How housebuilding can tackle the cost of living crisis and boost growth

This article draws on “Hitting housebuilding targets would reduce rents by £251 a month” published by the Centre for British Progress, written by Rob Blackie, Tim Leunig and David Lawrence.

Andy Burnham’s recent promise to tackle the cost of living pitch ignored the most practical approach: increasing housebuilding to bring down rents. This week the Office for Budget Responsibility predicted that people will get poorer in the next few years. If Britain focuses on cutting rents we can reverse that trend.

The typical British renter spends three times as much on rent as on food, and five times as much as on energy. And in the most expensive areas, such as London and the South East, renters typically spend 40% of their incomes on rent.  And this isn’t because we’re spending money on good housing either. Britain’s housing is smaller, and lower quality, than our European neighbours.

The costs affect not only renters, but all of us. The government spends around £37bn a year on housing subsidies, money we all have to find via our taxes or lower public spending elsewhere. This is the highest rate of any comparable country. There are less obvious costs too: businesses face high rents in London, and skilled individuals can’t afford to move there, constraining the growth of successful businesses in our most successful city. National income – and tax revenues – are lower as a result.

Our high cost of housing can be explained by simple supply and demand, nothing more and nothing less. For instance, London’s population has grown by 1.6 million people this century, and supply hasn’t kept up, constrained by planning rules that prioritise golf courses over house building.

It is reasonable to ask whether new private housing, aimed mainly at people on relatively high incomes, will lower rents more generally. The Prime Minister implies not, hence his currently unfunded pledge to create the “biggest council house building programme” since the 1950s. This would cost tens of billions of pounds a year. This is an admirable ambition, but very unlikely to happen when our government is short of money.

The evidence is clear that private building lowers rents for everybody. Recent research from Finland, for example, shows that while people who move into new flats are indeed relatively well-off, such moves kick off a classic house-moving chain.  The majority of people who move – presumably to somewhere better or cheaper – have lower than average incomes, and – quite remarkably – over a third of people who move are in the lowest fifth of households by income.

Many of these are adult children previously stuck at home with parents, others are people moving out of overcrowded shared flats. So long as enough new homes are built, the laws of supply and demand means lower prices and greater choice at all price points.

All this happens at no cost to the government.

Let’s imagine that England actually hits the current housing targets, for five years. The standard model, developed for the UK government by the University of Reading, shows that rents would fall about 2% a year. In absolute terms, London would see the biggest falls. The rent on a typical two bedroom flat in Lambeth would, for example, fall by over £250 a month within five years, compared to trend. The same renters in Manchester would save £51 a month (because rents are already much lower in Manchester), £43 a month in Birmingham and £32 a month in Sheffield.

As a comparison, the government’s recent energy VAT cut is worth £4 a month – and that has to be covered by £4 extra tax. Or to look at it another way, a £250 rise in disposable incomes from lower rents is approximately equivalent to wage rises doubling over the same period.

Building this number of houses would also increase both national income and tax revenues as well. Government spending – particularly on extraordinarily expensive and terrible temporary accommodation – would fall as housing became more readily available. The rise in tax revenue and fall in spending would reduce government borrowing by £1bn a year, just from cheaper housing in London alone.

In recent years sensible planning reforms in places as diverse as Auckland, Austin, Minneapolis and California have increased house building and caused lower prices. There are many proven models to copy. The government’s recent reforms to the planning system are welcome – but the data on actual housebuilding shows that they are insufficient.

Housing policy failures of both the current and recent governments have everybody in the country who needs to rent somewhere to live, as well as first time buyers. More housebuilding will benefit every postcode since it will increase tax revenues, and reduce pressures on public spending.

No other policy can have as big an impact without needing public spending. It’s time we got building again.

 

 

* Rob Blackie was Liberal Democrat Mayoral candidate in 2024, achieving the best result for 16 years. He has beaten the Greens in competitive elections as an organiser or candidate in 2010 (twice), 2012, 2024 and 2026. https://bsky.app/profile/robblackie.bsky.social

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

18 Comments

  • “ It is reasonable to ask whether new private housing, aimed mainly at people on relatively high incomes, will lower rents more generally”

    And, of course, the answer is ‘yes’. New top end housing will attract buyers currently living in not so new and not so top end housing. This kicks off a chain of moves as these not so new and not so top end houses come on to the market and are bought up by people in smaller, cheaper or older houses etc. Eventually, much cheaper housing comes on to the market that will be attractive to people currently paying for private rental housing, and as these private rentals become available, rents begin to increase more slowly or are even competed down by market forces.

