What our Liberal Democrat leaders are saying about the EU referendum

4 leaders and a president 1I was delighted to receive the email about the Lib Dem leaders’ European event and signed up immediately because, frankly, the EU referendum debate has been inundated with arguments that don’t always make sense and are often factually ambiguous. I am quite often irritated these days because of this.

The Lib Dems leaders,Paddy Ashdown, Ming Campbell, Nick Clegg and Tim Farron, didn’t let me down and it was excellent to see a united front on display. It felt like quite a historic moment for a young person like me.

The event took place at the BAFTA offices in Piccadilly. Each leader began with an impassioned speech explaining what staying in Europe meant to him and why we should adopt the same approach.

My favourite remark came from Tim Farron who said that those who support the leave campaign are “selfish” and should set aside their own prejudices or beliefs for the good of their children’s future and how we should avoid being, “insular, isolated, alone or irrelevant”. He said that he was not making the decision to vote in as a politician but as a “parent and a patriot”. Tim also attacked the out campaign and referred to it as “sheer dishonest elitism”. Tim’s analysis was spot on because of his emphasis on a concern for the future generations if we were to leave the EU.

I spoke to Tim afterwards and got a good account about his beliefs. He explained than any young person voting should, “consider educational opportunities, work abroad and most importantly climate change.” He sees climate change as an extremely pressing issue for future generations and that we would be “better equipped to deal with it in the EU”. He also said that staying in the EU would be a “smart outward looking statement”.

4 leaders and a president 2Paddy displayed a similar sentiment to Tim in that he addressed the importance of the EU’s help with future generations. Leaving, he said, “would be an act of historic folly which our grandchildren and children would be bound to pay the price”. Paddy repeatedly praised the EU and placed emphasis on it’s ability to act as a tool for avoiding conflict as he referred to it as, “the greatest peace making institution that we have ever seen”.

Ming also praised the EU by explaining that membership is beneficial to Britain as it holds, “complimentary affiliations” which mean that we are able to work together for mutual benefits.

Nick conveyed the need for affiliations with the EU by positioning the UK as an international foreign policy player. He said that if we are to act on an international stage “how else are we going to go toe to toe with great superpowers other than doing so with the collective clout that we have through the European Union?”

4 leaders and a president 3I was compelled by these arguments which continually reiterated that we are stronger together and that we benefit from the EU as 3 million jobs are linked to trade with the EU, 89% of businesses back staying in Europe and because EU membership has increased average UK salaries by £1,800.

The debate then moved to questions from the audience. The leaders were asked about the non factual and unsupported information being put out by the leave campaign. These so-called fact come via those such as Michael Gove who claimed that the NHS would receive £100m more a week in funding if we left the EU. The leave campaign has not only been riddled by false statistics but also by false and harmful sentiments such as Farage referring to sexual assaults by immigrants to stir anti-European feelings.

Tim and Paddy who noted the appeal of providing simple solutions to complex questions for the general populace rather than solid facts. The help of the EU in dealing with the migrant crisis and the potential of a subsequent Scottish referendum as a result of an ‘out’ vote were addressed in further questions.

Nick Clegg also furthered his case by not only addressing the importance of economic benefits from the EU but also the cultural ones by providing a narrative of cultural benefits from the EU and stating that we are, “culturally entwined with Europe as it is a part of our cultural landscape” and that we are, “better for it”

It was a successful event and if I could vote I would certainly be putting an ‘X’ beside ‘Remain’.

* Maelo Manning is a 15 year old Lib Dem member. She blogs as Lib Dem Child.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in News.
Advert

8 Comments

  • Richard Underhill 9th Jun '16 - 8:53am
  • Rightsaidfredfan 9th Jun '16 - 9:02pm

    I really don’t think it’s fair to say that those who want to leave are selfish. One could easily turn it around and say that wanting cheap labour to under cut those at the bottom of the socio economic pile is selfish.

  • @Rightsaidfredfan
    You are extraordinarily naive if you think Brexit will lead to lower immigration.

  • David Evans 9th Jun '16 - 10:16pm

    Andrew R – You may disagree with Rightsaidfredfan, but play the ball, not the man.

  • Rightsaidfredfan 9th Jun '16 - 11:37pm

    @David Evans

    Thanks. This whole thing has descended into personal attacks, mostly from the remain side. The outers are called selfish, the outers are called bigots and the personal attacks on boris tonight did remain no favours either.

  • Im not sure how respectful one can be, to someone who tells completely unsupported things and is prepared to sustain a lie, even when it has been identified as such.

    You may for what I find unbelievable, want to wreck the British economy,reduce inward investment and watch as businesses reluctantly leave our shores but some of us dont. And we might just get a little uppity with those who use false arguments to promote this.

  • “Im not sure how respectful one can be, to someone who tells completely unsupported things and is prepared to sustain a lie, even when it has been identified as such.”
    You’re right Bob.
    Every time someone writes about ‘EU Funding’, I point out the *fact* that the EU has no funding to give, and the sleight of hand trick is that the EU are giving us our own money back. But you can be sure that a dozen LDV articles onward, and someone will repeat the lie that audaciously calls itself ‘EU funding’?
    Very frustrating,.. I agree.

  • .I’m for ‘IN’ but have a ‘gut feeling’ that it’ll be ‘OUT’….

    Anyway, if ‘OUT’ it is, I’ll look forward to all that extra £100M per week (Gove) going into the NHS, the new trade deals and the 300,000 new jobs (Johnson) plus the massive reduction in immigration….

    With all that on offer perhaps it’s me who is ‘crazy’ to want to remain..

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarPeter Hirst 16th Jan - 3:06pm
    A wise politician, especially a Westminster one might say that (s)he is not the wisest person to make these constitutional decision, being too easily influenced...
  • User Avatarnvelope2003 16th Jan - 3:05pm
    David Raw: The point I was trying to make was that restoring a railway can be cheaper than widening a road but it might not...
  • User AvatarNigel Jones 16th Jan - 3:04pm
    The two Davids are thinking in one of the right lines, but we need both their suggested policy action approach AND a positive vision for...
  • User AvatarJoe Bourke 16th Jan - 3:00pm
    Peter Martin, Jennie's comment is on her own lived personal experiences: "It’s not metropolitan elitist to say that many leave voters voted the way they...
  • User AvatarJenny Barnes 16th Jan - 2:59pm
    This here people's vote. What's the question? You can hardly put TM's annihilated deal on the ballot, after what happened to it in Parliament. And...
  • User AvatarSean Hagan 16th Jan - 2:43pm
    Thank you, David Raw, for reminding us about the Jenkins Commission and the other political realities which made it impossible to extract a commitment from...