If the Democrat primaries were being run on first past the post (rather than allocating delegates in proportion to the votes won by the different Presidential candidates), then Hillary Clinton would now be the Democrat nominee for President, despite having won fewer votes overall.
Subscribe
-
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
-
Like us on Facebook
-
Subscribe to our feed
-
Sign-up for our daily email digest
Most Read
- The Falklands are under threat again and we can’t rely on America to save us
- Mathew on Monday: Ann Widdecombe, robust debate and the need to disagree agreeably
- William Wallace writes: The case for higher taxes
- Congratulations to five new peers
- “Palestine should be run by Palestinians” so why won’t Britain reckon with what it did?
Search
Op-eds
-
Defining our future in Burnham Britain (Gareth McAleer)
-
Andy Burnham – new messiah or naughty boy? (Mark Hunter)
-
“Palestine should be run by Palestinians” so why won’t Britain reckon with what it did? (Alex Cole-Hamilton)
-
You can’t defend your way to a World Cup… or No. 10 (Tom Reeve)
-
The financing timebomb in Sub-Saharan Africa: What Britain should do — and isn’t (Rupinder Singh)
-
Is Farage set to lose Clacton?
-
Citizenship ceremony
-
Welsh Lib Dems are short of peers and the Lords is weighted towards London and the South East of England
-
Another myth exploded: Queen Victoria and the lesbians
-
"Everyone carried a shopping bag": Muriel Spark on London, 1945
-
Lloyd George Society Chair - Welsh Lib Dem Peers face extinction
-
Saving the curlew from extinction in Shropshire
-
The cinema in a church that became a curry house
Recent Comments
Jenny Barnes
Do the LDs have an actual political project apart from "more seats in the HOC"? Asking for a friend....
Hywel
"Andy Burnham has consolidated the centre left, pushed Reform to the margins and made a progressive coalition government the new baseline. " Has he? The evi...
Tristan Ward
I have been out calling on known supporters asking for help today in one of our top 10 target seats. The response was enthusiastic and I recruited 5 new helpers...
Jana
@Simon McGrath “ Ironic that the first comment is anti semitic conspiracy theory.” I don’t understand this statement. There is no disagreement that th...
Andy Daer
Alex reminds us of the historical reasons why British prime ministers need to take responsibility for the awful consequences of our failures during the Mandate ...
4 Comments
That’s a dubious claim. You are trying to compare apples and oranges. Obama did very well where state parties held caucuses, where the totaled votes cast were lower than in states which held primaries. In these states Clinton tended to do better overall. Had all states used the same electoral system then Obama may have received most votes. Why are you trying to talk up Hillary when Barack is evidently the candidate more aligned with Liberal Democrat positions than Labour???
B. Stearn:
I think you miss hte major point here – Mark is pointing out that Clinton has less votes, but if FPTP had been used she’d have won.
Its pointing out the way that FPTP can produce absurd outcomes rather than talking up Clinton.
Actually the delegates don’t seem to be allocated in proportion to the votes won by the different Presidential candidates, because if they were, Hillary would have more delegates from Nevada and Texas, where she won the popular vote, but now Obama has more delegates from both states. I understand, that they actually use a sort of first past the post, but they have now breaken the states to sort-of one-member constituencies, whereas previously the winner got all delegates of the state.
NN unfortunately it ain’t that simple… In fact just about each state uses a slightlky different system, some have caucuses and some polls and some both and some whole state and some sub divisions – tere is some very good explanatory information via abc.com’s political pages – facinating stuff but the Dems still don’t have one candidate!
I suspect what’s keeping Hillary going is the GE opinion poll analysis that she has a better chance of beating McCain and the belief that this could swing the superdelegates and the convention vote.. Have a look at:
http://www.electoral-vote.com/
facinating stuff if you are interested in psephology and bear in mind that the Novemeber poll is for state votes in an electoral colege not for the president… so that’s another quirky system…