Tag Archives: wittgenstein

Adam Bell

Opinion: Redefining Fairness

By Adam Bell | Sat 4th December 2010 - 2:52 pm

Our political discourse has become increasingly dominated by insubstantial ‘buzzwords’ like ‘fairness’ and ‘progressive’ to the point where discussions about politics have begun to focus less on policy differences and more on how these words are to be used. Truly, British politics has entered an era in which the works of Wittgenstein are more relevant to the debate than any properly political philosopher or theorist.

This is perhaps exemplified by the debate within our party over the meaning of the word ‘fairness’. Prompted by Nick Clegg’s Hugo Young lecture, the Social Liberal Forum (SLF) recently wrote in an article here on LDV concerning this subject, and claimed that it means:

“…that society is fairer when absolute poverty is eliminated, the gap between rich and poor is reduced and where people can rise (and fall) through the income hierarchy regardless of their starting point.”

On this definition, fairness is a question of outcomes, rather than principle. It is a term subsidiary to the moral principles that dictate which outcomes are to count as good, and which assign values to the decisions made by individuals inasmuch as they move towards those outcomes.

I am going to argue that this definition is incorrect, that it speaks to an undeveloped concept of liberalism, and that adherence to it will result in our subsumption into a Labour Party moving inexorably rightwards. I will then sketch out a new definition of fairness that aims to avoid these consequences.

Continue reading »
Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged , and | 19 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Nonconformistradical
    @Andy Daer " If we want to have institutional care of the elderly (which often means abdicating responsibility for our own relatives)" What do you mean by '...
  • Andy Daer
    Keir Starmer's speech writers must have been delighted to have come up with "an island of strangers", an apparently anodyne reworking of Enoch Powell's "rivers ...
  • Peter Davies
    @J The latest poll in London shows us and the Greens up five points each (16% and 15% respectively). I suspect much of that swing is in posh Labour areas like I...
  • David LG
    The problem that Labour (and apparently Ed Davey) fail to grasp is that we don't have an immigration problem, we have a xenophobia problem. If leaving the EU t...
  • Mark ValladaresMark Valladares
    @ Matt, One of the things that often puzzles me is the selective disregard for the idea of market forces. In this instance, market forces are effectively den...