Lib Dems to join Brown cabinet?

That’s the startling story in today’s Guardian, which reports:

Gordon Brown and Sir Menzies Campbell, the Liberal Democrat leader, have held private discussions in recent days about a plan for one or two senior Lib Dems to join Mr Brown’s first cabinet, the Guardian has been told by a well-placed source. It is being emphasised that the discussions have not been about a coalition and may not have been conclusive.

The comments of the quoted party spokesmen do not refute the story, which by implication suggests there’s something to it:

One of Sir Menzies’s closest aides, Lord Kirkwood, issued a qualified denial last night but declined to deny the story of recent discussions. He said: “We are getting this sort of speculation all the time from people who want to write stories about cooperation [between the parties] at levels which are in their imagination.
“But they [Mr Brown and Sir Menzies] talk all the time, they talk about Fife and other things. If you start getting into particular meetings it’s impossible. This suggestion is not known to me and not admitted. Some of these players do have to trust each other in relationships one-to-one.”
A spokesman for Sir Menzies said: “We are not commenting on this tittle-tattle or any other story based on rumour and speculation, now or in the future. We are an independent party which firmly disagrees with Labour and Gordon Brown on the issue of Iraq, civil liberties, including ID cards and 90-day detention, nuclear power and council tax to name but a few.”

What do LDV readers think of this development? Three questions occur:

1. Is it tenable for Lib Dems to serve in a Labour cabinet, but for the party to maintain it’s not in coalition with Labour?
2. Who would serve, and in what capacity? Nick Clegg at the Home Office? Vince Cable at a Treasury spin-off department?
3. What Lib Dem policies is it believed one or two Lib Dems serving in a Brown cabinet could have implemented?

For me the answers to questions 1 and 3 are “no” and “nothing” respectively (which makes question 2 rather redundant).

As a party which believes in proportional representation, and the breaking down of petty tribalism in favour of mature cross-party working, we will at some time have to think about what this might mean in reality – which will often be uncomfortable. However, we don’t have PR yet, and careless coalition whispers without it being in place strike me as foolhardy.

For years, the Lib Dems operated a firm policy of ‘equidistance’ between Labour and the Conservatives, a concept which was, perhaps understandably, dropped by Paddy Ashdown during the derided fag-end of the last Tory Government.

But tactically, strategically, and in principle equidistance is the policy which best fits a spiky, independent, liberal democratic party.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in News.


  • Edward Davey 20th Jun '07 - 9:09am

    For the record, there is no prospect of any Liberal Democrat joining the Brown Government.

  • Phew – long winded comment narrowly averted by Ed’s response. Well done Ed.

    I think most of us would be appalled at the prospect of LibDem MPs proping up this governmemnt in the final year(s) before a general election (however much some of them might want to get behind >that

  • Peter McGrath 20th Jun '07 - 10:51am

    I think the headline here is ‘Guardian provides cheap kite, Iain Dale tries to fly it.’

  • Climb every stairway 20th Jun '07 - 11:06am

    Nick Robinson says it is true and that it maybe Lib Dem peers joining.

  • 1 NO!

    2 & 3 therefore irrelevant.

  • Jeremy Sanders 20th Jun '07 - 12:24pm

    I suspect that this whole story is more about Brown (or more likely one of his supporters) trying to give out the message “we would be prepared to work with the Lib Dems in future”, than anything to do with us. Nick Robinson’s suggestion that there is some difference between having Lib Dem peers in a Labour cabinet, and Lib Dem MPs is just plain silly.

  • dprendergast 21st Jun '07 - 10:38am

    please do not do deals with the devil

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Stephen Glenn
    Willie I would love there to be a world in which those of us who stand up and defend trans rights can disagree well with those who are gender critical. The p...
  • Michael KilpatrickMichael Kilpatrick
    It has just been intimated to me that the working group for this paper were expressly forbidden from considering further taxation changes in conjunction with th...
  • Mary Regnier-Wilson
    To be clear when I say there are things that we should be discussing a society, I mean things like how we ensure sex and relationship education doesn’t exclud...
  • Andrew Hickey
    "I’m a liberal and a contrarian, when everyone is agreeing with each other I want to start poking holes." That must be very nice for you, to be able to t...
  • Mary Regnier-wilson
    This post may well have been perfectly valid 10 years ago. There are things to be discussed as a society about how we as a society deal with a growing number of...