    So allowing the private sector to build top end housing leads to an increase in the supply of rental properties and, possibly, falls in rent levels.

  • Peter Davies 31st Oct '26 - 8:11am

    While I agree that private development will bring down prices and eventually rents, presumption against building in the planning laws is not the major problem.

    Planning takes too long because it’s a negotiation between two parties with little incentive to speed it up. The developer is making money from rising land prices while they wait and the council is putting off unpopular decisions and infrastructure costs.

    LVT should be introduced based on zoning so from the point when a council designates a site as for housing until new owners move in, the developer is losing money. There should also be a direct transfer from national to local government based on the increase in residents adequately housed. That would more than cover the infrastructure costs and give councils an incentive to let development happen. It would also give them an incentive to commission new homes for sale or commercial rent themselves and we should let them do that.

  • “{Building more council houses} is an admirable ambition, but very unlikely to happen when our government is short of money.”

    We managed to build quite a few in the immediate post war period when it is often said we were nearly bankrupt. We found the money for rebuilding plus we found money to nationalise key industries.

    So why wasn’t a lack of money a problem? The answer is that these were essentially asset swaps. Govt bonds and stocks were swapped for company shares. Money was swapped for the ownership of property and land. So the net cost was zero or was even something that could be done at a profit.

    So, for example, we could build, say, 100 houses which would be worth £250k each This would be a total of £25 million. If we put out the necessary work to tender it would be, perhaps, £20 million. If we did what we did in the post war period and bought up land at agricultural prices it could be even less.

  • @peter – Land prices have not been rising, at least in London, for ages. The idea that developers string out negotiations is hard to sustain in the context of their losing money with every day that passes (lost interest as well as falling land values).

  • UK housing is in a shameful state after decades of a cosy financial relationship between major developers, lenders and government. By abandoning new building to the ‘market’, successive governments have ensured that profits alone decide what is built. We are continuing to cover good farmland in sprawling low-density estates of energy-inefficient houses that are utterly dependent on using cars. Many new city apartments are cramped, poorly designed and have extortionate charges. For most people, there is no alternative available.
    Improvements will come only from a radical overhaul and legislation. Building regulations should be enforced by a national inspectorate independent of local government and whose assessments are public. We need a minimum standard for any dwelling that includes space, quiet, storage, disabled access and maintenance.
    One of the very few benefits that planning could deliver is much too readily abandoned by capitulating to the developers. People need quality outdoor spaces, schools, doctors and community facilities. Where is there for teenagers to meet constructively ?
    The repeated failure to meet these basic needs drives alienation, the sense that where we live is separate, not part of a community. Lots of opportunities for the party here.

  • Peter Davies 31st Oct '26 - 11:56am

    London is a special case. There wasn’t enough undeveloped land without planning permission sold to get an accurate figure. What matters is what developers think will happen in the long term. Large developers are certainly land banking. They only start the planning process as early as they do because they expect to get a better deal the longer it takes.

  • Pawel Urbanski 31st Oct '26 - 12:26pm

    This subject needs far more attention and more noise from Liberal Democrats, particularly in London. Rob’s direction is right, and the report is useful. But we cannot overlook one thing: in London this year the problem is not permission; it is building. Only 5,500 private homes were started in 2025, down more than 80% from ten years ago. At the same time, more than 4,000 finished homes stood unsold, the highest number ever recorded. Also, permission is not a home. More than 200,000 homes in London have permission and haven’t started on site, and permission that doesn’t start does not affect rents.
    I would put more focus on the levers a Mayor or a council can use now: buy unsold homes for key workers and for families in temporary accommodation, as Lib Dem Richmond has started to do; let councils assemble the empty floors above high streets, where the barrier is fragmented ownership and a separate front door, not planning; and give the building safety regulator the staff to clear its queue. We can do all of this now, and it would make a difference.

  • I would have thought one of the biggest barriers to buildings getting built is the supply of materials and the availability of competent staff to turn those materials into a house. There certainly doesn’t seem to be a large number of idle trades workers around just waiting for housing projects to be approved!

