Tag Archives: professor a c grayling

Should Parliament put a stop to Brexit?

Most suggestions for resolving the “What the (insert expletive of choice) do we do now?” conundrum tend to involve various degrees of access to the Single Market or a General Election. Few are brave enough to suggest that Parliament simply declines to invoke Article 50. Until now.

Professor A C Grayling, Master of the New College of Humanities in London, has written to all MPs telling them that they have a responsibility not to support any such motion. He lists several reasons, not least the paucity of the campaign, the likelihood of the break up of the UK if we leave the EU and the fact that the threshold for such a huge change was set way too low. He has a point. You can’t change the number of places on a toddler group committee without a 2/3 majority. When the party conference considers a vast swathe of constitutional amendments in September, they will need a 2/3 majority to pass. With hindsight, you have to wonder why on earth we let such a major change through on a simple majority.

Harvard’s Professor Kenneth Rogoff agrees that the threshold is too low:

In terms of durability and conviction of preferences, most societies place greater hurdles in the way of a couple seeking a divorce than Prime Minister David Cameron’s government did on the decision to leave the EU. Brexiteers did not invent this game; there is ample precedent, including Scotland in 2014 and Quebec in 1995. But, until now, the gun’s cylinder never stopped on the bullet. Now that it has, it is time to rethink the rules of the game.

Grayling isn’t a fan of referenda anyway:

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged , , and | 82 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • FSPeople
    Pete Roberts The legal system has resolved how you address many of these situations but the LibDems just decided the law didn’t apply to them. That seems a p...
  • Jana
    @Nick Baird “ There is zero link between what you actually pay in, and what you get out” Clearly a false claim. For example, someone who leaves the UK i...
  • Ruth Bright
    Hi Jana that is a very fair point. I always pay careful attention to your comments. However, the use of barracks and other MoD property seems preferable to hote...
  • Nick Baird
    To add to Jenny's comment, you can build entitlement to a state pension without paying a penny. You can get NI credits if you are claiming benefits for being i...
  • PM
    Lib Dems could be a little bolder by actually discussing what goes on in the EU! Those who are in favour of rejoining should be prepared to do that https:/...