Ed Davey was interviewed on Sky News this morning
The first question was about whether we should apologise for our role in slavery. He said:
If you have done something wrong, I have no problem in apologising for it. That’s what normal people expect to do. I think Tony Blair started this about 20 years ago and I think if the PM wants to consider it in a bit more detail, we should have that debate.
I don’t think reparations is the right approach. We’ve been doing a lot about it in terms of supporting poorer countries. It showed we had a moral obligation to support those well off in the world where there was global economic injustice. When we were in Government we really pushed that hard and I think that there is a case for doing more of that. I’ve been rather disappointed that both under Conservatives and Labour that has been trimmed back, pushed by pressure from Reform. I think that if we can grow our economy, because aid is linked to our national income, we will be able to support people in less well off countries a bit better.
Isn’t Andy Burnham going a bit further than you?
Not at all. We’ve put forward the idea that we should rejoin the Single Market with freedom of labour earlier this year. We have to negotiate it but we have already advocated and put forward a bill to inttoduce a youth mobility scheme to Parliament.
If you look at what’s happened to immigration since we left the EU, immigration got out of control. If you look at what Europe is doing on immigration, the EU signed a pact earlier this year and it has seen immigration to Europe fall as well. If we work with our European partners we can do a better job than Labour and the Conservatives have done.
But aren’t people protesting about immigration across Europe?
If you look at the protests in France and elsewhere outside Europe, they are related to the cost of living and you can see who has created that problem across the world, Donald Trump with his mad war in Iran. We could benefit from a much closer trade and defence relationship with Europe. By joining the single market and customs union, we could boost our economy. The problem with the Budget is that it had no growth strategy whatsoever. I don’t hear any growth strategy other than what we are putting forward.
But wouldn’t freedom of movement send people to our labour market and stop people getting jobs?
The NEET problem has got worse since Brexit. If we grew our economy there would be more jobs for young people, if we grew our economy there would be more help with the cost of living. If you look at what’s happened from 2021 projected to 2031, it’s a decade of freezing income tax allowances. That’s a massive stealth tax. Conservative and Labour chancellors and PMs have done this and have had to do that primarily because of Brexit. If you look at the independent analysis from forecasters, they show that the Treasury has lost £90 billion a year because of Brexit.
If you look at what Goldman Sachs said last week, if you went back into the single market and customs union, it would boost our economy by between £70 billion and £150 billion.
But aren’t Lib Dems being squeezed out of the debate here? You are at the bottom of the opinion polls.
Opinion polls aren’t real elections. Two and a half years ago we got our best result in 100 years, 72 Lib Dem MPs. If you look at local elections we have had 8 years of conseecutive gains which has never happened before. I’m not interested in polls, I’m interested in elections and we keep winning.
Do you have any KPIs for success. When is it time for you to leave?
When I took over, we had 11 MPs, we now have 72. We were way behind in local Government. Now we run more Councils than the Conservatives. The polls aren’t high under my leadership, but we keep winning in elections. What would you prefer to do?
The problem we have is that nobody is listening to what we say, so the fact that we might have called for the UK to rejoin the single market earlier this year does not make up for all those years where we sat on our hands and didn’t talk about Europe at all. Arguably, if we had, we could have contributed to an even bigger rise in public opinion in favour of much closer relations, even rejoining, the EU.
I also wish he had been a bit stronger on the benefits of immigration rather than feeding the false narrative that it’s too high and A BAD THING. We desperately need more people to come here. We have an aging population, particularly in Scotland.
And the problem with his argument that we’re winning elections so it doesn’t matter what the polls say is that we are winning those elections because the Conservative Party were at rock bottom. We were lucky. Those circumstances will not replicate themselves and we need to be looking beyond the Blue Wall to our next gains. And to do that we need a message that is nationally relevant.
We’re certainly getting a bit better at doing that, but it’s not yet cutting through. We lost an opportunity to influence the national debate after Andy Burnham’s Conference speech.
What was good about this interview is that he did press home the need for economic growth and associated us with things like raising the tax threshold and rejoining the EU that would help boost the economy. A lot of the stuff that Daisy Cooper was putting out ahead of the election was micro, tinkering at the edges. Ed’s comments on and response to the Budget was a bit more macro.
* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings. You can find her on Bluesky at caronmlindsay.bsky.social



48 Comments
Good interview by Ed.
