Love is not enough

`Love is Enough’ is a wonderful song. Well done to Ed Davey and the Bath Philharmonia Young Carers Choir on having targeted the target Christmas  Number 1 spot. As a sentiment, though, it only reflects one side of the essential components that make us who we are as a political movement and segment of British society.  

At Party Conference in Bournemouth in 2023, I helped found a new Affiliated Organisation called Liberal Democrat Friends of Ukraine, focusing primarily on the bellicose military objective of helping Ukraine to defend itself against Putin’s aggression. Humanitarian support and reconstruction aid are our other priorities. It was the right thing to do – for Ukraine but also for Britain.

That Conference in September 2023 passed a belligerent motion urging the Government, `in defence of liberal values’, to:-

Do all it realistically can, in view of Putin’s brazen actions, to help arm Ukraine, including with longer-range precision weapons,…. to defeat Russia. Continue to strengthen the supply of British arms and ammunition to Ukraine… 

Fantastic. Lib Dem Friends of Uraine works closely with sister AOs like the Armed Forces and Hong Kong. We are about values. Membership of Lib Dem Friends of Ukraine alone has surged to about 350, much of it since Brighton 2024. So many Party members care about this.

Standing back from the `Peace Dividend’ mindset that has catastrophically got us, since 1989, to where, militarily, we are now, we can see how Utopian the daydream was.

Liberal, advanced democracies, including ours, have slid into a vicious circle of 1939 ostrich groupthink.

All parties seem to think that voters would question whoever was honest enough to spell out the substantially higher share of GDP that would be needed to re-arm, and adequately defend Ukraine and ourselves.

Responding to this, they collectively encouraged voters to believe that there was no danger – leaving the UK insufficiently capable, apart from our excellent at sea nuclear deterrent.

The last GE campaign was classic. All parties, including ours, sidestepped to give national security, and rearmament, sufficient prominence. Media, led by the BBC, joined the silent conspiracy. So these became non-issues. Yet (with Ukraine our front line) they’re the biggest issue of our time.

Despite his `warts’ obvious today, Churchill, with his infectious bravery, still has much to teach us. He combined political know-how, brilliant oratory to inspire ordinary men and women, and a lifetime’s experience and understanding of war. This Tory then Liberal then Tory was able to get attention.

We need some Churchill-like innovation and determination. Our AOs (Friends of Ukraine and of the Armed Forces), combined with one in nine of our MPs who are ex-military together make a formidable, excellently informed team to voice truth to power. 

The task is to provoke discussion and discourse. 

Get people in progressive politics, like Lib Dems, take the lead national in defiance of Putin, whose ultimate aim is to destabilise and control Europe as this Economist article argued last month. There is increasing pressure for the UK to move towards spending 3% of GDP on Defence. A big debate to have.

A Russian attack on a NATO country by 2030 is a real possibility, some commentators appear to think.

How to pay for this, including military support for Ukraine? Options exist worthy of debate:

Confiscate frozen Russian assets here. A Finnish court has boldly ordered seizure of Russian assets after Russia failed to pay £4.6bn to compensate the Naftogaz Group after its occupation of Crimea in 2014.

Take the painful step of reviewing taxes or cutting certain public spending to allow for substantially increased spending on defence. Freedom costs.

A new and less seismic idea (at least mitigating the above agonising option) is to raise £250bn, for building up capacity and kit over the next five years, through a `coalition of the willing’ in Europe, supported by pledges of higher future defence spending (4). 

Ed Davey recently called on Keir Starmer to hold a `Save Ukraine’ summit of European leaders in London.  Sadly, Love is just not enough. The Hard Talk starts now. 

Our Party can make the difference (eventually harvesting many more votes) if direction comes at pace. 

Our 72 MPs and more than 70 Peers are the first line of persuasion to make greatly increased defence and security spending a central part of any considered UK government platform, as well as love. Good people in the party membership exist who value progressive values, practical politics and a patriotic responsibility to defend the Realm. Time for action. 

