Our starters for 2010 – how did we do? (Part II)

A year ago, Lib Dem Voice posed 10 questions, the answers to which we believed might shape the Lib Dem year – time to revisit them, wethinks. You can read Part I of our round-up here.

6. Will any of the party’s senior figures – within or without the Lib Dem shadow cabinet – take an official position offered by whoever forms the next government?

When I posed this question I rather had in mind Gordon Brown’s GOAT appointments — such as Lib Dem MP-turned-peer Lord (Matthew) Taylor’s housing review, or Baroness (Shirley) Williams’ advice on nuclear proliferation. What I certainly didn’t expect — who did? — was that Nick Clegg would end the year as Deputy Prime Minister, one of five Lib Dem cabinet ministers, with a further 15 Lib Dem government ministers.

7. Will the party’s December 2010 poll ratings exceed the 19% recorded this year?

Erm, no. Though at the height of ‘Cleggmania’ the Lib Dems were consistently scoring above 30%, the general election saw the party poll 23%, only a notch up on 2005. The party’s decision to enter into a coalition has divided opinion, with many former Lib Dem supporters finding the prospect of sharing power with the Conservatives anathema.

There has been a steady decline in the party’s ratings since May, with ICM — the pollster with the most consistent track record — showing the Lib Dems down at 13% in December 2010. YouGov, whose sheer volume of polls — they accounted for 15 of the 19 December polls — means they are most frequently reported in the media, have tended to be least kind to the Lib Dems outside of election time, and are currently showing us in single digits, aound 8-9%. The hope is this is as low as we will go, though the Coalition’s cuts have yet to start biting.

Though the next general election is supposed to be over four years away — and therefore polls asking how the public would vote if a general election were held tomorrow are utterly hypothetical — this will be of scant consolation to the thousands of Lib Dem councillors and MSP/AM/GLAMs facing re-election in the next couple of years.

For a fair-minded analysis of the Lib Dems’ poll ratings, try Anthony Wells’ UK Polling Report blog-post here.

8. Will the Lib Dems maintain or even better their position in Scotland (12 MPs) and in Wales (4 MPs)?

In Scotland, the party made no gains at the general election, though Mike Crockart safely succeeded John Barrett; and, very sadly, we lost Willie Rennie’s by-election gain in Gordon Brown’s backyard of Dunfermline and West Fife. In Wales, we lost one of the party’s previously safest seats — Montgomeryshire — ascribed to the ‘Lembit effect’, though successfully boosted Mark Williams’ wafer-thin majority in Ceredigion to over 8,000.

All eyes, though, will be on the Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly elections in May. In Scotland, the latest Holyrood opinion poll (compared with the 2007 result) showed the Lib Dems at 11% (16%) in the constituency vote and 9% (11%) in the regional vote.

However, it is in Wales that the polls are showing the Lib Dems worst hit since the general election, with the latest Assembly poll (compared with the 2007 result) showing the party at 6% (15%) in the constituency vote and 5% (12%) in the regional vote. If this were to come to pass, the Lib Dems could be reduced from six AMs to only two.

9. What role will Ros Scott play in the inevitable post-general election inquest? Will she live up to her campaign pledge to be the voice of the membership, and be re-elected President of the Liberal Democrats unopposed; or will she face a challenge? And will the party’s membership increase in the next year?

The overwhelming support among Lib Dem members for the Coalition Agreement reached with the Conservatives — something which no-one would have predicted a year ago — reduced the critical need for the Party President to act as a buffer between the membership and the leadership in May. However, with the Lib Dems now suffering in the polls as the realities of Coalition begin to hit home the role of President has never been as important as it is now.

Ros Scott suprised many in September by announcing her decision not to seek re-election as President, though she was all-but assured a second term (probably without a contest), with her ratings among members, according to Lib Dem Voice’s regular surveys of leading party figures, showing her consistently well-regarded.

So why did Ros stand down? Her own answer was customarily elegant: she felt the party needed a President who was “a strong media performer and tough campaigner”, and that others were better placed than her to fulfil that role. Liberator Magazine speculated the real reason was Ros’s private discontent that Nick Clegg was refusing to give her the access to him she felt she needed to do the job effectively.

Whatever the reason, the result was a contest which pitched current MP Tim Farron against ex-MP Susan Kramer, with Tim narrowly edging out Susan.

As for the party membership figures, well for the first time in many a year they increased substantially. 65,861 ballot papers were issued to paid-up members in the Party President contest; this compared with 58,768 members in December 2009 — an increase of over 10%. Not that this was a surprise to those of us inside the party, who’d seen for ourselves the influx of keen new members during the past year, and especially since the general election.

Will we retain all these members, both new joiners and old stalwarts? It seems unlikely. The recent tuition fees debacle prompted some resignations, and it would be an optimist who believed the next year won’t see further difficulties for the Lib Dems now we’re a party of government.