Thanks for putting this in the LDV, Caron. I think Ed probably knows we did well in the general election because everyone had had enough of the Conservatives, and Keir Starmer wasn’t very attractive to voters either.
I think we have been too nervous about promoting the benefits of EU membership, and I’m afraid the softly, softly approach of talking up the single market is not going to excite anybody either. We should skip that, and go straight to advocating re-joining the EU as a full member. For too long we’ve been scared of upsetting the leave voters, but by now, many of them will be dead, and some will have changed their minds. Many of those who still go on about “the will of the people” (the leavers were 37% of the electorate, if I remember correctly) would never vote Lib Dem whatever we say, so what have we got to lose by being openly pro-EU ?
Reperations just adds to the culture wars which is impossible to put any boundaries on or context to.
Human rights activist Bayard Rustin puts it into perspective…
“If my great-grandfather picked cotton for 50 years, then he may deserve some money, but he’s dead and gone and nobody owes me a dime”..
Chloe will find that the Trevelyan family wouldn’t agree with her. Led by Laura Trevelyan, (former BBC correspondent in the USA) they have made educational reparations in Trinidad where their ancestors owned over 1,100 slaves. Laura’s ancestors include George Otto Trevelyan (Liberal MP for Peebles – and in Gladstone’s Cabinet as Scottish Minister in the 1880’s) and his son Charles Phillips Trevelyan (Liberal MP for Elland and a Junior Education Minister in the Asquith Government). Charles resigned from the Liberal Party over the First World War, later serving as Education Minister in the Cabinet of the first two Ramsay Macdonald Labour Governments in the 1920’s.
I don’t know whether (or if) the Gladstone family has ever made any reparations for the slave plantations they owned in the West Indies…. though they did receive the equivalent of millions of pounds of compensation in 1837 after slavery was abolished in the British Empire.
“ If you have done something wrong, I have no problem in apologising for it. That’s what normal people expect to do“
Ed is right of course. But there are no “you” who have done anything wrong. The people responsible died hundreds of years ago.
I think it is right for all sensible political parties to rule out reparations. I don’t see it ever being politically viable to ask the electorate of 2026 to pay for the sins of their great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great parents. Especially when there is a close to record tax burden and people are struggling to get by.
Also where does it stop. Do we send the German’s a bill for the pain and suffering and damage caused by WW2, the Scandinavians an invoice for the Viking raids?
I know you should never say never, but I am confident that the UK electorate will never in a million months of Sundays agree to any form of direct monetary reparations.
What the Trevelyan family do with their own money is entirely upto them as private individuals. When it comes to taxpayer’s money , then govts should give a single penny to countries who continue to suffer from poor governance oozing grievance politics. Those who advocate this rubbish can make a private donation by all means.
According to a DNA test, a small amount of me is Viking, presumably from my Wiltshire ancestry. Does that mean I should be offering reparations to the descendants of my non-Viking neighbours?
Collective punishment for rebellion against the Romans included ploughing the fields with salt so that people starved. Does that mean the Italian government should be paying any descendants compensation?
OK, that’s reductio ad absurdum, but the truth is that we can’t be held responsible for what our however many great grandparents may or may not have done before 1837.
Any apologies were due from slave traders and slave owners and they’re long dead. Any apology from current generations would be tokenistic at best.
Andy Burnham 2016 HOC speech..
“There is nothing socialist about a system of open borders that allows multinationals to treat people as commodities and move them around Europe to drive down labour costs and create a race to the bottom”
Danish Pm
“For me, it is becoming increasingly clear that the price of unregulated globalisation, mass immigration and the free movement of labour is paid for by the lower classes.”
“Any apologies were due from slave traders and slave owners and they’re long dead.” and most of their descendants are probably also slave descendants. Very few white people who went to the West indies in the early days made it back to Britain.
I agree with Simon McGrath and Mick Taylor on the question of reparations. Both the victims and the perpetrators of the Trans Atlantic Slave Trade are long dead. So not only is there nobody responsible for the Trans Atlantic Slave Trade still alive but all the victims are also long dead. I also think that concentrating solely on the Trans Atlantic Slave Trade overlooks the fact that slavery was endemic. What about the East African Slave Trade where millions were taken to Arab and Muslim Countries and of whom many of the males were castrated? Unfortunately none of their descendants of those slaves live in The West.
Finally it also ignores the fact that slavery still goes on in many countries around the world, including some in Sub Saharan Africa. Consigning slavery to the dustbin of history should be the focus, not reparations.
