For the vast majority of people across the United Kingdom, this year’s Budget may as well not have happened.
After working through the Chancellor’s announcements and examining the practical impact on household finances, it is striking how little has changed for ordinary working people. For many families, the only noticeable measures are a £100 payment for households in Council Tax bands A to D and the abolition of gas standing charges.
Neither measure addresses the deeper challenges facing normal people.
The £100 payment is welcome as far as it goes, but it barely touches the sides of the ongoing cost-of-living pressures that households face. Energy bills, housing costs, food prices and transport expenses remain significantly higher than they were only a few years ago. A one-off payment offers temporary relief but does nothing to improve long-term living standards.
Meanwhile, the abolition of gas standing charges has been presented as a significant intervention. Yet this measure deserves closer scrutiny. Standing charges exist to recover fixed costs within the energy system. Removing them does not make those costs disappear. Instead, the cost is likely to be recovered elsewhere, most probably through higher unit charges. For a vast majority of households, this is less a case of eliminating costs and more a case of shifting how those costs are paid.
The real disappointment is that the Budget represents a missed opportunity to address the growing burden on working-age taxpayers and younger generations.
If the government was serious about making Britain fairer, it should have focused on reducing the tax burden on earned income. Three changes in particular would have provided meaningful support to millions of workers.
First, the personal allowance should have been increased. Years of fiscal drag have seen more and more people pulled into paying tax even when their real purchasing power has barely improved, in many cases it has retreated slowly. Raising the personal allowance would have allowed low- and middle-income earners to keep more of what they earn and would have provided support across the income spectrum.
Second, the threshold at which the higher rate of income tax becomes payable should have been increased, at least regionally. In London a normal classroom teacher with 5 years of experience is paid above the threshold for higher rate tax. This increasingly pervasive fiscal drag is meaning that working people are increasingly being dragged into higher tax bands never designed for them.
Third, the government should have increased the earnings threshold at which student loan repayments begin. Similarly to tax thresholds, graduates are increasingly being dragged into paying ever larger amounts of a relatively modest income in student loan payments. This money would be disproportionately spent better by young graduates than by the government.
Graduates already face a substantial effective tax rate through the student loan system. Many younger workers find themselves paying income tax, National Insurance and student loan deductions before they have even begun to build savings or get onto the housing ladder.
All of these compound together alongside the frankly irresponsible increasing of housing demand by the government’s new housing ISA to create a fiscally intolerable situation for the engine room of our national economy.
For millions of young and working people, the people who drive the UK economy, this Budget was one of managed decline rather than ambition. Labour must do better.
* Callum Robertson is a teacher and member of the Federal Board. He is a Watford Borough Councillor.



14 Comments
“ If the government was serious about making Britain fairer, it should have focused on reducing the tax burden on earned income”
Absolutely spot on. People should always feel that they and their families will be financially better off by working for a living than by living on benefits. For some low income earners who pay income tax, that is not the case.
Callum Robertson’s comments are spot on , though a little bit skewed towards those whose great fortune is to be young. But I do wish Liberals would stop using the phrase “tax burden.” Taxation is not a burden: it is the subscription we pay for living in a civilised and organised community. You might even call it a privilege.
@ Peter Wrigley Well said, Peter. Amen to that.
I disagree on the personal allowance. It has risen massively before the current freeze, and far exceeds the tax free allowance of most comparable nations. Income taxes on lower to average earners are now the lowest they’ve been in generations, meaning we’re heading to point where nearly 70% are net recipients of government spending.
If there’s an allowance that should be raised, that would be the 40% higher rate. This was intended for the top 5% of earners. Instead, it will potentially hit nearly half of full-time workers by 2031, many of whom will also be suffering the 9% graduate loan deductions.
@ Callum,
“The real disappointment is that the Budget represents a missed opportunity to address the growing burden on working-age taxpayers and younger generations.”
I’m unfortunately no longer a member of the younger generation but I do sympathise with this argument. I do wince when I read that ‘we’ should all pay more tax when what is really meant is that the younger generation should pay more tax. The balance has shifted over the years. When I was a member I would say that we were only slightly better off then the previous generation, who in their later years, could be described as the WW2 generation.
They in turn would have been a better off than the previous WW1 generation.