10. Who will be crowned Lib Dem Blogger of the Year in 2010? Will the number and reach of Lib Dem blogs grow as a direct result of the general election? And will the internet prove decisive in any constituency election race, thanks to either brilliant campaigning or an embarrassing gaffe?

At the fifth attempt, Richard Flowers’ most excellent Very Fluffy Diary of Millennium Dome, Elephant trumped a strong short-list for Lib Dem Voice Blog of the Year. Ryan Cullen’s marvellous Lib Dem Blogs Aggregator continues to form the hub of the party’s blogging action, with the Voice regularly welcoming new additions, and highlighting some of the best of Lib Dem blogging through the Golden Dozen.

One of the great additions to online Lib Dem life in the past year has been the emergence of Simon McGrath’s Vote Clegg, Get Clegg Facebook page. Simon made his personal Lib Dem awards this week — if you’re on Facebook you can read it here — including Reading West’s Daisy Benson as Grassroots Campaigner of the Year, and Sarah Teather as MP of the Year.

I gave my take on the state of the Lib Dem blogosphere here — and as I concluded then:

For the moment, Lib Dems are generally phlegmatic: we knew the potential for unpopularity when we signed up to the Coalition, and can hardly bail out now. But if that situation is sustained, and is reflected in actual elections at the Scottish, Welsh and English local elections next year – and especially if the referendum on the alternative vote is lost – the Lib Dem blogosphere may be the place where members’ discontent manifests itself most publicly.

Yet we can also expect it to be the place which – through its striking devotion to liberalism, diversity, debate, fun and irreverence – will continue day in and day out to remind Lib Dems exactly why it is they joined the party in the first place, and to encourage floating voters wherever they are to test the waters.

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Simon McGrath 1st Jan '11 - 12:15pm

    Thank you!

  • Anthony Wells’ polling report should make chilling reading for any LD member.

    Although I can understand the desire amongst those LD’s who approve of the coalition (or at least are prepared to hold their noses as they try hard to swallow the rat sandwich) to downplay the seriousness of the collapse in support over the past 6 months, I’m not sure that “hoping for the best” represents a credible strategy.

    If, as now seems likely, you lose badly in Oldham & Saddleworth, the local elections in May, and the Scottish and Welsh votes, the only possible positive you will have to fall back on is a yes vote in the AV referendum. If that doesn’t happen, I predict you are more or less finished as an electoral force; you will be lucky to survive as a lame duck adjunct to the Tory party, desperately hoping that things pick up before 2015.

    The long term outlook for the LD’s is, I think, pretty bleak. I think you have comprehensively alienated too many of your erstwhile supporters; they are unlikely to return.

  • Grammar Police 3rd Jan '11 - 12:45pm

    @ Galen10

    I think if you were to learn anything from 2010, it’s how fickle the polls are – and the correlation between polls and reality.

    It’s certainly not good to be on around 12-15% in the polls (YouGov weight very heavily against the Lib Dems because of how far out they were just before the election, when we were polling 27-32% and got 23% – and so I take them with a certain amount of salt) – but we were hitting that and lower during portions of the last parliament.

    Predictions of the end of the Lib Dems as an “electoral force” are more about the wish-fulfilment of the people making them.

  • @ Grammar Police

    I always find it strange how easy people find it to rubbish polls when the results looks bad for them, but rely on them when the news is good. Of course polling isn’t an exact science, but in the long term, the trend in LD support since May 2010 is beyone argument, cavilling at the odd % point or at YouGov’s record can’t hide the fact that LD support has collapsed whichever polling organisation you care to examine.

    As to whether such predictions are wish-fulfillment, only time will tell of course. Obviously LD members and supporters of the Coalition have an axe to grind, and are likely to find comfort where they can. You may well be right; things may change, and the LD’s may come out of the Colaition smelling of roses. You may win the O&S bye election, increase your vote at the local elections and in Scotland and Wales, and contribute to the AV referendum resulting in a yes vote.

    I wouldn’t bet the farm on any of the above however, would you? More to the point, the smart money has to be on the LD’s being punished for their role in the Coalition; the extent to which they can recover from, or even survive, such punishment is the real issue.

    The poll in the Independent (link below) is a weighted average “poll of polls” including ComRes, ICM, Ipsos MORI and YouGov. It shows the LD’s at a historic low of 11% (and even this may be an over-estimate of your current support, as it is unlikely to cover the whole of the tuition fees fiasco).


Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Helen Dudden
    So many in the fast track lane that never provided what they were contracted to supply....
  • nigel hunter
    I trust the MPs are also monitoring the feelings of all trade unions who are considering strike action. The workers hsve not had good pay rises for some time.Eq...
  • Chris Moore
    The fact that some groups are exquisitely offendible and actually or potentially violent should never be a pretext for censorship of views they are unable to to...
  • James Pugh
    @Caron Lots of things to unpack, so I can’t respond to all the problematic things written You do say that you agree that everyone has the right to say t...
  • Jason Connor
    Can't the national government intervene on this issue or is there anything they can do? The SNP are basically discriminating against the residents of Orkney and...