PMQs: education

Some real desperate farce from the House this afternoon. Brown’s answers to Cameron were incredibly poor throughout – “I’m sure that sounded great in the bunker” Cameron said after one particularly otherworldly response. As a further indicator of the standard on the government side, planted questions enable the PM to mention the National Minimum Wage and football, and several involved waving the scary “before 1997” card.

A sneering question comes from a Tory backbencher about bullying in the workplace (vis, Number 10) referring to reports of  “a Whitehall official” throwing office equipment around. Gordon even manages to fluff the answer to this, with a brisk and grim-sounding “Any complaints will be dealt with in the usual manner”. And a Nokia duly flies across everyone’s mental imagery! Does he have a death wish? Opposition genuinely helpless with laughter for once. And oh no! Apparently Gordon Brown is “determined to help LDV”. Spare us!

Anyway, Nick Clegg broached a new subject today, education and youth. He was palpably enraged by the Brown’s big set-piece speech this week on education and children (yes, he made a speech, although you may have been distracted by the swastikas). This was Brown’s “big chance” to address the problems of a care system in crisis, Britain having the unhappiest children in the world, poor literacy rates etc.

The central announcement of this speech was straight out of The Thick Of It – setting up another route for parents to complain about a school’s standards alongside the existing ones. How was this tinkering going to fix the enormous problems attending the education system and the country’s youth, Clegg wanted to know?

Brown answered one demi-clause concerning literacy standards and sat down. He really didn’t get the question, did he?

“There comes a point when stubbornness is not leadership,” Clegg replied “It’s stupidity.” To the resulting roar from the Labour benches, he retorts, “At least I say it to his face!” Aha – overheard in the tea room, perhaps? This government has crimminalised and vilified young people, Clegg goes on, and abandoned a whole generation – and all the Prime Minister can do is make a vaccuous speech to save his political skin.

Incidentally, I haven’t checked but I think I’m right in saying Clegg hasn’t run education up at PMQs before. If we consider PMQs as a sort of thumbnail guide to the issues at the heart of a party’s public discourse, this is a significant new choice. Clegg’s PMQs thumbnails over the past year and a quarter have been the economy,  tax and the Gurkhas. The first and last named are now what you might call “under our belts” issues. Tax shouldn’t, but has, dropped from the public radar at the moment because too many people remain confused about the difference between cuts in the overall tax take and the act of redistributing the existing package.

So now, there’s space in the PMQs thumbnail gallery for young people and education, the platform we’re apparently going in to the next election on, and the build-up starts here. I’m encouraged, as I have been throughout, by the way Clegg talks about young people in prison, the care system and primary education in the same breath. This is the liberal way to look at it. An authoritarian would section off bits of that narrative and label it “crime”.

Apologies for the hiatus in the full publication of this post during wot time I was busy being distracted by a thing.

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in PMQs.
Advert

5 Comments

  • I have to disagree with Frank; I thought the Tories played all the right cards today. People want this government gone; they dont want it to do something about anything; they just want it plain gone and Cameron clearly articulated that in what was a star turn….

    The problem with Clegg is Brown just reels off mindless statistics…unlike last week where Clegg clearly rattled his cage this was a return to the norm…

  • Alix Mortimer,

    Can you not do a report in the nude?

    I would really appreciate that as it would show the LD’s have nothing to hide! 🙂

  • Alix = Fox! 🙂

  • It takes a particularly sad git to post offensive messages on one site then scuttle off to PB.com to boast about having done it!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Peter Chambers
    Thanks @Simon R for the comment. Yes more can be done within the Laws of Thermodynamics, or indeed the more complete Statistical Mechanics. And the UK is in the...
  • Freddie
    Rodrigo, re: a closed matter planetary system - taking your argument as true, can we not overcome this by venturing beyond our planet - mining asteroids, off wo...
  • John Waller
    Tom, I have always agreed with your views. But on Iran mine differ. During the war my Iranian friend sent me the Tiktok link above, and we talked for some tim...
  • David Warren
    The 1924 Labour government was desperate to appear respectable and it achieved that. However they were still brought down by a Red Scare. Returning to office...
  • Paul WalterPaul Walter
    Indeed the book writes extensively on Wedgwood, Haldane and Trevelyan in its "New Labour" section - along with others. Sorry I didn't mention this....