Opinion: Why Florence Nightingale should be in the National Curriculum and why Liberal Democrats should want her there

The Secretary of State for Education has decided that Florence Nightingale (1820-1910), famous for the Crimean War (1854-56) and major founder of professional nursing should be thrown out of the National Curriculum. Mary Seacole, who is there now, is to stay. Many Liberal Democrats support this, probably thanks to misinformation in wide circulation from Seacole campaigners.

Nightingale influenced not only Britain but the world on nursing and hospital safety. She brought trained nursing into the dreaded the workhouse infirmaries, beginning in Liverpool in 1865. She called for quality health care for all, including those who could not pay fees (no NHS then). As early as 1864 she argued for the abolition of the punitive Poor Law system, to be replaced by agencies to provide care for the aged, chronically ill, disabled and children.

Nightingale was also a lifelong Liberal (no vote, of course). She wrote campaign letters for suitably progressive candidates, including one for the first Indian MP. She tried to get Gladstone to be more liberal on women and India; he admired her, but did not budge.

She was adept at presenting statistics in arguments for health care reforms, for which she was made the first woman Fellow of the Royal Statistical Society. Do today’s girls have too many role models of effective social reformers, expert at statistics? Britons, male and female, young and old, have benefited from Nightingale’s reforms, and the health care system could use her help now.

What About Seacole?

Mary Seacole was a Jamaican businesswoman who ran a restaurant/bar/store/takeaway/catering service for officers during the Crimean War. She was generous and kind also to ordinary soldiers. She did first aid on the battlefield on three occasions, but missed the first three, major, battles (busy in London on her gold-mining stocks). She gave out tea to cold soldiers waiting transport to the general hospitals. She was an admirable person and her memoir, Wonderful Adventures of Mrs Seacole in Many Lands is still a lively read. There she reports only an amicable relationship with Nightingale (in contrast with the BBC’s numerous attacks on her), never claimed to be a heroine, nor to have won medals for bravery, and never claimed to have pioneered nursing or even to be a nurse.

There also she makes clear that she was three quarters white, proud of her Scots heritage, married to a white man, had a white business partner and an entirely white clientele. She never called herself “black” or “African.” Her frequent racial slurs are understandable in the historical context. But how did she become a “black heroine?

Mrs Seacole should be honoured for her own merits, and not given credit for Nightingale’s. For an expose of the misinformation on her see here.

* Lynn McDonald, PhD, LLD (hon) is a former Canadian MP (New Democrat, related to Labour Party), a sociologist and director of the Collected Works of Florence Nightingale. See her short book, Florence Nightingale at First Hand (Continuum 2010).

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

5 Comments

  • Christine Headley 24th Jul '13 - 12:03pm

    And Florence Nightingale had Bonham Carter cousins (mentioned in Mark Bostridge’s biography of her).

  • Paul Griffiths 24th Jul '13 - 6:30pm

    Liberal Democrat policy is to axe the National Curriculum. Articles like this demonstrate why.

  • Florence nightingale’s hospital killed more people than the other war hospitals. She should get a mention for inventing the pie chart (among other statistical analysis techniques) in response to that fact and for learning from her mistakes and trying to teach others, but the romantic image of the lady with the lamp is pointless.

  • R Uduwerage-Perera 27th Jul '13 - 6:40pm

    History is as has been quoted many times before “written by the victors”, and is general an interpretation of the facts (whatever they might me).

    For me is it important to teach the achievements of both Florence Nightingale and Mary Seacole for they were both remarkable women in a male dominated world. Mary Seacole has further significance for being not only a woman, but a Black woman (using modern terminology) who at a time of gaining notoriety slavery in the UK was a a fresh memory, and in the USA and other places it was still prevalent.

  • R Uduwerage-Perera 27th Jul '13 - 6:42pm

    Apologies for the typo’s. Note to myself, do not tap away on the iPad whilst standing on a train!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarMark Smulian 13th Jul - 9:17am
    Thanks for the post Caron. The simplest way to find them is to search for 'liberal revue' on YouTube. The shows there are from 1988-89,...
  • User AvatarChris Cory 13th Jul - 8:33am
    @David Raw. 12/7, 9.05 I too approve of tax on tobacco, sugar, etc., and like MichaelBG I consider it illiberal. I call this the Liberal...
  • User AvatarPeter Martin 13th Jul - 8:11am
    The assumption always was that Brexit would be more likely to lead to the Scots breaking away from the UK. Scotland was being taken out...
  • User AvatarPeter Martin 13th Jul - 4:06am
    @ Joe B, Thank you for telling us all about the BoE's monetary responsibilities. There's about 150 words or so. You then mention the Govt's...
  • User AvatarMichael BG 13th Jul - 3:05am
    David Raw, I am not against taxing tobacco, sugar or alcohol or petrol. As I wrote, when there is no alternative but increasing prices to...
  • User AvatarJoseph Bourke 13th Jul - 12:19am
    The Bank of England has two main responsibilities. Firstly, to support the government in maintaining macroeconomic stability i.e price stability ( inflation target) and subject...