Observations of an ex pat: Wanted – Helmsman

The good ship Europa is without a helmsman, rudderless, and drifting aimlessly through the stormy seas, dangerous shoals and shark-infested waters of Brexit, immigration, a stagnating economy, Russian aggression, Chinese perfidy, American tariffs and Donald Trump’s unilateralism.

Ship Europa is in desperate need of a captain who can repair the damage and set the ship back on a course which its bickering crew can agree upon.

Traditionally, the role has fallen to the one of the two continental giants—France or Germany—and sometimes, during calm and sunny periods—the  former rivals  together. Italy and Britain have played roles as first officers, providing political ballast to one or the other would be captains. There has even been the occasional triumvirate

Well you can forget about Britain. It is too busy jumping ship and setting off in the same storm-tossed sea in a leaky dinghy with a tenth  of the cargo. As for Italy, well its far left/far right coalition is busy drilling holes in the ship’s hull. Meanwhile, the newly recruited officers from Eastern Europe are plotting mutiny.

The crew and passengers had high hopes of German Chancellor Angela Merkel and perhaps even higher hopes of the young determined-speaking French President Emmanuel Macron. The problem is that the ship is constructed as a collection of nation states held together by the collective will of its citizens. It is not a single unitary political structure.

Being a collection of democratically-organised nation states means that it is a prerequisite that the ship’s officers have the financial and political support of the people back in their respective home ports. Angela Merkel had that support for many years and is acknowledged to have been a great helms person. Then she ran into the immigration problem.  Her decision to allow in a million-plus refugees in 2015 was a moral triumph and a political disaster.  The immigration issue has been the main cause of the split within Germany’s coalition government and resulted in her relinquishing the leadership of the Christian Democratic Union. Angela Merkel is effectively now a lame duck chancellor and extra ballast on Ship Europa.

Eager Beaver Emmanuel Macron has been quick to offer himself for the job.  He proposed a European finance ministry, integrated tax structures and a new European defence force.  And it looked as if he had the credentials: a fresh-faced, confident, multilingual, ex –banker and economics minister who had been swept into office on an electoral tsunami.   He had everything, but most important of all, he had the support of a large French national base.

Not anymore. The confidence turned to arrogance and Macron’s position in the popularity polls sunk almost as quickly as it had risen.

A perennial problem for successive French presidents has been the politics of the street. Sarkozy, Mitterrand, Chirac… they have all called for reform of stultifying regulations governing agriculture, working hours, tax structures and a host of other areas where outdated practices were holding back the French economy and restricting France’s role in the world. On each occasion they were forced to back down when the people took to the streets. Macron declared:  “Pas Plus!” He would introduce reforms and stand firm.

His firmness may have worked if he had picked the right plank on which to stand. Unfortunately raising fuel taxes was the wrong one. It may have been good for the environment, but it hit hardest the traditionally politically active group that could least afford to tighten their belts—the rural poor. After weeks of rioting Macron was forced to climb down. Politics is an unforgiving business. Once you slide down the slope it becomes slippery and harder to climb back up, and the jackals at the bottom increase exponentially.

Macron remains the most likely ship’s captain, but  l’affaire des gilets jaunes has seriously weakened his authority at home and abroad at a time when both France and Europe need a firm hand on the tiller


* Tom Arms is foreign editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and author of “The Encyclopedia of the War” and the recently published “America Made in Britain". He has a weekly podcast, Transatlantic Riff.

Read more by .
This entry was posted in News.


  • You might care to read the ALDE manifesto which is all about changing the EU whilst supporting its continuation. In terms of leadership, our very own Guy Verhofstadt, former Belgium Prime Minister and now our leader in the European Parliament, is a charismatic speaker and very keen to make changes. You can follow this link: https://www2.aldeparty.eu/r?u=kG5Fq_0UpGPF4ssiTmvUo_YvVd1zcLLFASE8XWydLtq3nHshcU0V5gjHsIxgB0jG4Fslmoj2sIiQgmJrbbQhVrMH4kamTvzLKKo4aHHjJNI&e=185f4c49cd5a201dffb928ac5ee8fe7b&utm_source=aldeparty&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=newsletter_12december&n=11

  • Richard Underhill 14th Dec '18 - 11:50am

    Remember that Angela Merkel is an Ossie. “The Ossies said ‘We are one people’.”
    “The Wessies said ;We are too’.” Unifying Germany is bound to be a slow process.
    Housing the asylum seekers was a big job, but the Germans were well organised and proceeded to process the applications. There will inevitably be a high proportion of refusals of applicants who cannot credibly claim to have suffered persecution individually for a Convention reason.
    If there is another wave of asylum seekers this summer Germany is unlikely to repeat their generous offer.
    Children and grandchildren of Gastarbeiter who were born in Germany should be allowed to progress towards citizenship, some are white-skinned Catholics from the form Yugoslavia, others are ethnic Turks.

  • Richard Underhill
    ethnic Kurds

  • My first reaction is, no we don’t need a strong leader. We need strong democratic institutions and an ability for all of us to have access to genuine news about what is going on in the world.
    As far as Angela is concerned she may have been an Ossie, but not a typical Ossie, since her family moved from Hamburg. Her father by all accounts was free to move between East and West. And of course she spent some years in Moscow and speaks Russian, having won a prize as a student for her Russian.
    It is difficult to find the views of people who lived in the East of Germany at reunification because many moved West. For example Frankfurt (Oder) on the Polish border quickly lost over a third of its population. However the population of the rest of Germany started to decline as well. The introduction of young people from outside helps to supply workers who can support the economy and support the older people.
    Britain of course had the same situation, but the decline was masked by the higher level of immigration.

  • Peter Hirst 15th Dec '18 - 5:15pm

    Who needs a captain? In a true democracy, the leadership is provided by a Group who are representatives of the components of it. I like the rotating presidency concept if you need an administrative leader.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Michael BG
    Roland, As I have already stated there should be a work allowance for everyone - an amount they receive before they lose any benefit. I am thinking of over ...
  • Katharine Pindar
    William Beveridge didn't in the 1940s know anything about payouts being clawed back by taper rates. He simply wanted a system by which everyone, working or not,...
  • Michael BG
    Peter Davies, You didn’t say what amount of Local Housing Allowance your single person with two children is getting. For Inner South West London a category...
  • Steve Trevethan
    Thank you....
  • Andrew Melmoth
    @Fiona No-one has put forward a credible reason why an independent Scotland wouldn't be able to join the EU. But even if there was some impediment there is no ...