Tag Archives: john ward

That Andrew Marr question: wrong, wrong, wrong

It’s a few weeks since I was emailed an article by John Ward (also sent to a number of other blog-sites), subsequently published at notbornyesterday.org, alleging the Prime Minister suffers from depression and obsessive compulsive disorder, and that these conditions are being treated with prescription pills.

I decided not to publish, or refer at all to the allegations on Lib Dem Voice. As I explained to John in an email at the time, “without named sources for the story it’s not something we could publish on LDV. I appreciate, given the nature of the story, that having sources on the record is difficult, but still.”

The BBC’s Andrew Marr today felt no such compunction, asking Gordon Brown bluntly: “A lot of people in this country use prescription painkillers and pills to help them get through. Are you one of them?” To which the Prime Minister would have been quite entitled to reply – though of course he couldn’t, as Mr Marr would have known – “None of your damned business.”

There are two issues here. First, was the BBC right to pose the question (and I’m sure the line of questioning was cleared at a high level within the Corporation)? And, secondly, should it matter to us what the Prime Minister’s reply was?

Was the BBC right? Absolutely not.

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged , , , , and | 37 Comments

Recent Comments

  • User AvatarGordon 24th Jan - 5:52pm
    “Two. We should now devote as much energy to changing the electoral system as we have to stopping Brexit.” Right idea, wrong target. Soon after...
  • User AvatarJayne R 24th Jan - 5:29pm
    Ha - fair point at Chris Cory. Though I believe a later showing would have been less unequal in audience make-up. As a child growing...
  • User AvatarJeremy Cunnington 24th Jan - 5:18pm
    The fundamental reason for building HS2 is the lack of line capacity on that stretch of railway. As the article says by building this line...
  • User AvatarChris Cory 24th Jan - 5:13pm
    Jayne and Ruth. Matinee kind of guy....oh I did smile . Generally no, but in truth this was a slightly earlier showing in the early...
  • User AvatarJeff 24th Jan - 5:08pm
    The alternative High Speed UK proposals, which utilise part of the old GCML route, may offer better value for money… ‘High Speed UK - Connecting...
  • User AvatarKaterina Porter 24th Jan - 5:05pm
    We are living in a country where can children come to school unable to follow lessons because there was not enough money at home to...