Polls Apart: The dehumanisation of Palestinians

I wrote this as Israel went to the polls. It could be weeks before any result because Israeli elections are extremely complicated and depend on coalitions. The one certainty is that little will change for the Palestinians. No candidates are interested in Palestinian self-determination, and all support the illegal settlements.

The West Bank was locked down to ensure free movement and security for Israelis to vote. That prevents the Palestinians from moving from their Israeli designated areas for school, work, medical aid, anything. Israel locks the West Bank down for various reasons at will.

The West Bank including East Jerusalem is occupied territory, illegal under international law. Various statements from Israeli politicians call for the Gazification of Palestinian areas of the West Bank (total destruction) and the Judaization of all the land including Israel itself where twenty percent of the population are Palestinian ‘citizens’ of Israel. Those ‘citizens’ already live under Israel’s Jewish Nation-State Law, which only gives the right of self-determination to Jews. Hardly democratic.

Even the BBC, which has been credibly accused of pro-Israeli bias, documents the illegal Israel settler terrorism, supported by the Israeli army (IDF), who also kill, maim, imprison, and demolish. Ethnic cleansing is an Israeli policy, not just that of rogue settlers.

There is something particularly visceral about the destruction of ancient olive groves and vineyards. The damage caused to land that Israelis claim to love, designed to make it so inhospitable to Palestinians that they leave can also be described as ecocide, destroying native flora and fauna.

I wrote a review of the film NAZA, whose title is Israeli shorthand for “collateral damage” (the number of non-combatants that can legitimately be killed for any suspect). So, one Naza can mean a baby and two hundred Naza can mean the population of a neighbourhood or tower block. It is now showing on general release and will be available for streaming by the Guardian in late November.

The film is about the dehumanization of a population. If people are not human and all propaganda just portrays them as a threat to Israel’s existence, then the idea that they can be exterminated is ‘understandable.’ Some may object to terms like ‘extermination’ and ‘genocide’ as reminiscent of the Nazis, yet my mother equated the treatment of Palestinians to her treatment at their hands well before she died in 2008. Long before October 7th.

NAZA is also shocking for its juxtaposition of Tel Aviv opulence with the destruction in Gaza and the cold, calculating methods for killing Palestinians, and the purposeful erasure of Palestinian history and culture through the destruction of whole neighbourhoods and even seed banks, archives, libraries, municipal records, and cultural heritage sites.

Did you know that Israel does not allow basic commodities like toilet seats, tents, water purifiers, food items, cancer treatment, educational supplies, basic hygiene supplies, and much more into Gaza because they could all be considered ‘dual use’? Does that also make air and water ‘dual use’? Where does that end?

As Einat Temkin, an Israeli Jew who served in the IDF, pointed out in a recent Facebook post, ‘at least 31 human beings were killed by the IDF in Gaza in the past week, mostly civilians, including 7 children, without any consequences or accountability. By comparison, following the killing of two IDF soldiers by Palestinian resistance fighters near Hebron on Friday, the entire city is now under attack, with houses demolished, IDF forces invading and thousands of human beings forcibly displaced from their homes and dispossessed. The two Palestinian shooters responsible for killing the IDF soldiers – by international law considered legitimate military targets – were immediately eliminated.’

Responding to the escalation, leading Israeli human rights group B’Tselem called for “urgent action” from international actors “to prevent the forcible displacement of Palestinian civilians, collective punishment and extensive unlawful destruction in Hebron.”

Hand wringing, words of condemnation and threats are not enough. The world needs to stop Israel before it is too late.

Consider this: if Israel has nothing to hide and its behaviour is in any way legitimate, why does the government refuse all independent journalistic investigation into the events of October 7 and its actions since?

A recent report by UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese describes “mediacide”: the systematic destruction of the media’s ability to document and expose Israel’s atrocities in Gaza. The report examines how the killing and silencing of Palestinian journalists, Israeli censorship and propaganda, and biased international media coverage have not merely accompanied genocide but have facilitated its commission and obstructed accountability.

For this alone, Israel, not just its settlements, is culpable and should be sanctioned. You would think that we have already seen cruelty beyond any reason, yet we are still listening to Israeli justifications for anything and everything. It is time, beyond time, we demanded full open accountability.

* Miranda Pinch is a member of the Winchester local party and Communications Lead for the Lib Dem Friends of Palestine and has been a regular visitor to Palestine and Israel for many years. She is also part of the 'Holocaust survivors and descendants against the Gaza genocide' network.

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

10 Comments

  • Katharine Pindar 29th Oct '26 - 3:07pm

    Truly sorrowful reading, Miranda. Thank you for this. Our Foreign Affairs spokesperson must please continue demanding condemnation of continuing killing in Gaza and the West Bank and further sanctions against Israel, unless a new government promises better treatment of the Palestinians. Hopefully the larger Arab/Israeli successes in the Election may yet allow them some influence.

