Julian Huppert MP writes: Hargreaves and site-blocking: a good start

I was pleased when Vince Cable announced, yesterday, the government’s response to the Hargreaves Report. Like many people who are interested in IT & IP, I was pretty worried that it might turn out to be another damp squib, where an eminent academic publishes a set of excellent proposals, only for the government to fail to act. This, of course, is what happened after the Gowers Review.

Thankfully the Coalition is supporting all ten of Professor Hargreaves’ recommendations. They are important copyright reforms that could add as much as £7 billion, or 0.6%, to the UK economy – most welcome at a time of wider financial difficulty. I hope that most Lib Dems would instinctively recognise that moves to encourage parody and satire are desirable, and as for format-shifting – copying CDs to your iPod, for instance – the exceptions to copyright there are long overdue.

Vince also announced that the government would no longer be attempting to implement the site-blocking measures in the Digital Economy Act. As regular readers of this website will know, the repeal of the file-sharing measures in the DEA has long been one of my political priorities, and I have written frequently and sometimes at length to update Lib Dems on its lack of progress – which I welcome!

But as Paul Thompson has already suggested, this cannot be considered a total victory by any means. The reason the government has given for the abandonment of these measures is not one based on principle, but one based on redundancy: that following the judgement last week forcing BT to block Newzbin, rights holders now have another way forward.

I think there’s quite a lot here to be cautious about. While it’s a good thing that another report has shown the DEA to be a singularly flawed piece of legislation – hardly surprising, given its history – I won’t be satisfied until we have a genuinely liberal approach to copyright and piracy in place. That sort of approach must prioritise clear legal process and a proper evidence base – not selective data from precisely those organisations most likely to benefit from draconian legislation.

Our forthcoming policy paper, produced by the working group I had the honour of chairing, will also contribute to the debate around these issues. Liberal Democrats have a great opportunity to influence the direction of Britain’s digital policy. Yesterday was a good example of what can be achieved – but there is always more to be done!

Julian Huppert is the Member of Parliament for Cambridge. He recently chaired the Liberal Democrat policy working group on Information Technology.

Read more by or more about , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Andrew Suffield 4th Aug '11 - 6:58pm

    Keep doing what you’re doing.

  • Good news at last.

  • Yes, but cases under s97A of the 1988 Act involve detailed analysis of what is reasonable and possible, on a case by case basis. The scrapped measures were, apart from being redundant, also deemed to be unworkable and unmanageable.

    Yet the filesharing measures involving subscribers, implicity requires them to adopt “reasonable measures” to prevent shared connections from being used for copyright infringement. If a workable and manageable solution does not exist which can achieve that on the ISP side of the modem, then where is this magical solution that subscribers are expected to implement on their side.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Cassie
    Martin, I can only suggest you look at the figures for the UK re Covid cases and deaths. The UK is getting close to your emergency situation again, in spite of ...
  • matt
    @Martin You asked me to google c4 fact checker on masks, so I did. I presented you with the information that it contains and the links it provides. How is i...
  • Russell Simpson
    As a kiwi from Southland (who's been living in the UK for 35 years) I well remember the UK joining the EEC. It had a huge impact on rural NZ. One impact was a h...
  • Martin Frost
    So what you are saying Cassie is that if the intentions are well-meaning (even if misguided) then it is OK? Didn't Mao think it a similar way? Iam sorry but I ...
  • Cassie
    Martin, you are missing my point. I am not arguing for or against the specific public health measure you are so fiercely opposed to. I am saying that bringing i...
Thu 28th Oct 2021