This is the text of a speech I delivered at a demonstration in London on 11 May 2025 organised by ‘We Democracy’.
Last November, the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants against the Israeli PM Netanyahu and the then defence minister Yoav Gallant. Among the many charges, one egregiously stood out: the war crime of starvation: already then, there were reasonable grounds to believe that Netanyahu and his government have been ‘intentionally using starvation of civilians in Gaza as a method of warfare by depriving them of objects indispensable to their survival, including food, water, and medicine and medical supplies’.
We stand here over two long months since Israel imposed a complete blockade on the Gaza Strip. The hunger and food shortage situation in the Strip is worsening. However, for Israeli ministers and members of Parliament, what we have is a Schrodinger’s starvation: they would tell you, sometimes in the same interview or Knesset hearing, that there is no starvation, it’s all fabrication; but that if there is starvation, it is Hamas’ fault for stealing supplies; and that even if it is not the result of stealing, Hamas is ultimately responsible for the outcome because it continues to hold hostages. The latest ‘creative’ explanation, comes from a UK charity, UKLFI: they claim Israel is helping tackle obesity, which was one of the biggest health issues in Gaza prior to October 7th.
To state the obvious: hostage-taking is a vile, horrendous crime. Hamas’ behaviour is morally depraved. But there is never, ever, justification for a deliberate policy of starvation. It is never, ever, permissible to use civilians as bargaining chips, starving them in order to pressure an armed group to surrender. The fact that, in 2025, this is something that needs to be said; that, in Israel, saying it will be met with considerable hostility, shows how low we have sunk.
Since the 2nd of March, Israel’s hard-right messianic government has banned all aid from entering Gaza. This hermetic siege is by far the longest and harshest ever to be imposed on the Strip. With farmlands destroyed, the 2+ million population is almost entirely dependent on food coming from outside the strip. Most of it has run out. UN bakeries were closed a month ago due to a shortage of flour and cooking gas. Medications are also running out and clean water is in short supply.
Gaza relies on 168 community kitchens operated by the UN World Food Programme. These kitchens provide a hot meal that usually includes rice and beans or hummus. The WFP recently reported that its warehouses have emptied, and the remaining food had been transferred to the kitchens. It is unclear how long the food stored in the kitchens will last, but ten of them have closed last week and all the others have reduced the amount of food they are able to provide.
The Red Cross warned last week that ‘humanitarian efforts in Gaza are on the verge of complete collapse. Weeks of intense hostilities, combined with a complete blockade of aid for two months, have left civilians without the essentials they need to survive. Without immediate resumption of aid, they will have no access to food.’
Doctors and aid agencies reported that malnutrition-related illnesses, especially among children, are spreading in the Gaza Strip. UNICEF, reported that more than 9,000 children in the Gaza Strip have been hospitalized for acute malnutrition since the beginning of the year. It stated, and I quote: ‘hundreds of other children who desperately need treatment cannot access it due to insecurity and displacement.’
The UN Office for Cooperation and Humanitarian Affairs stated last week: ‘Children across Gaza, deprived of their childhood for many months, are rummaging through vast mountains of garbage in search of materials to burn for cooking. Plastic, fabrics, wood, anything that will help them survive. Facilities have been set up across the Strip that burn plastic and toxic waste to produce fuel. Clouds of black smoke rise into the Gaza sky, emitting dangerous fumes, endangering people’s lives and destroying the environment.’
Two months ago, the Israeli authorities made a deliberate decision to block all aid to Gaza. Blocking aid starves civilians. It leaves them without basic medical care. It deprives them of dignity and hope. It inflicts cruel collective punishment. Blocking aid kills. It needs to stop.
I will conclude by reading a poem written last year by Michael Rosen.
Don’t name the dead children
The people must not know the names
of the dead children.
The names of the children must be hidden.
The children must be nameless.
The children must leave this world
having no names.
No one must know the names of
the dead children.
No one must say the names of the
dead children.
No one must even think that the children
have names.
People must understand that it would be dangerous
to know the names of the children.
The people must be protected from
knowing the names of the children.
The names of the children could spread
like wildfire.
The people would not be safe if they knew
the names of the children.
Don’t name the dead children.
Don’t remember the dead children.
Don’t think of the dead children.
Don’t say: ‘dead children’.
***
But there ARE dead children in Gaza.
And they DO have names.
* Dr. Ruvi Ziegler is Associate Professor in International Refugee Law at the University of Reading. He is an Advisory Council member of Liberal Democrats for Seekers of Sanctuary.
8 Comments
Thank you. A spokesperson from the USA supporting the Israeli government said on radio there was no shortage of food in Gaza. The Israeli government says they imposed the ban on food aid to persuade Hamas to release hostages but if there is no shortage in Gaza then this imposition is not going to work. In addition to trustworthy reports, does this not show that those who claim there is no shortage are lying?
If they are not lying, it would be very easy for them to allow the international media into Gaza to report on what the IDF have been up to. After all, the media seem to be able to get almost anywhere in Syria today.
Nigel Jones makes a good point: if the blockade is not causing starvation, why impose it? Israel provides only confused responses to that question.
What Ruvi’s typically excellent, timely, and very powerful article does not address is the absence of a UK government response. Under Keir Starmer’s leadership, the UK has been wringing its hands over Israel’s increasingly deadly response to the October 7 attack by Hamas, and doing nothing meaningful to bring it to an end.
Unusually when a humanitarian disaster is taking place, in this case we have the means to stop it – by imposing punitive sanctions on the perpetrator. Starmer is not interested, and David Lammy does his master’s bidding, but when is Parliament (the MPs elected to represent the wishes of the British people) going to demand action instead of evasions and denials ?
“There is never, ever justification for a deliberate policy of starvation.”
Thank you for putting this essential liberal tenet so clearly. With the Starmer government’s complicity in war crimes Lib Dems are being seen to be the main party that upholds international human rights. Many Lib Dems will be demonstrating this at tomorrow’s national peace march for Palestine in London [email protected]
Andy Daer is right; there should be a UK Government response to the Israeli latest attacks on and denial of aid to Gaza, and we must press for it now. I was glad to read in the Parliamentary briefing from HQ that our Foreign Affairs spokesperson Calum Miller has written to the Foreign Secretary urging the UK to take stronger action if Israel continues its military assault on Gaza, including a total arms export ban, recognition of Palestine, and sanctions on extremist Israeli ministers. I hope he will repeat this urgently. Israel must be prevented from occupying Gaza and expelling its remaining suffering people. Most urgent is prevention of further starvation there.
It’s good to see some support for UK government action, but we have gone past the time when a total ban on arms sales would stop Israel. Only full sanctions would stop the slaughter and bring Israel to its senses. Donald Trump would quickly fall into line if we (closely followed by France and Germany) led the way. I’ve written to my MP to that effect, and hope others will do so, or already have.
Guardian…Layla Moran urges more action on Israel and warns of ‘cruel destitution’ in Gaza…
I would go further and treat Israel as we would ANY other nation behaving in such a manner to an specific section of it’s population…
A total ban on all trade, not just on arms sales… It worked in apartheid SA, whose offences paled into insignificance compared to Israel’s actions..
Agree with the posts above. BBC news tv coverage recently showed a trembling and probably fatally injured child being cared for by her despairing mother shocked and appalled me. This cruelty must stop.