” For too long we’ve been scared of upsetting the leave voters, but by now, many of them will be dead,”
That is an appalling thing to say.
Simon and Mick,
In talking about reparations due to Britain, don’t forget demanding them from the Algerian government for all the slave-taking raids by North African privateers on British coastal towns!
Andrew Tampion; appalling ? Why ? Demographic analysis after the vote in 2016 showed a high degree of correlation between leave voters and age. Broadly, younger people voted remain and older people voted leave. I forget which respected analyst said that in January 2019, enough leave voters had already died for the current population to have a majority in favour of remain. People are still dying of old age, so of the people who actually voted in 2016, it’s a racing certainty that remainers are now the majority.
Where do we draw the line. The Romans moved Britons to Europe, the Normans slaughtered
large numbers of people in Yorkshire and the North and as for the for Vikings. Have the Germans paid reparations for the Holocaust. We can go on for ever, all this whilst Europe is on the brink of a war of potential extinction.
Of course Councillor McGrath is correct when he writes, “The people responsible died hundreds of years ago”, and Chloe is also correct when she writes, “What the Trevelyan family do with their own money is entirely up to them as private individuals”.
What neither mention is that when slavery was abolished compensation was paid to the slave owners out of public money for the loss of their “assets”…………. amounting to 40% of the then public budget. An acknowledgement of this might, just might, be more in the true Liberal philosophical tradition.
>”If you look at what’s happened to immigration since we left the EU, immigration got out of control. ”
Factually incorrect, non-EU immigration got out of control pretty much as soon as Blair enacted the Conservative agreed Freedom of Movement (FoM) policy in 1997. Remember the UK border controls (and IT systems) were in poor state under Thatcher et al, they saw FoM as a way of avoiding doing anything to the border systems.
Lib Dems, and others, do like to make the case for the UK rejoining the EU with the first steps being to have closer ties with our European neighbours. The argument is almost exclusively about the supposed benefits we’d experience. There’s virtually no discussion of what type of organisation we would be rejoining.
Events in France are being totally ignored. There are similar stories in the media today of problems elsewhere, including in Germany and Portugal. Problems that look even worse than we are experiencing in the UK currently. So I’d really question why we might expect our economic problems to improve if we were to become more like the French, and be subject to the same austerity inclined neoliberal policies.
@David Raw: Many things were done 200 years ago that we would today not be proud of. The compensation to slave owners was paid because doing so neutered some of the then opposition to abolishing slavery, allowing the abolition to get through at a time when many people still believed slavery to be normal. But it’s simply not practical or realistic to go round apologising for or paying compensation for things that were done many generations ago, which were once thought normal but which according to the standards of today we now see as very wrong. Personally I’d rather focus on the many injustices that we see happening around the World today.
(Or should the descendants of – say – child chimney sweeps, or people who suffered 19th century workhouses also today be demanding financial compensation for the wrongs inflicted on their ancestors?)
@ Simon Robinson. I’m glad to see you say that the opposition to abolishing slavery was bought off, which, of course, I knew. Whether the modern Lib Dems should be cold hearted realists and agree with Henry Ford that history is bunk is quite another question given that the Christian religion was born over two thousand years ago and is apparently still part of the modern established state in the UK.
So if I said that the overwhelming majority of remain voters from 1975 had died and that therefore the 2016 referendum was justified you’d be fine with that?
Should have added, an apology and an assertion of liberal values costs nothing.
@ Caron Lindsay
“we need a message that is nationally relevant.”
Which bit of:
“We need more growth”
“We need to do something about climate change”
“We need to join the Single Market and Customs Union
“We need more joint defence with Europe”
“We need to do something about care”
“We need to do something about water/sewerage and energy infrastructure”
“Trump is an international gangster and Farage and the Tories are far too close to him”
“Energy prices are too high”
“We need to raise income tax thresholds”
is not nationally relevant?
“What neither mention is that when slavery was abolished compensation was paid to the slave owners out of public money for the loss of their “assets””
I agree the fact that no compensation was paid to freed slaves is problematic. But fropm a purely legal point of view the law was changed and something that had been bought legally was taken away. So paying compensation was not unreasonable. Suppose a future Green Government banned ICE cars with immediate effect and refused to pay the owners compensation? That said it is regrettable that the freed slaves got nothing.
