Author Archives: Simon Read

Simon Read

Opinion: Proportional voting

By Simon Read | Mon 10th May 2010 - 9:20 am

I propose a method of voting in the House of Commons which has the effect of proportional representation without any of the complexity.

There are two possible sacred principles in British democracy:

1) A Member of Parliament has one vote;
2) A party’s voting strength in the house should match its share of the countrywide vote.

Each principle has its adherents. Principle (1) seems to be assumed by everyone but never mentioned.

These principles are in fact contradictory, leading to much complexity, so I propose to abandon principle (1) above, leaving us with principle (2).

The mechanism is simple: take the number of votes cast at …

Continue reading »
Posted in Op-eds | Tagged | 38 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Peter Hirst
    Valuing the idea of independence while recognising that in the modern world it is an illusion is a dilemma that many politicians recognise. Freedom is probably ...
  • Peter Hirst
    What the world needs is a global body that recognises, evaluates and reports on AI content so that some other body can decide when to act to prevent it being ha...
  • David McDowall
    Rather than focusing on Ambassador Huckabee, shouldn't we focus on Britain’s abject failures on Palestine? Pillage is plunder, and absolutely forbidden. We th...
  • expats
    Ref. Israel/UK...The Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, called the UK “the Islamic republic of Britain” in a podcast interview, where he also descr...
  • Alex Macfie
    Not sure how "economic liberalism" is supposed to work with a natural monopoly such as water provision. You just get private monopolies. Also you can't necessa...