President Xi’s Grand Zero-COVID Reversal: What are the Risks? 

President Xi has announced he will be opening China’s borders to travel by Chinese citizens  from Sunday 8th January,  a fortnight before the start of the 15-day celebration of the Chinese New Year which sees hundreds of millions of Chinese go on holiday inside and outside China to visit family and friends. 

Whilst this is normally a time of celebration, the number of COVID cases in China is rocketing into the hundreds of millions as well. The failure and then sudden reversal of Xi’s zero-COVID policy is a disaster for Chinese citizens. Their plight does not only deserve our fullest attention but any support we can give. 

The answer clearly is to fix the problem at home. However, Xi has turned down German Chancellor Scholz’s offer of our more effective mRNA COVID vaccines whilst not having concentrated on a comprehensive vaccination programme, even with China’s own less-potent vaccines. The cruel illogic of dictatorship is revealed once more, prestige and political survival counting more than life. 

Instead, Xi is putting at risk the health of the rest of the world, the second time COVID is being exported globally after the Chinese Communist Party initially suppressed information on COVID for a month when it appeared in Wuhan in 2019, allowing for its spread.

What should we do? Do the United Kingdom and the rest of Europe feel our citizens are protected enough with our own vaccines to open up to our Chinese visitors? Even if we could be, Xi’s folly is putting at risk those populations such as in Africa and Asia who have not been vaccinated to the same degree as in developed countries.  

The problem is that the Chinese Communist Party has once again clamped down on trustworthy information about what is going on, including to the World Health Organisation. We do not know what new COVID variants are arising. The numbers of COVID infections and deaths declared by Chinese authorities are ridiculously small. We should indeed take our decisions based on medical evidence but it is proven that this is completely unreliable coming from the Chinese authorities.  

Secondly the worldwide spread of COVID from China has already restarted. This week, 52% of passengers arriving in Milan on a plane from China tested positive for COVID. 

The UK government has had a policy of “living with COVID”. Nevertheless, a large influx of infected Chinese visitors into the UK is an unforeseen emergency and runs a high risk. Following decisions made by other countries, it has just been announced that passengers arriving from China to England from 5th January will need to show a negative COVID-19 pre-departure test taken no more than two days prior to departure. 

However, a doctor on CNN recently said all visitors coming from China should be tested immediately before boarding a plane, two days before being not enough given the speed of the spread in China. Japan has already decided to test on arrival.

We do not need more cases in the UK at a time NHS nurses, emergency services and our border force are heavily over-stretched or even on strike. The possible requirement for quarantine hotels, the return of mask wearing as well as increasing racism against people looking Chinese are the last things we need.

It should not be forgotten that this will also impact on Chinese residents in the UK going back to China to visit family and friends for the holidays and then needing to come back.

Suspicions have been raised about Xi’s other motives for opening his borders. Is he practicing hybrid warfare, “weaponising” COVID in an attempt to further destabilise the West? China’s “without limits” friendship with Russia was on display again this week when Xi declared at his videoconference with President Putin that, despite Ukraine, “in the face of a difficult and far from unambiguous international situation, we are ready to build up strategic cooperation with Russia”.  Attempts to weaken liberal democracies can take many forms.

* George Cunningham has been elected to the FIRC 2023-25. He is Chair of the FIRC Subcommittee on China, Chair of Lib Dems Abroad and a Lib Dem member of ALDE Council.

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

7 Comments

  • George Thomas 31st Dec '22 - 7:50pm

    “Following decisions made by other countries, it has just been announced that passengers arriving from China to England from 5th January will need to show a negative COVID-19 pre-departure test taken no more than two days prior to departure. ”

    I’ve worked with people who have tested negative in the morning, tested again due to increased coughing on same day and this second test be positive.

  • Because there is no regular testing in our own country we do not know the situation here. The infection rate appears to remain high. Many countries have low vaccination rates. Should we not try to look for a coherent policy?
    As far as the NHS is concerned we are already beyond the point of collapse. My opinion is that our priority should be reintroducing a health system here.

  • Jenny Barnes 1st Jan '23 - 9:17am

    The UK government has a policy of pretending Covid19 has gone away so that the pressures on the collapsing NHS increase to the point of complete failure. Private healthcare & insurance to be introduced shortly. Poorer people obv don’t need medical care. I’m still wearing masks in public spaces. I believe there are about 1 million cases in the UK now. General election needed now.

  • Mel Borthwaite 1st Jan '23 - 9:47am

    Unless a variant of Covid arrives in the UK against which current vaccinations are ineffective, the days of covid restrictions must remain in the past. People in the UK have had ample opportunity to be vaccinated and we must all now accept living with covid in our midst in the same way we live with flu.

  • Martin Gray 1st Jan '23 - 10:20am

    Ultimately , the lock downs will prove infinitely worse than the disease itself …

  • Helen Dudden 2nd Jan '23 - 9:09am

    My granddaughter works in a hospital, a privately funded hospital and had PPE and access to testing equipment. Her sister in law did not have the same working in a NHS hospital.
    That’s how things are. Are staff in the NHS worth less? In the same breath are private hospital staff worth more?
    The prevention of transmission was a number one incentive.
    That’s the NHS care system, broken by the likes of Jeremy Hunt, who made cut backs and reduced the nursing staff.
    My granddaughter is as committed to good care in her position, as her sister in law in ICU who worked through the pandemic providing care with reduced equipment.

  • Jenny Barnes 2nd Jan '23 - 10:22am

    A proper living with covid policy would include:
    mask wearing in public places
    proper sick pay so those with disease, whether covid, flu, or something else, could stay home rather than go to work and infect people there
    free lateral flow tests so everyone could test themselves before significant social mixing
    campaigns for flu and covid vaccinations ( only 50% of those eligible have had flu jabs)
    AND
    serious money to start fixing social care – bed blocking – A/E wait times, ambulance blocking, Health care backlog, medical staff pay…
    When Hunt was on the health commitee he said social care needed £7 billion. now he’s chancellor, he seems to think £0.5 billion (1 fourteenth!) of that is enough.

    Nope not listening la la la.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • Zachary Adam Barker
    "Ed Davey is the likeliest leader of the current crops of MPs" Then perhaps we should consider allowing the party leader to come from outside of the Commons ...
  • Chris Cory
    The fundamental point behind this piece, that the typical family is £1200 worse off since Rushy Sanuk (as Joe Biden likes to call him) came into office, seems ...
  • Chris Moore
    Ed Davey is the likeliest leader of the current crops of MPs. He may not be particularly charismatic - a common criticism on here - but he's decent and solid an...
  • Chris Cory
    @Steve Trevethan. Dividends paid to the the owners of any company are not inflationary because they are simply a distribution of profits from the companie...
  • Chris Moore
    "Neo-Liberalism" is not dominant. All main parties support a mixed economy with transfers to the poorer off. The devil is in the detail, not in over-arching ...