“it is regrettable that the freed slaves got nothing”
Freed slaves didn’t get “nothing”. They got freedom. I don’t recall many electing to stay in chains on the basis that they didn’t get a lump sum as well. And yes I know about the “apprenticeships” that many were forced into which seems outside the spirit of the deal.
Yes (by 20th and 21st century standards) people should always have had freedom, but as others have pointed out those standards were less entrenched in the 19th century and before.
I think it’s more important to prevent a reversion to 19th century standards (consider Article 4 of the European Convention on Human Rights and those who wish the UK to withdraw from it). Right now arguing about reparations just gives weapons to those who want to go backwards.
In the discussion about reparations – an irrational notion for all the reasons mentioned – no one seems to mention that there are more slaves/trafficked people in the world now than there have ever been. We can’t do anything about the crimes committed by our ancestors but if there’s political will and money to spare, how about addressing the current situation. (Much as the abolitionists did 200 years ago),
On the subject of the EU, I was and still am a “remainer” despite being old! I subscribe to “better together” The world is fractured enough as it is.
After the Norman conquest, the majority of the English were forced into serfdom. The descendents of the Normans are still significantly richer than the descendants of the serfs. I’m not asking for reparations but I do think we need to bring inheritance tax to levels where the proceeds of past crimes become irelevant within a few generations.
@ David Raw
“I’m glad to see you say that the opposition to abolishing slavery was bought off”
One interpretation is that majority opinion in 19th century Britain (at least in the political classes) thought tax payers money was well spent in buying off the slave owners to set people free.
To put it another way, slaves got their freedom quicker than they would have had had they had to wait until the slaveowners saw the error of their ways, allowed the legislation through Parliament and voluntarily set people free.
I’ll leave you to decide whether you think waiting to pass the abolition legislation without making the payments to the slave owners would have been a better course than getting people out of slavery quicker, or whether the money was well spent.
@DavidRaw. To be strictly accurate, the Church in Wales and the Church in Scotland play no state role since they were disestablished by the 1906-14 Liberal Government. I would welcome the disestablishment of the CoE as well.
@ Mick Taylor Correct.
@TristanWard. Growth and doing something about climate change are of course incompatible. I despair that our leaders call for growth rather than the obvious alternative of spreading what we’ve already got more fairly. Oh but that would mean taxing the rich and tackling wealth inequality and we can’t have that, can we?
I agree Andrew Tampion, it was a callous and spiteful comment. There should be a referendum on EU membership so that it’s a democratic decision.
I agree with much of what Ed Davey says, but the message needs to appeal more to voters in Labour areas and the redistribution of wealth and raising the personal allowance are key policy issues.
I remember speaking to a transport driver taking me home after a major op a few years ago. They were originally from one of the Caribbean islands. We talked heath care in general and how this island was struggling to provide the same level of care we sometimes take for granted for in the UK. Perhaps the overseas budget can be used to support these countries for specific altruistic purposes.
@JasonConnor. We are a parliamentary democracy. We elect MPs to make decisions for us. If a future government gets elected on a platform to join the EU, then consent would be there. We didn’t need a referendum in 1975, we were already members of the EEC. That was Harold Wilson papering over disagreements in the Labour Party. Referendums in the UK are usually held because a government hasn’t the cajones to make a decision about a contentious issue. Viz, devolution to Scotland and Wales, the AV referendum and many others. You could also argue that the 2016 referendum was held so that Cameron could shut his anti EU MPs up only he got it wrong.
Referenda are not really part of the UK constitution and we should have nothing to do with them.
@ Mick,
“Referenda are not really part of the UK constitution and we should have nothing to do with them”
What is actually part of the constitution? Unlike in most countries, no official attempt has been made to codify such arrangements into a single document. In other words we don’t really have one!
Maybe Lib Dems should suggest that we should and propose one. A real one for the whole of the country. We can leave Magna Carta out of it. I’m happy for my wife and children to pay off any debts, out of my estate, I may owe after my demise even if owed to Jewish people. 🙂
I’d suggest that we can leave Parliament to make changes as and when they see fit providing they aren’t taking powers away from future Parliaments or make changes to the constitution. If they want to do they should hold a referendum.