  • Simon McGrath 29th Oct '26 - 5:27pm

    “ Even the BBC, which has been credibly accused of pro-Israeli bias“
    You may have missed their recent payment of £400k to a producer who was discriminated against for being Jewish

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/crwydxw0we8yo
    And talking of elections , perhaps you missed that those for Palestinians have yet again been cancelled https://www.gov.uk/government/news/joint-statement-on-the-postponement-of-palestinian-elections

  • Miranda Pinch 29th Oct '26 - 7:06pm

    Simon, you give a strange example re the BBC. Not only irrelevant to my point, but one swallow does not make a Summer and I do try to keep Israeli policies distinct from Judaism as I think equating them is the greatest antisemitism.
    As to your point about elections. I think it is quite difficult for any country under occupation, ethnic cleansing Israeli settler and army terrorism and not allowed freedom of movement or freedom of association between East Jerusalem, the rest of the West Bank and Gaza, not to mention all the dangers for Palestinians, to have any sort of a proper free and fair election. Don’t you?

  • @Simon McGrath 29th Oct ’26 – 5:27pm..
    Deliberately avoiding the points raised in the article by implying equivalence of BBC coverage and ignoring the condemnation of Israel’s actions* in preventing meaningful Palestinian elections (mentioned in your link) .
    You also ignore the state sponsored attacks on Arabs trying to harvest their olives, etc., the NAZA expose’, The collective punishments in Hebron.. The list goes on.

    *..We reiterate our call on Israel to refrain from actions that could impede the conduct of elections, including the practical arrangements necessary for all Palestinians to participate…

  • Israel threatens and intimidates all those who are trying to vote in Jerusalem. Unless international forces go over and force Israel to behave there will be no Palestinian elections. It’s Israel and it’s occupation that is stopping democracy for Palestinians because it believes that it owns the whole land. Palestinians refused to vote unless all of them can vote. The propaganda protecting the brutal occupation is extremely disturbing for those of us who believe in fair elections.

  • Even Miranda’s extensive catalogue of the ways Palestinians suffer under Israeli occupation can’t include everything, and one fundamental fact remains too often unspoken: when a country is being invaded and colonised, those who try to oppose the aggressor are usually called ‘the resistance’. That word was used during the German invasions of France, Italy and Greece, but it is convenient for the hawks in the Israeli government to refer to those in the resistance movement in Gaza and the West Bank as ‘terrorists’.
    This reverses the roles of the combatants, making the Palestinians the aggressors and the Israeli invaders the victims. Politicians the world over are suckered into this inversion of reality, but no intelligent person should be taken in by it.

  • We have yet to see whether Netanyahu is actually removed from power, and whether, if he is, anything much will change.
    As Miranda has said, Israel should be sanctioned, and that should mean harsh measures like banning all trade, not just a little bit of tinkering with imports from illegal settlements.
    The only way to make Israelis realise we mean business is to hit the Israeli economy so hard that they can’t ignore us. When we say the ethnic cleansing of Palestine is “illegal under international law” we should be willing to back that up with action. Too many politicians think their obligation under those laws can be fulfilled by saying something guardedly critical of the Israeli government, and then going back to sleep. It can’t. The Palestinians are still being killed and being robbed of their land on a daily basis under the Occupation.

  • The Arab parties (Joint List + Ra’am) have 19 seats.

    Do none of these members support the illegal settlements. Are none of them interested in Palestinian self-determination ?

  • Miranda Pinch 30th Oct '26 - 4:59pm

    Andrew. Yes they do believe those things, but if they could be considered at all to make up an Israeli government, then they will have to compromise a very great deal. No one will accept them if they insist on very much sadly. At the moment the main parties refuse to include them at all. If they do compromise enough to get a foothold, then maybe eventually they could help soften things for the Palestinians, but it would be a long road even then.

  • For those who haven’t yet seen Naza (spoiler alert), there’s a superficially jarring insertion halfway through of an old TV clip of an interview with a (surprisingly handsome) young man who was asked to define terrorism. He said it was the intention to kill or maim civilians. In the context of the testimony which makes up the bulk of the film, from those who arranged the IDF targeting in Gaza, it seems unlikely that anyone in the Watershed in Bristol with me this afternoon failed to realise that the fresh-faced young Benjamin Netanyahu was sending a message to himself in the future, a message which said “you will become the problem; terrorism can be carried out by a state, if deliberately and knowingly killing civilians is what it does”.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

This post has pre moderation enabled, please be patient whilst waiting for it to be manually reviewed. Liberal Democrat Voice is made up of volunteers who keep the site running in their free time.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • David Evans
    Cj asks a very profound question - "How much money is that worth?" Bypassing the choice of money to determine how much something is worth - it could be wider...
  • Cj Williams
    Shared sovereignty diminishes the power of the people to hold those that rule to account. How much money is that worth?...
  • Stewart Edge
    Well said Dave Allen 15th Nov 11:41pm. 'Burnham and Milburn are genuinely trying to tackle this problem. The Tories didn’t. Starmer didn’t. The Lib Dems se...
  • David Evans
    The simple fact that we as a party have to face (and particularly those of us who are in what I will call the massively optimistic internationalist group) is th...
  • Matt (Bristol)
    In view of 17 year olds being able to attend University in Scotland (among other factors), I think there are practical barriers to implementation of a hard-18 t...