Opinion: The gloves are off for the Man in Tights

The House of Commons is an odd place. People try to pretend they don’t know one another’s names even when they do. There’s the curious, formalised sparring by red-faced men who actually quite like each other. And the whole affair is officiated over by a middle-aged metalworker in hosiery, and sometimes a curious wig, referred to only as Mister. It’s like the most surreal fetish party in the world.

Now the first rule of Mister Speaker’s Club is that you do not talk about Mister Speaker. MPs will go on record to criticise their opposing number’s finances, living arrangements, office staff and occasionally even their politics, but not even the most daring and outspoken likes to get on the wrong side of Mr S. And with the present Speaker, Michael Martin, there has been much for them to criticise him about.

Most seriously, there is the Damien Green affair, a sordid tale of police, subterfuge and possible abuse of government power which, if true, should be enough to condemn the Speaker on it’s own – but there is much more. Claims of bias in the chamber, the publicly-funded refurbishment of his home and trips made by him and his wife to destinations as varied as the Bahamas, Hawaii and Harvey Nicks have all popped up as topics for comment by The Observer, the Taxpayers Alliance and former MP Martin bell – so what of his current flock?

Aside from Clare Short suggesting he should soon retire – and she rather has form for that sort of thing – and a smattering of calls to hold inquiries and hearings “sooner rather than later”, you’d have a job to find any MP of any party openly criticising Speaker Martin. Now I confess to a bias; as an adopted Black Country lad, I want Betty back like you wouldn’t believe – Parliament just runs better with a Tiller Girl at the helm – but, even so, I find this astonishing.

A couple of days ago, though, one broke rank – Essex Tory MP Douglas Carswell announced on his blog that the Commons’ Table Office has received and approved the text of a motion he submitted calling on Speaker Martin to resign. Heavy stuff in a culture where even giving an interview against the man is taboo.

It’s early days and this is one of those issues which will either unite or bitterly divide opinion, so I’m getting my two-penneth in now. If this motion gets to the floor, I want to see Nick Clegg leading 62 Liberal Democrat colleagues through the “Aye” lobby to help remove the man who has brought his office into disrepute, overseen the Commons in its darkest hour of recent history, and had his nose in the trough alongside those he should have been reprimanding.

Michael Martin’s supporters will claim he is the victim of class-ism or that the Speaker should be above this sort of criticism. We must be willing to stand up and say that he is being urged to quit, not because he once lived in the centre of Glasgow, or what he did for a living there, but because of what he has been doing since he took up residence in the Palace of Westminster. As for being above criticism “by tradition”, I hope I don’t need to tell anyone the liberal answer to that.

Make no mistake – the Speaker must go, and Liberal Democrats must speak and act to remove him.

* Benjamin Mathis is Vice-Chair of Campaigns for Liberal Youth, and writing in his personal capacity as a Lib Dem member.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds and Parliament.


  • I’m not actually LY’s VC Campaigns anymore, despite what it says at the end of this – just for clarity!

  • I’m not sure we were ever seriously putting Ming forward, were we? It would be unprecedented for a former party leader to do it.

    Increasingly I think the position of speaker is too open to abuse and “getting your feet under the table”. I don’t normally like term limits but maybe there’s something to be said for a fixed one- or two-year term for Speakers.

    In this sort of situation I think we’d have to start seeing it more like a council mayor, with members serving their term and then returning to normal councillor/MP life afterwards.

    Wouldn’t this be better than an indefinite and (traditionally) unchallenged incumbency?

  • Anyone know if Lord Rennard is going to repay his £ 41,678 second home’s claim?

  • Mark Littlewood 14th May '09 - 3:04am

    The headline of this article shoudl be deleted.

    The entire problem is that the gloves are NOT off.

    Why the removal of the Speaker, as an urgent and necessary measure, has been left to Douglas Carswell MP is just amazing.

    It is no his considerable credit and our shame that we have not grabbed this issue by the neck.

  • I think it will now have to be someone like patrick cormack or another older one . Or maybe the independent doctor guy We could have had ming until this week.

  • The most appropriate Liberal Democrat candidate for the Speakership is Alan Beith, and I very much hope that our MPs will put his name forward when the time comes.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Nonconformistradical
    @Christopher Haigh "The constitutional monarchy is there to provide ceremony and tradition and long may it continue." So what happens if the person who inhe...
  • Christopher Haigh
    The prospect of a political head of stare would be truly frightening. The constitutional monarchy is there to provide ceremony and tradition and long may it con...
  • David Evans
    Although an interesting and important topic, I find the content of this article somewhat heavy on the rhetoric, but rather light on factual analysis. For examp...
  • Tom Harney
    I suggest we campaign for a way of writing a constitution for our country. We need to consider the best way of involving our fellow citizens in this. What exact...
  • Matt Wardman
    Over a period of 5 years, that does not to me look too bad. I think the more interesting short-term hit will be the removal of Hereditary Peers. Were I Mr...