These are my personal views rather than a statement from Lib Dem Friends of Ukraine

 

 

* Tony Paterson was the Co-Founder and first Chair of Liberal Democrat Friends of Ukraine. He is now an Executive Committee member. A retired Solicitor for asylum seekers, he is a Lib Dem member of Richmond Council.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

6 Comments

  • CllrNoelHadjimichael 23rd Dec '24 - 1:22pm

    It is good to see Tony’s contribution articulate some real world challenges for us as a political party and a major force in the Parliament. The Ukraine conflict is such a serious threat to our security let alone the broader European and Global situation. Having active, conscientious and robust AOs working in close alignment with Peers and MPs in the subject areas is no luxury. It is in our national interest. As incoming (1 Jan 2025) Chair of the LibDems of the Armed Forces (and a fresh committee recently elected) we aim to lend our voice to progressive, practical and patriotic responses to the 2025 we are facing. Liberals have always been defenders of values in hard times.

  • Tristan Ward 23rd Dec '24 - 2:04pm

    I think Tony is absolutely right on this.

    As I understand it, the UK cannot today meet its NATO commitment to put two divisions “on the ground” in Europe should need arise. We may not even be able to deliver one.

    Politically, the Conservative’s failures to ensure proper defence of the country can be exposed, along with Farage’s sympathies with Putin. It’s worth recalling that in the 1930s it was the right that were the appeasers, not the liberals and left. With luck we may be able to label the Tories and Farage “the new appeasers” or similar.

  • Jonathan Brown 23rd Dec '24 - 4:26pm

    Very well said Tony. You’re right, freedom does cost. And paying to help Ukraine now will be far, far cheaper in the long run than letting the country be overrun and an emboldened Putin launch fresh attacks on us and our other allies in the years ahead.

    Although I would add to that, I think the danger is at least as much from the message it sends to other dictators and wannabe dictators and to the catastrophic impact it would have on the morale of democracies. We need authoritarians to understand that we will not sit passively while our societies are undermined from within and gobbled up piecemeal from without. Because if we don’t make them understand this, this is what will happen to us.

  • Zachary Adam Barker 27th Dec '24 - 8:34pm

    Tony Pearson. I have sent your group 2 emails asking to join. Please could you respond?

    We need to present a bolder long term plan for Ukraine with some backbone. Piecemeal aid packages won’t cut it anymore. Estonia has the right idea, constant support looking at time frames over years.

  • Helen Dudden 1st Jan '25 - 6:14pm

    Love is not enough. Respect and being an individual in your own right. Often loving yourself to be able to be loved.
    My father who was in the army said war does not put much right.

  • Peter Hirst 3rd Jan '25 - 2:37pm

    Love is enough if you include actions coming from love that include defending our motherland, protecting Ukraine and preventing violence wherever we can. Acting from love is well known to parents, close friends and members of organisations. Sometimes it is challenging to defend actions and this might be because we have lost the love.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

This post has pre moderation enabled, please be patient whilst waiting for it to be manually reviewed. Liberal Democrat Voice is made up of volunteers who keep the site running in their free time.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Jenny Barnes
    I'd be interested to know if Daisy Cooper thinks that just cutting taxes will create economic growth. Would that growth increase activity enough to compensate...
  • Nigel Jones
    Likewise the many passages in both Old and New Testaments that show God's strong care for the poor. Then there are the prophets' attacks on leaders who don't ca...
  • Nigel Jones
    We read in Luke's gospel that a group of Jewish people attempted to kill Jesus because he preached a message about occasions when prophets working under God aid...
  • Peter Davies
    @Roland Absolute poverty in India has dramatically declined since 1993. A new rich and a large middle class has emerged but the poor are better off too....
  • Roland
    >” witness India’s miserable economic progress from 1947 until the Manmohan Singh reforms of 1993.” Shame the economic benefits seem to have benefited...