can agree with except the obsession with the Tories and Reform. I don’t see them forming a coalition as two distinct parties. Unless it’s a scare tactic to warn off Tory voters returning to the fold in Lib Dem gained seats. I would like to see more of an offer in labour facing seats.

  • Tristan Ward 29th Oct '26 - 10:58am

    I don’t see [the Tories/Reform] forming a coalition as two distinct parties”

    I think this is clearly wrong I’m afraid.

    Consider:
    Much of the right wing press calling for “the Right to unite”
    Both groups want to the UK to with drawn form the ECHR
    Both groups want to do away with “net zero” which they consider “woke”
    Both groups attack on welfare
    Both groups refusal to have nothing to do with the European Union
    Both group’s knee jerk support for Trump’s war in Iran

    “I would like to see more of an offer in labour facing seats.”

    Why would proper reform of welfare, getting closer to the EU, proper defence of the country, growth and paying down of the national debt not be welcome in Labour facing seats?

  • An appalling budget.
    Defence should be front and centre, without that everything else sinks into irrelevance.
    Healey should resign, Burnham needs to get some bottle and the Chair of the house of commons defence committee deserves a knighthood for his letter last night on behalf of the all party Defence Committee.

  • @slamdac. The vast majority of non UK or commonwealth citizens cannot claim benefits now, so your statement repeats the lies told by the right.
    We do really have to stop demonising or othering migrants and people on welfare. Of course we should aim for everyone able to work to have a job. That will sometimes mean jobs on the frontline of public services, though ideally the private sector should help too.
    Providing work is cheaper in the long run than paying people to be idle, because people who work pay taxes

  • @Mick They are not British Citizens, ultimately the UK government’s primary responsibilities is to British Citizens. That is the whole point of a nation state.

    Foreign nationals can have their interests promoted and protected by their own government. It is not the UK taxpayer’s responsibility to subsidies people who choose to move to this country.

  • Where is the money for defence. It is an abdication of responsibility.
    Will the Government and some in this party face up to reality of the present time, guns come way before butter.

  • Jason Connor 29th Oct '26 - 3:13pm

    What evidence do you have from both those parties individually that they would join a coalition? I haven’t seen any and I wouldn’t believe everything you read in the press.
    Far better to concentrate on positive policies that appeal to people than scaremongering.

    But as I said on the whole I agree with much of Ed Davey’s speech. Many of us have said on here before, Lib Dems put very little effort and resources into winning seats in Labour held areas; much of this territory has gone to the Greens. Proper reform of welfare and paying down the national debt sound ominous to me.

  • Mick is correct that no country issuing its own currency can go broke. However, a problem can arise if a country can no longer borrow in its own currency, but instead starts to borrow in dollars or euros.

    With the decline in manufacturing, the UK has had a current account deficit every year since 1984. Ultimately foreign investors may doubt our ability to repay our debts.

    There is an article of mine on this website “The UK Takeover Laws and Short-termism” of 26 August 2014.

  • @ John,

    “a problem can arise if a country can no longer borrow in its own currency, but instead starts to borrow in dollars or euros.”

    A country which issues its own currency can always borrow in its own currency. The UK can always borrow in pounds. The lender of last resort will effectively be the BoE. This is where the money came from to help us recover from the 2008 crash and the Covid pandemic. The usual mechanism, however, is to increase interest rates if we want others to lend us more. This may involve holders of dollars and euros lending us their money but the loans themselves will nearly always be denominated in pounds. If so, there is never a concern that debts will involuntarily be reneged upon.

    This inflow of overseas money does, however, cause the pound to rise in value and it is this that leads to a deficit in our current account. The more the pound appreciates, the more imports we can afford.

  • Mick Taylor 29th Oct '26 - 8:22pm

    @Slamdac. Perhaps you should read what I said! UK and commonwealth citizens are the only people who can claim benefits, with a few exceptions. So it’s simply not true, as the Tories and Reform suggest (and you too it seems) that immigrants come here to go on benefits. The truth is that people come to the UK for two reasons. They come to seek asylum from persecution (and many of them go home when it stops e.g the former Yugoslavia) or they come here to work , usually doing the jobs that UK citizens won’t do.
    As Liberals we should not be demonising asylum seekers, immigrants or those on benefits and certainly not boosting the lies told by the right (and certain people who claim to be on the left).

  • @Mick I don’t think its right that Commonwealth Citizens can claim benefits.

    You have highlighted one of the problems of immigration. In my opinion there is nothing progressive or Liberal by allowing Employers to keep wages and working conditions lower in the knowledge that they can import workers who will tolerate the conditions that British Workers won’t.

    Strong border controls, coupled with strong welfare reform, and enhanced employment rights will force employers to raise conditions, whilst forcing people who can work into the workforce. Again there in my opinion, there is nothing liberal or progressive in allowing people to opt out of the word of work and just rot on the scrapheap.

  • @ Jenny Barnes,

    “Today’s pensions are paid from today’s taxes.”

    Not if we think about the contributions that previous workers have provided to the present day economy. A teacher will have taught children who now be using their education in making for a more productive economy. A builder will have built homes for younger occupants to live in. A civil engineer will have built the motorways and bridges we are still using years later.

    There is more to economics than the flow of money. The way to pay for future pensions is to build a healthy economy and keep a healthy environment for the use and benefit of future generations. Not to provide the money per se. Govts can always create as much money as they choose. The difficulty is to ensure that it will buy something useful.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Jana
    @Jason Connor “.. is disrespectful to the victims….” I’m not surprised you believe that the musician should be facing consequences even before his...
  • Simon Robinson
    @David Evans: You seem to be saying I should change my mind on the basis of figures you quote that show much bigger fines imposed by the EU than by the UK. But ...
  • David Warren
    How would you improve communications with members who don't hold any office in the party but campaign on its behalf? This year I have made hundreds of calls ...
  • Jason Connor
    If a police officer were to face serious allegations of sexual assault they would most likely be suspended from duty or put on garden leave pending an investiga...
  • Cj Williams
    David Evans. You don't need to chuckle. I agree with you. The people of Europe have voted for Govt's that have legislated to constrain the research and develope...