No that’s right. There is no written constitution. Referenda enable people to have their say on decisions which fundamentally change the country’s direction such as this. And that’s important in a democracy. Likewise in Scotland and Wales. If the outcome had gone the other way and UK voted remain, then I bet many remainers would extol the benefits of referenda. I say that as an ardent remainder myself. The result last time wasn’t helped that the then Labour leader showed little enthusiasm for staying in the UK to the chagrin of so many of their members
The problem with Referenda is that they are usually binary, giving Voters only two choices when there are actually multiple possibilities. Not only is that undemocratic, it splits the public into two Teams where Identity replaces debate. If you are in the Red Team then the Blues are the Enemy.
Also the two-choice Referendum rules out any chance of Democratically connecting different but related decisions such as the Status of Northern Ireland & Scotland.
Its no wonder that Anti-Democratic figures like Farage love Referenda.
Whether or not the comment about dead people was appropriate, it’s dangerous to assume that high support for a position among youth, or a general trend of rising support, make its adoption inevitable. Mark Pack recently pointed this out in a recent edition of LDN, noting the higher Tory vote share among the youngest cohort of voters (yes, really) in the 1983 and 87 elections, which one might have thought would lead to a Tory hegemony for a generation. Well it didn’t exactly work out like that!
It’s “referendums”.
@ PM,
It can be either. I do remember from my schooldays that the plural in Latin involved replacing the ‘um’ of a neuter noun by an ‘a’. I must have managed to stay awake for at least some of the time 🙂
But, the word has migrated into English so .referendums is usually considered to be OK too.
I don’t particularly care either way. The important thing is that we don’t outlaw them on the spurious grounds they weren’t mentioned in Magna Carta!
Except that “referendum” is not a Latin 2nd Declension Neuter noun. It’s a gerundive; as such it is used in English differently from Latin so should take an English plural naturally.
In Latin it may be a gerund but in English it’s a noun. If I were to object to the Government’s referending of the public, that would be a gerund.
“We elect MPs to make decisions for us. If a future government gets elected on a platform to join the EU, then consent would be there. We didn’t need a referendum in 1975, we were already members of the EEC.”
So if a UKIP Government had won a majority on a platform of leaving the EU you’d be fine with that?
@Andrew Tampion. As the current UK constitution (unwritten) stands, then yes. You can’t have one rule for things you like and another for things you don’t like.
Referenda/Referendums?? How typical of LibDems to argue about semantics rather than the substantive point.
Have a referendum on which plural form should be used (this sounds like an OMRLP or Count Binface policy).
No need for a further referendum or a second referenda, Mic and Alex, if one can accept the Speaker’s ruling back in June 1998.
The Tory MP Alan Clark asked Speaker Betty Boothroyd to officially rule on whether the plural of “referendum” should be “referendums” or the Latin-derived “referenda”. After our Betty had consulted the Oxford English Dictionary and noted that the choice was a matter of taste, stating: “I’ve always preferred the use of the English language to any Latin form if that is of some guidance,” expressing her personal preference for referendums – not surprising given our Betty was a Dewsbury Lass.
” You can’t have one rule for things you like and another for things you don’t like.” ???
You’ve only got to attend a football match to know that nearly all those who have a partisan interest think you can! If referee the disallows a goal for a close offside decision we all know which sections of the crowd will either agree or disagree.
Are Libdems really any different from those they might regard as the hoi polloi? In the event that we did rejoin the EU, would LibDems agree that an elected government had the right to unilaterally cancel our membership? Or would the argument be that only 20% , or whatever, of the electorate had voted for the ruling party and therefore it had no mandate?
@Peter Martin. Until the UK gets a written constitution and/or changes its electoral system we are stuck with a party winning a GE with less (sometimes considerably less) than 50%. The resulting parliament can do anything it wants to, because there are no constitutional restraints on its action. It could scrap Scottish and Welsh devolution, it could give the governing party permission to run the country by decree and there would be nothing to stop it. As long as a majority exists for its policies it has free rein. It could even scrap elections.
I suspect that the EU knows that and it will not agree for the UK to join the EU without fundamental constitutiopnal reform that would limit, but not abolish, the UK’s right to leave again. There would be no point in joining the EU if a change of government could take us out again.
Hence LibDem support for electoral reform and a written constitution. Not directly because of the EU issue, but because those policies are fundamentally right.
I personally think the idea of a mandate is a very flawed one. Issues can fundamentally change during the course of a 5 year parliament, so it’s a very foolish government that sets down red lines it won’t cross, regardless of the circumstances. As JM Keynes rightly observed “If the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do Sir”.