    Approving planning permission twice as fast doesn’t mean that there’ll be twice as many houses built, it just means that the constructors need their pipeline of “sites in planning” to be half as big as it currently is. Maybe you’d get a very short-term blip while everything adjusted, or maybe there’d be a bunch of sites with some token construction started (so it doesn’t lose planning permission again) then waiting three years at that stage for the building teams to get there.

  • @cim, when there is demand for workers, people train in the relevant skills – just look at Milton K, which builds far more houses relative to population than most places, and runs out of neither bricks nor brickies (etc). It is important to offer small sites as well, so that small builders who cannot and do not want to sit on land forever can get in the market. That is how we built so many houses in the interwar era, making a home more affordable than ever

  • Nonconformistradical 1st Nov '26 - 9:57am

    “supply hasn’t kept up, constrained by planning rules that prioritise golf courses over house building.”

    How much land which has not already been concreted over should be built on and which land?

    Rob – are you proposing to build on flood plains – a major property insurance risk?

    https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/feb/18/one-in-nine-new-homes-in-england-built-in-areas-of-flood-risk-study-shows
    “One in nine new homes in England built between 2022 and 2024 were constructed in areas that could now be at risk of flooding, according to new data.

    The figures show the number of homes being built in risky areas is on the rise – a previous analysis showed that between 2013 and 2022, one in 13 new homes were in potential flooding zones.”

  • According to AI.. “Council housing is considered one of the highest-yielding social infrastructure investments available to the public sector, generating a direct benefit-to-cost ratio of 3.4. Independent economic modeling shows that a sustained programme to build social rent homes adds tens of billions to the economy, breaks even in roughly 11 years, and eventually creates an entirely self-sustaining profit for the taxpayer.”.

    So, if during our tenure in government we had insisted on such a programme, thousands more families would be in secure accommodation and the UK would be making a profit.. Of course the same could be said for EVERY post Thatcher administration..

  • Peter Davies 1st Nov '26 - 10:51am

    “AI” searches are still just searches with the ability to check sources and methodology removed.

  • @Nonconformistradical

    The building of house in flood risk areas is creating something of a ticking timebomb.

    The current ‘Flood Re’ arrangement which means flood insurance is manageably affordable will come to an end in 2039. That might look comfortable long term but it isn’t really in terms of property ownership. It is expected that there will have been mitigation measures put into place in that time to reduce future insurance costs.

    To give some idea of scale, Pre-FloodRe my home insurance was in the region of £1800 – when it came in that dropped down to c.£250 a year. The total insurance claim after I was flooded in 2015 probably ran to over £50k (all costs 2015 figures)

  • @ “The building of house in flood risk areas is creating something of a ticking timebomb”

    The way we do it, it is. However, other countries appear to use house designs that are built to withstand flooding such as by raising the height of the house with stilts or devoting the ground floor to garages with the house above.

  • @Noncom… In London of course most existing houses are already built on a flood plain and that is why we have the barrier. In any case, the main way to get more homes in London is by making the centre looks a bit more like Paris, or some suburbs a bit more like Islington.
    @expats – The report you found was paid for by Shelter and house builders. Take with a very large pinch of salt. The idea that social housing is profitable for government is implausible – if it was, I promise you HMT would have done it years ago!!

  • “As a point of info, Flood Re only covers homes built before 1 Jan 2009.”

    Well I learnt something new today! My (former) house (indeed probably all the at risk housing in my old village) was very very pre-2009!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • David Evans
    Simon Robinson Please see my response to Cj above and reconsider your view that "I’m not convinced that the EU allows us to hold either company to account ...
  • David Evans
    Cj, I really do chuckle at the idea that individuals (one at a time) not using the services of Amazon, Google etc would mitigate in any way at all against the ...
  • Simon Robinson
    Claiming that Amazon and Google damage society, without also acknowledging the good they do, paints a bit of a misleading picture. Amazon has enabled us all to ...
  • David Raw
    It would be helpful if candidates could give much fuller biographies, i.e. : age, length of party membership, education, employment experience, po...
  • David Raw
    Could I (in a neutral and evenhanded way) enquire whether there are any candidates for office in the 'English Party' from areas outside of London and the Home C...