Hackney Council backtracks on library book ban

A quick update on the story about Hackney Council banning a book launch from one of its libraries because the book contained “controversial or political opinions”. Dave Hill has the details of how Hackney is now backing away from its original position, and talking about being happy to stock the book by Iain Sinclair in future.

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in News.
Advert

9 Comments

  • Clegg's Candid Friend 13th Nov '08 - 11:36pm

    It’s quite misleading to describe this as a “library book ban”.

    As far as I know, there has never been any question of the book being banned from Hackney libraries, as your headline would suggest.

    Or as suggested by your no-doubt carefully phrased comment about Hackney “backing away from its original position, and talking about being happy to stock the book by Iain Sinclair in future”.

    In fact, the “original position” was the withdrawal of an invitation to hold an event to launch the book in a local library, and the reason the book isn’t stocked at the moment is that it hasn’t been published yet!

  • Clegg's Candid Friend 14th Nov '08 - 12:47am

    I’m not assuming any such thing. It’s perfectly obvious what you’ve done here.

    Clearly the sentence was carefully constructed to give people the impression the book had originally been banned, without explicitly saying so.

    Just like “library book ban” in the headline.

    What’s the excuse for that? You can hardly claim, as a print journalist could, that there wasn’t room to write “ban on book launch in library”!

  • Clegg's Candid Friend 14th Nov '08 - 9:23am

    “As for the headline – the story is about a ban involving a book and a library. No headline can give all the details of a story (unless it’s a very, very simple story!) …”

    But it’s clearly not about a “book ban”, is it? Would it really have been so hard to write “book launch ban” instead?

  • Mark, do you think it is necessary, or wise, for public libraries that are funded by the taxpayer to get involved in commercial product launches for books? Especialy those which advocate a particular political point of view?

  • Grammar Police 14th Nov '08 - 1:22pm

    @ David – but that wasn’t the reason Hackney withdrew its invitation to speak.

  • David Allen 14th Nov '08 - 2:53pm

    Mark: Fair enough, if it’s novels, local history, whatever. But when it comes down to politics, or religion, shouldn’t we be cautious? If we launch a Conservative book today, what do we say when the BNP put in their application tomorrow?

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Paul Holmes
    Mick you say that the Liberal Democrats never polled anywhere near the 6M votes won by the Liberals in Feb 1974. You mean apart from the 5,999,606 in 1992, or t...
  • David Allen
    Burnham and Milburn are genuinely trying to tackle this problem. The Tories didn't. Starmer didn't. The Lib Dems seem to begrudge giving Burnham any credit. ...
  • Mick Taylor
    @PaulHolmes. Your unknown Liberal Party I joined in 1964 polled 6 million votes in February 1974. The electoral system prevented them making sweeping gains. The...
  • Steve Trevethan
    Thank you for an “other countries” article. Ditto the comment from P M. Might it be relevant that South Africa, France and Spain have Neoliberal policies...
  • Paul Holmes
    I can though very much agree with what you say about Clegg. But of course he, Laws, Alexander etc were very much classic Economic Liberals favouring lower taxe...