Fantasy Frontbench – University College London (UCL)

University College London has started a Fantasy Frontbench to debate major current issues. The first in their series was “Should Climate Change be UK’s Top Policy Priority?”. The guest speakers were Natalie Bennett (previous leader of the Green party), Ahir Shah (a comedian), Professor Mark Maslin (Geography professor at UCL) and Dr. Emily Shuckburgh (climate scientist at the British Antarctic Survey). About 120 people attended including children from local schools.

Before the discussion started, the audience was asked the question, and the result was 52% for Yes and 48% for No (to which Ahir commented that this was considered an overwhelming majority these days).

Each member of the panel had two minutes to put their case: for or against the motion. Interestingly Natalie started with “Climate change should not be the dominant policy priority but be one in a combination of high priority policies” – after a gasp, the indicator went to 43% for Yes and 57% for No.

During the discussion (It was less of debate as they all seem to agree on the main issues) the key points made were: –

  • Dr. Shuckburgh stated that Carbon dioxide (CO2) in the atmosphere was at an unprecedented level and as a result global temperature had increased by 1 degree from 150 years ago;
  • She highlighted that this was particularly bad for the elderly as the temperature fluctuations are bad for their health;
  • Dr. Shuckburgh also talked about the acidity of the oceans and the adverse effect of that on the coral reef;
  • Mark Maslin stated that this was one of the four main issues that the world faced today (he mentioned two others, and they were hunger and war);

On the question of the impact on the UK of climate change, the main points raised were:

  • The significant flooding from rising sea levels;
  • More internal flooding from rain;
  • Disruption of the food we import;
  • Natalie made a good point that “We can’t have infinite growth on a finite planet”;
  • Mark Maslin (when the discussion moved on to the Paris Agreement) stated that from 2020 we need to reduce our emissions by 2% until 2070 to get to zero emissions and then continue if we are to achieve negative CO2 reductions in the atmosphere;
  • The panel agreed that another threat, to the UK, was the lack of investment in research and development and green innovation.

As for the future – Mark Maslin quoted Al Gore (whom he met at a conference) who told him “We have to fix democracy before we can fix climate change”. The panel all agreed with this. The point is that some countries and local politicians are resisting progress on climate issues and if peoples voices were heard in a more representative democratic system, the focus on climate change would be more favorable.

To find out more about the Fantasy Frontbench look at the UCL site. The URL is shown below:

The panel finished with a message of hope, they were confident that as a human race we will find a solution to climate change. The final result of the question was 57% for and 43% against the motion.


* Cllr. Tahir Maher is a member of the LDV editorial team

Read more by .
This entry was posted in Events and Op-eds.


  • Richard Underhill 15th Jul '18 - 3:28pm

    Yes, the USA should abolish the electoral college and go for direct elections.

  • Richard Underhill 4th Apr '19 - 10:13am

    Peacetime PM Winston Churchill reprimanded his chief whip with the words “One is enough”. Ted Heath went on to be Harold MacMillan’s euro-negotiator and was the first MP to be elected as Tory leader.
    He sacked Powell from the Shadow Cabinet after the ‘Rivers of Blood’ speech and allowed the immigration to the UK of a large number of Ugandan Asians with the simple comment “It was the right thing to do”.
    The sun-tanned sailor became PM himself in 1970, but is now a non-person in Tory circles.
    He appointed a woman to the cabinet (married with twins), made friends with the successor to De Gaulle with French wine in the Paris embassy, but was overwhelmed by multiple problems in 1974 as his Political Secretary, Douglas Hurd, has documented. While agreeing with Churchill about referendums, he said, in 1975, “If there is to be a referendum we must win it”.
    He was shown with Roy Jenkins (then Labour) and David Steel (Liberal) headlined ‘The Euro-pals’.
    MacMillan, Heath and Callaghan (Labour) were all from a generation who had served in WW2 and understood the horrors of war,and the overwhelming priority of prevention, much better than their successors, such as Thatcher and Blair.

  • richard underhill 28th Jul '20 - 1:32pm

    A fantasy cricketer who scored 400 not out in a test match His comment should be treated with respect, even if he is commenting from Antigua. If he thinks that the current West Indian team are not match fit for a five day contest he should be allowed to say so and should not be deleted from the blog.
    His comment was included on the BBC red button, itself in danger from Boris’s budget cuts.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Dan
    David Raw... Not the daily express. It was a link in the Euro News. I have to go through the link to copy and paste it up here...
  • Peter Watson
    @Michael 1 "We need to promise to scrap tuition them [fees?]." Having defended/supported the 2012 system of tuition fees and repayment for the last 9+ years de...
  • Iain Sharpe
    Like James Moore, I don’t know what constitutes a ‘fake’ newspaper. There are no rules that say political parties can’t use newsprint or have to use set...
  • Paul Fisher
    It's great that Joe Biden is President BUT 74 million Americans voted for Trump. Think about it. The problem is deeper that cheap shots at Europe....
  • Paul Fisher
    An existential crisis methinks....