Tag Archives: stewart hosie

Nothing of public interest in lurid headlines about SNP MPs

Pick up any newspaper today, particularly the Scottish ones, and you’ll find a whole load of froth about two SNP MPs who have apparently had relationships, not at the same time, with the same woman. Both MPs have separated from their wives, most recently Deputy Leader Stewart Hosie from Scottish Health Minister Shona Robison at the weekend.

Those events will be particularly traumatic for the people involved and most especially for their children. I can’t however, see why it is any of our business. If either of them had shown hypocrisy and sought to curb others’ personal freedom, then perhaps calling them out for that would be relevant. Where is the public interest in this?

Much of the reporting is sensationalised and, more importantly, misogynistic on all sorts of levels. The woman concerned is cast as the “home wrecker” and extensive scrutiny is made of her blogs she has written which are simply not relevant. Nor is it appropriate to compare with the SNP MPs who have had to resign the whip and sit as independents. They have had to do because of various allegations of financial misconduct which are being investigated, not their personal lives

We really don’t need to know all of this stuff, and I wish editors would think about the effects of their articles on everyone affected. It’s hard enough for kids to come to terms with parents’ separation without their schoolmates hearing all sorts of lurid, unverifiable speculation. Maybe people who buy these papers and enjoy reading these stories should ask themselves how they would feel if it was their child going through it. We need to remember that behind each wild headline are lots of people having a really hard time. Our demand for such coverage makes their lives worse and it’s not necessary.

Posted in News | Also tagged , and | 25 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User Avatarcim 27th Feb - 3:44pm
    Toby Keynes: I don't think anyone is defending the current system as a good one, but given the opportunity to replace it, replacing it with...
  • User Avatarwilliam francis 27th Feb - 3:16pm
    Your article operates on the assumption that the only way to attain political power is to be in government. Ordinary Parliamentarian can influence legislation via...
  • User Avatarn hunter 27th Feb - 2:43pm
    To start this LibDem Policy Forum we could start with housing. Re more housing of modular type. Houses built in flood plains may be able...
  • User AvatarWilliam Wallace 27th Feb - 2:34pm
    A working group of LIbDem peers produced a fairly lengthy report on the 'left behind' two years ago, which was forwarded to the FPC -...
  • User AvatarFrank West 27th Feb - 2:33pm
    A couple of ways to fight back. On individual rights, the huge abuse of data by the govn (nowadays just about anyone can dig out...
  • User Avatarnigel hunter e 27th Feb - 2:29pm
    Chris Cory. That is an EXCELLENT idea.