If the Democrat primaries were being run on first past the post (rather than allocating delegates in proportion to the votes won by the different Presidential candidates), then Hillary Clinton would now be the Democrat nominee for President, despite having won fewer votes overall.
Subscribe
-
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
-
Like us on Facebook
-
Subscribe to our feed
-
Sign-up for our daily email digest
Most Read
Search
Op-eds
-
We cannot afford to become complacent about violence against women and girls (Anton Georgiou)
-
George Potter: For an English State Party that works, and is in your corner (George Potter)
-
Vince Cable writes…When is a spy not a spy? (Vince Cable)
-
America or Europe: sovereignty subordinated or shared? (Lord William Wallace)
-
Trust, consent and the limits of criminal law – why a staggered age of consent is the wrong instrument (Owen Driscoll)
-
Lord Bonkers 30 years ago: An Englishman's right to beat his stepson
-
John Pardoe, Michael Foot and Francis Pym debate on the night Jim Callaghan's government fell
-
One farewell speech and two debut speeches from Lib Dem peers
-
World Toilet Day
-
The Joy of Six 1609
-
What is the future of Wales' four police forces?
Recent Comments
PM
"Britain, long ago, became utterly dependent on favourable trade with . . everywhere else. ...........Finally, the mask has slipped and the rules based ord...
Jason Connor
How do you know all these companies are unregulated?They would have to comply with GDPR in any case. And yes I would as I have nothing to hide. And as a social ...
David Evans
Simon Robinson Please see my response to Cj above and reconsider your view that "I’m not convinced that the EU allows us to hold either company to account ...
David Evans
Cj, I really do chuckle at the idea that individuals (one at a time) not using the services of Amazon, Google etc would mitigate in any way at all against the ...
Simon Robinson
Claiming that Amazon and Google damage society, without also acknowledging the good they do, paints a bit of a misleading picture. Amazon has enabled us all to ...


4 Comments
That’s a dubious claim. You are trying to compare apples and oranges. Obama did very well where state parties held caucuses, where the totaled votes cast were lower than in states which held primaries. In these states Clinton tended to do better overall. Had all states used the same electoral system then Obama may have received most votes. Why are you trying to talk up Hillary when Barack is evidently the candidate more aligned with Liberal Democrat positions than Labour???
B. Stearn:
I think you miss hte major point here – Mark is pointing out that Clinton has less votes, but if FPTP had been used she’d have won.
Its pointing out the way that FPTP can produce absurd outcomes rather than talking up Clinton.
Actually the delegates don’t seem to be allocated in proportion to the votes won by the different Presidential candidates, because if they were, Hillary would have more delegates from Nevada and Texas, where she won the popular vote, but now Obama has more delegates from both states. I understand, that they actually use a sort of first past the post, but they have now breaken the states to sort-of one-member constituencies, whereas previously the winner got all delegates of the state.
NN unfortunately it ain’t that simple… In fact just about each state uses a slightlky different system, some have caucuses and some polls and some both and some whole state and some sub divisions – tere is some very good explanatory information via abc.com’s political pages – facinating stuff but the Dems still don’t have one candidate!
I suspect what’s keeping Hillary going is the GE opinion poll analysis that she has a better chance of beating McCain and the belief that this could swing the superdelegates and the convention vote.. Have a look at:
http://www.electoral-vote.com/
facinating stuff if you are interested in psephology and bear in mind that the Novemeber poll is for state votes in an electoral colege not for the president… so that’s another quirky system…