Opinion: Greens may do well in Haltemprice and Howden

The decision by the Lib Dem leadership to allow David Davis to resign in the comfortable knowledge that no Liberal Democrat would oppose him was a strange one. Without Lib Dem acquiescence, the by-election almost certainly would not have taken place. As it is, it seems unlikely to me to do much to fracture the Tories’ current revival, and it may allow the party’s opponents to gain valuable ground, and not just in Haltemprice and Howden.

Who, then, might do well enough in the by-election to gain ground while the Liberal Democrat by-election machine twiddles its thumbs? Could someone from the ranks of the Independent candidates gain votes on the ‘42 days’ issue? Ealing vicarage rape victim Jill Saward has attracted some publicity for her stand. Or the horrible National Front (neither the BNP nor UKIP are standing) might do well by attracting immigrant-haters who disagree with Davis’s stand. Or perhaps no-one will seriously trouble him, since The Sun failed to stump up the money for Kelvin Mackenzie to take Davis on.

However, my own view is that the Green Party is best placed to use the Haltemprice and Howden by-election to gain ground. They have far better civil liberties credentials than David Davis. He is pro-death penalty, pro-28 day detention, against the Human Rights Act, and supported the Government ban on demonstrations within a mile of Parliament. Giving the Greens a free run against him in this by-election has allowed them the opportunity to test their potential in a race where they can present themselves as the only left-leaning opposition to the Tories.

And the Greens are becoming better organised at first-past-the-post politics. They managed 22% and a close third behind Labour and the Tories in Brighton Pavillion at the last election. And at local government level in Norwich, where the Lib Dems ran City Hall as recently as 2006, they are now the official opposition to Labour. All of the Green gains have been deliberately targeted at Lib Dem expense, and all in what should have been a strong Liberal Democrat Parliamentary prospect at the next election. The Greens are no doubt campaigning hard in Haltemprice and Howden, reinforced by clever campaigners from Norwich, Brighton and elsewhere.

And while much comment about the Henley by-election has centred on Labour’s dreadful fifth place, hardly anyone seemed to notice that the Green Party came third. Their vote share, with a strong Liberal Democrat campaign, was less than 4%, but it will be interesting to see how much the Greens can improve this share with no Liberal Democrat effort at all.

Their immediate task has been a difficult one, given the short notice of this by-election – less than a month from Davis’s resignation to polling day. They may not have had the time to make a very significant impact in a seat they have never contested before. So a Green win on Thursday is very unlikely. Even on a very low turnout, with Green student campaigners just starting their long vacation. Even roundly attacking Davis’s record on the very liberties he claims to be upholding. And even with the Tories divided over Davis’s stance, but complacently assuming he will win easily anyway.

In such circumstances however, a good second place does not seem outrageously improbable, and may attract national media attention. It may act as a catalyst for further progress. Liberal Democrats leaders may come to regret giving them the opportunity.

* Terry Gilbert is a former Liberal Democrat Parliamentary candidate, and has been a Lib Dem member since 1983.

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in Op-eds and Parliamentary by-elections.


  • David Heigham 9th Jul '08 - 3:09pm

    If the Greens don’t come second in Haltemprice, they are going to be very embarassed.

  • Anders Hanson 9th Jul '08 - 3:30pm

    may attract national media attention. It may act as a catalyst for further progress.

    The only catalyst for further progress would be winning the by-election, which is incredibly unlikely.

    If the Greens get a good second then it will be seen for what it is – the Greens only doing well because no other credible party was standing. It will then soon be forgotten.

  • Of course, the real reason we didn’t run in H&H is because after fighting Crewe and Henley using Rennard’s fairly expensive strategies, our war chest is looking a little depleted at the moment.

  • Tony Greaves 9th Jul '08 - 4:04pm

    Davies is attacking the Liberal Democrats in the Grauniad today for not standing.

    What a slime-bag.

    Tony Greaves

  • In the Guardian – Davis pays back the Lib Dems for stepping aside ….

    Davis is realistic about a likely low turnout in Haltemprice and Howden tomorrow,

    “I’m sorry that Labour and the Liberal Democrats funked it, but we’re still having a good argument and getting the issue raised.” This is true, sometimes to politically suicidal lengths.

  • I’ll be less sceptical of the opportunism shown by the greens if they manage to improve on the free run they’re being given at this by-election when the general election comes round.

    Are they using it as an opportunity to put their arguments and build their organisation or are they really using it as an opportunity to bolster their self-perception by infringing on others core territory?

    Frankly the greens are facing a crisis as their local activism diverges away from their national agenda, while their strategy contradicts their policy proposals. Whatever result they achieve in H&H they will only be delaying the day when they are forced to face the reality of this crunch.

    They are lucky that our abscence from this contest obscures the contradictions in their ranks.

  • David Morton 10th Jul '08 - 2:21am

    The party didn’t see the real signifigance of the Labour Representation Committee till it was too late. I fear we are making the same mistake about the Greens.

  • carbon dave 10th Jul '08 - 1:03pm

    Nobody ever expects a shock result!

    But tomorrow the Greens may well get elected.

    Green is go.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • David Allen
    Calling for a bilateral ceasefire amounts to granting Netanyahu permission to carry on bombing. Demanding that Hamas should somehow prove in advance that they ...
  • Martin Bennett
    David: Thanks for that, actually I got most of it (though you add detail), but if Labour allowed a free vote, many would abstain, some would vote for, but possi...
  • Katharine Pindar
    Thanks for the favourable comments, chaps! But I do hope other party members will take up Callum's offer and write here. In this Election Year. everything the F...
  • David
    Martin, the short version is Labour couldn't vote for the SNP motion because it was a trap. The SNP motion talked about "collective punishment", effectively ...
  • Leekliberal
    Well said Nigel! If our leaders could only say bold Liberal innovative things like this, to include a Palestinian State, instead of our being the reactive 'us t...