Author Archives: Ben Wōden

Is there a scientific basis for the sugar levy?

Discussion of the sugar levy has focused on effectiveness and moral/political hazards. I want to focus on one problem that makes those redundant: Does it make scientific sense?

Not obviously.

A popular narrative: In the past, we thought obese people were that way because they lacked willpower and ate too much food, particularly fat, which obviously made you “fat” – it’s called fat! Then, scientists who had previously been silenced by the nutrition science establishment (which was in Big Sugar’s pocket) bravely spoke up and educated us on the Science!™, and now we know that it’s sugar, not fat, that makes you obese.

Reality is more complicated.

The supposedly debunked “fat = evil” paradigm was never a scientific consensus, but merely a pop-science one. It was less the work of the nutrition scientists than of sugar companies and the makers of low-fat diet products. The supposedly triumphant “sugar = evil” paradigm also has little support amongst nutrition scientists. At best, they are marginally more concerned with the impact of sugar on health than they were 50 years ago, and marginally less concerned about fat.

It isn’t hard to blow the simplistic anti-sugar position out of the water. This graph does it impressively, and should make everyone update their beliefs significantly away from thinking that sugar is a major cause of obesity, and should absolutely torpedo the simplistic “sugar = evil” position that has taken hold in many parts of the population and, seemingly, in government.

Posted in Op-eds | Tagged , and | 23 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarMartin 12th Jul - 10:14am
    Given the behaviour of the Westminster government and increasing centralisation, are you really sure that implacable opposition to a post Brexit independence referendum is a...
  • User AvatarPeter Martin 12th Jul - 8:09am
    “…Sunak will have to order steep tax rises to plug a £40bn gap in the public finances caused by emergency spending during the Covid-19 crisis.”...
  • User Avatarrichard underhill 12th Jul - 7:48am
    This seems to assume that we actually want more economists, when we actually want political reform, including electoral reform.
  • User AvatarJenny Barnes 12th Jul - 7:22am
    “Increasing road fuel tax is not a good policy “ Oh yes it is. My side of the theatre can shout louder than your side....
  • User AvatarMichael BG 12th Jul - 3:12am
    Joe Bourke, You set out what might be Rishi Sundak’s thinking. However, he has made a huge mistake in not having a new worker retention...
  • User AvatarMichael BG 12th Jul - 3:06am
    Thank you everyone who has commented. Katharine, Both Ed and Layla are talking the talk but they have not mentioned poverty in their top three...