Author Archives: Simon Read

Simon Read

Opinion: Proportional voting

By Simon Read | Mon 10th May 2010 - 9:20 am

I propose a method of voting in the House of Commons which has the effect of proportional representation without any of the complexity.

There are two possible sacred principles in British democracy:

1) A Member of Parliament has one vote;
2) A party’s voting strength in the house should match its share of the countrywide vote.

Each principle has its adherents. Principle (1) seems to be assumed by everyone but never mentioned.

These principles are in fact contradictory, leading to much complexity, so I propose to abandon principle (1) above, leaving us with principle (2).

The mechanism is simple: take the number of votes cast at …

Continue reading »
Posted in Op-eds | Tagged | 38 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Tony Vickers
    If we let the Greens win here it’s bad news for all our MPs who have slim majorities that largely depended on the tactical Green vote in 2024. We are disappea...
  • Hywel
    "This by-election, where we have absolutely nothing to lose, is a perfect opportunity to set out our stall as a political party and challenge voters to support ...
  • Peter Davies
    The difference between the 1997 deal and the Scottish one is that one was before the election and could be immediately renaged on once they were in power. The o...
  • Jana
    @Mick Taylor “ Last time we made a deal with Labour on this, in 1997, they had the Jenkins commission and then did nothing.” Perhaps. You are forgetting...
  • Peter Martin
    @ Michael BG, "I am surprised that you think the public mood is that benefits should not be means-tested." I didn't say this. I did say "Th...