NEW POLL: what do you make of the Pre-Budget Report?

We now know the details of Alastair Darling’s ‘crisis budget’, the PBR. The Guardian has a brief run-down of the headline changes here, chief of which are:

• VAT to be cut from 17.5% to 15% from Monday until 2010
• Top rate of income tax to rise to 45% on those earning more than £150,000 – the top 1% of earners – from 2011
• Allowances to be raised, so this will be worth £145 a year to 22 million basic-rate taxpayers
• National Insurance to rise by 0.5% on all rates of national insurance from 2011

The big question is: will it work? Here are your options in our new poll:

>> The Government’s financial stimulus is spot-on, will get the economy moving again, and pay for itself in the medium-term

>> A number of the Government’s measures are welcome, but overall the impact will be too small and the cost too great

>> The Government’s measures will have virtually no effect on the coming recession, and will result in recklessly high levels of borrowing

>> Don’t know

As ever, feel free to put forward your own more nuanced views in the comments thread below…

Read more by .
This entry was posted in News.


  • Its all very well taxing the rich at 45% from 2011 but who actually belives that once the Tories get into power they will keep that in place. The rich in this country do not pay their share of the tax.

  • Mike, what on earth are you talking about? The richest 10% pay around 50% of all income tax, and the richest 2% pay nearly one third. How is that ‘not paying their share’?

    If you and 9 friends go for a beer and spilt the bill as we pay taxes, the richest man will pay for half the drinks. If you insist that he should pay more, he might stop coming all together, at which point you all have to pay more – just because you wanted your rich friend to subsidize you more.

  • David Allen 25th Nov '08 - 3:25pm

    You have one option that says “it’s perfect”, and two options which both basically say “it’s a mistake”. I guess the official party view would summarise as “there’s plenty wrong with it but it is better than doing nothing”. That could only be recorded as “don’t know”!

  • Do the Liberal Party have any other MPs apart from Vince Cable and just how off the radar would they be without him?

  • David Morton 27th Nov '08 - 12:11pm

    Rightly or wrongly Labour seem to have cornered the market in terms of perceptions of crisis management. They own the “Do Something” franchise. Remarkably the Tories are putting there own head in the noose of the “Do Nothing” party though in fairness they sem to have ownership of the “its going to be a Disaster” Franchise.

    To date via the Stella, simply Stella, performance of Vince Cable the party has ben able to own the “We saw it comming” franchise. In effect we occupy the narrative of the lone genius/whisteleblower ignored by authority for so long as disater approached.

    However in narrative story telling the hero doesn’t find redemption by being right. He/she finds it being mitigating disater or leading the way out.

    In January to June 2009 the political space will be for how this should never happen again. So far we have been weak on this. My instinct is that so much of the talk of the tax cuts is all about restoring the status quo ante rather than describing why the status quo ante is inheritantly unstable.

    people are in genuine shock so i shouldn’t be so critical about offerring sygary tea and sympathy at the moment. thats how you treat shock.

    However we are in a classic two party squeeze the moment both in terms of the polling ( all the non ICM stuff is truely grim) and in terms of media coverage.

    The only way to break this is to move outside the consensus and say someting distinctive. The ” Never Again/ A better Future ” slot in the market is there fore the taking. In the New Year when the disater movie stuff about international conferences and £300bn bail outs in over ( hopefuly) and the grim monotony of a recession January kicks in then thats where the party needs to go. I’d suggest five headings which the blogosphere has already started to muse about.

    1. End Property Bubbles. Define the worst cases and gear against them.

    2. bring “polluter pays” tax principals to Credit Creation

    3. have the courage to say consumerism doesn’t make you happy

    4. dust off tobin tax principlas on all sorts of speculation and link it to decarbonisation

    5. talk afresh about volunteerism.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • David Allen
    Not all wars are like WW2. Some, like Korea, end in stalemate. Others, like Afghanistan, end very badly. In WW2, the Allies didn't only reject appeasement....
  • Chris Rennard
    It is sometimes claimed that we “underperformed” in 2005 when I was Chief Executive and Charles Kennedy was Leader. But electing 62 MPs, tripling our Westm...
  • David Raw
    Michael Bukola hits the spot. My advice to Sir Edward would be to avoid any interview with Andrew Neil under any and every circumstance....
  • Chris Rennard
    I do not think that those people seeking to see a sharper focus for us on some high profile issues are seeking for us to be a “think tank”. Whilst I would ...
  • David Raw
    @ Paul Fox. Some good and interesting points, Paul, and of course Paddy had charisma, an interesting hinterland, and could make an inspiring speech....