It’s the other way around now. Certainly I’m better off in my latter years than any of my three offspring. They have a larger income than myself but they have mortgages (or rents) and family responsibilities that I don’t. I’ve paid off my house.
So I would say that the idea that elderly people are likely to be not too well off is probably outdated. Of course some are struggling but so are many younger people. Yet we can get help, that they can’t, with energy bills, TV licences, free bus passes, cheaper train tickets and even discounted tickets at football matches! Thanks, I’ll take the help if it is offered but I my kids need it more than I do.
@Peter Wrigley
“ But I do wish Liberals would stop using the phrase “tax burden.”
I disagree with you on this. When I see how much I have to pay in Council Tax each month using the salary I get after already paying a whack of Income Tax and National Insurance, I feel that I am being forced to pay money in taxes that I really need to pay my own bills. Maybe taxation, itself, can be viewed as a membership subscription to be part of a civilised society, but the level of taxation is – without doubt – a burden.
@Jana. OK, so what services are you going to cut to get taxes down? We are being told we must pay MUCH MORE for defence. Are you going to cut education , NHS, care, transport, housing, local council services? If you say cut welfare, please specify exactly how you’re going to do it. Oh, it’s not so easy is it?
@ Mick,
We could look at taxes on wealth instead of cutting spending. It’s hard to deny that taxes are a burden. You must secretly agree. So if they are a burden, we need to look at where they are least painful. There is a luxury car tax on vehicles over £50k but its only £440 pa for six years. We could look at having luxury taxes on lots of other things too!
If you’re looking for cuts, we could reduce the gap between taxation receipts and govt spending by reducing interest rates. Govt spends £129 bn on interest payments according to the OBR. The reason we have large govt debts and deficits is because govt is encouraging others to lend to us by offering generous interest rates. This attracts ‘hot money’ into the economy pushing up the value of the pound to artificially high levels. This has boosted imports and killed much of our manufacturing industry over previous decades.
So if we cut interest rates we’d be on the road to both rebuilding and rebalancing our economy. As well as saving on interest payments, tax revenue would rise without having to raise taxation. A car built overseas doesn’t provide as much revenue to the Govt as a car built in the UK.
Callum Robertson would do well to consider the impact of Trump’s vain glorious war and tariffs on the constraints faced by the new Chancellor.
@Mick Taylor
“ OK, so what services are you going to cut to get taxes down?”
A fair question. I would suggest that we can reduce taxes on income by increasing VAT and using the proceeds to increase the personal allowance. Moving from taxes on income to taxes on spending gives consumers more choice as they only pay the tax when they choose to spend, but it leaves them with control over more of their income. It also helps make paid employment more worthwhile if you pay less income tax on it.
@ David Raw
Callum Robertson would do well to consider the impact of Trump’s vain glorious war and tariffs on the constraints faced by the new Chancellor.”
While I completely agree with you about Trump’s stupid war and tarrifs, I’m not sure why you are defending the Labour government. That’s their supporter’s job, not ours.
We should be highlighting Tump and tarrifs to those liberals (of all parties) as a reason to vote Liberal Democrat rather than Conservative/Reform given those two parties’ implicit support for Trump.
@ Tristan Ward, ” I’m not sure why you are defending the Labour government”. I’m not, Tristan.
Merely calling for a fair and open minded debate about the facts of economic life – and leaving all the right wing stuff to the Daily Mail/Daily Express/Telegraph/ Sky News et al who are better at it. As for “Tump and tarrifs” (sic)……. he’ll hopefully get his comeuppance next week.
@ Mick, @ Jana
“What services are you going to cut to get taxes down?”
I’ve just noticed that Rob Blackie, in his latest post, has quoted a figure of “around £37bn a year” in housing subsidies. The cost of these is not only borne by the taxpayer but also everyone else in the housing market who ends up paying higher rent than they otherwise would. I would estimate that for every pound of subsidy paid someone else has to pay at least an extra pound in rent too just to be able to compete.
These higher rents in turn feed back into the cost of the housing subsidies themselves. It’s no wonder the cost is so high.
This is obviously a very satisfactory arrangement for landlords, but not for anyone else. We need to find a way of cutting this cost without putting tenants out onto the streets. You’re a trained economist, Mick. Can you offer a solution?
I’d be interested in Mick’s, or anyone else’s. answer to this one.