Author Archives: Stephen Tall

Stephen was Editor (and Co-Editor) of Liberal Democrat Voice from 2007 to 2015, and writes at The Collected Stephen Tall. He writes a fortnightly column for ConservativeHome and 'The Underdog' column for Total Politics magazine. He edited the 2013 publication, The Coalition and Beyond: Liberal Reforms for the Decade Ahead, and is a Research Associate for the liberal think-tank CentreForum. He was awarded the inaugural Lib Dem ‘Blogger of the Year’ prize in 2006, was a councillor for eight years in Oxford, including a year as Deputy Lord Mayor, and appears frequently in the media in person, in print and online. Stephen combines his political interests with his professional life as Development Director for the Education Endowment Foundation, though writes here in a personal capacity.

Second Lib Dem MP signs up for Euro referendum

David Heath, the Lib Dems’ Shadow Secretary of State for Justice and Shadow Lord Chancellor, has become the second party MP to urge a public vote on the EU reform treaty.

David today joined a cross-party group of MPs in launching a nationwide campaign, labelled simply “I want a referendum”, which aims to force Gordon Brown to call a referendum on the EU treaty.

Last week, Mike Hancock became the first Lib Dem MP publicly to call for the party to support a referendum.

Posted in News | Tagged | 6 Comments

Is Matthew Parris right about Gordon Brown?

Former Tory MP and Times columnist has this to say about the new Prime Minister in today’s Times:

I keep saying this – but the man hasn’t got the ghost of a plan. Not an idea in his head. Anyone with ears to hear could guess as much from his speech and media interviews on Monday. “Citizens’ juries” across the country to advise the Government on policy? Spare us. Why doesn’t he advise the Government? He’s the Prime Minister.

What leaps from Mr Brown’s interviews is not the intellectual colossus that some of my Fleet Street colleagues describe, but

Posted in News | Leave a comment

The Ming Thing

Here we go again. Yes, it’s The Leadership Question. Frankly, I haven’t got the energy, and I reckon I’m not alone. But Lib Dem Voice tries not to ignore media coverage of the Lib Dems simply because it’s tedious beyond belief. So here goes:

* If you like Ming Campbell, he’s lauded by Dominic Lawson in The Independent here;
* If you don’t like Ming Campbell, he’s lambasted by Daniel Finkelstein in The Times here.

Whatever.

Posted in News | 15 Comments

Poll result: LDV readers say Yes to EU reform treaty referendum

We asked:
Should the Liberal Democrats back demands for a referendum on the European Union reform treaty?

You said:
Yes – 54% (85)
No – 37% (57)
Don’t know yet – 9% (14)
Total Votes : 156

This poll is now closed. A new poll will shortly go live inviting LDV readers to vote for one of the short-listed blogs in the ‘Best designed’ category of this year’s Liberal Democrat Blog of the Year awards.

Posted in News and Voice polls | 2 Comments

Is it time for a televised leaders’ debate?

Yesterday Gordon Brown faced repeated media questioning asking if he would agree to take part in the UK’s first televised debate between the leaders of the three main political parties. Mr Brown rejected the idea.

Adam Boulton’s blog rehearses the familiar arguments:

Brown didn’t even entertain the idea of debate. Instead he used the same old excuses. It’s not the British Way. A General Election is not a presidential contest, since voters are choosing between parties not directly electing a leader. British party leaders debate regularly in parliament. All these arguments are reasonable but not, I believe overwhelming. Isn’t precedent

Posted in News | Tagged | 15 Comments

High praise for Huhne’s green proposals

Chris Huhne’s new zero-carbon Britain proposals – which Chris wrote about for Lib Dem Voice last week – have met with the glowing approval of Guardian economics correspondent, Ashley Seagar:

At last someone in the mainstream of politics is taking climate change seriously. … when one of the main parties comes up with a coherent strategy for dealing with climate change, both at home and abroad, it deserves close attention, particularly as … Labour has made very little progress in moving to a sustainable energy economy, and knows it. The Tories, too, although talking about taxing flights, will duck serious policy changes when their Quality of Life report emerges later this month.

The LibDem document makes for fascinating reading.

Posted in News | Leave a comment

Taylor to lead major government review

Prime Minister Gordon Brown – as part of his New Politics / Big Tent relaunch of Labour – has appointed Matthew Taylor, Lib Dem MP for Truro & St Austell, to lead a major independent review of planning and land-use policy in relation to rural and affordable housing.

Lib Dem leader Ming Campbell has been quick to welcome the news:

“Matthew and I have agreed that he should take up this opportunity to review rural housing and business policies. As the MP for a rural constituency with the least affordable rural housing in the country, Matthew has direct experience of

Posted in News | 23 Comments

Top Lib Dem media tarts of the year

Which Lib Dem MPs received the most media mentions between 1st September 2006 and 31st August 2007?

To find out I trawled Lexis-Nexis’s online database of all UK national newspapers (and a huge number of regional ones), feeding in the names of each of our MPs in turn, and seeing how many returns were generated.

(I first compiled this list back in March, over at my own blog, since when Iain Dale has taken to tracking the performance of the Tory shadow cabinet – and a handful of Lib Dems – on a monthly basis.)

For ultra-fairness, those with variations on their names – eg, Vince Cable and Ed Davey – have had their scores combined. To qualify, the MP must have been mentioned either as a Liberal Democrat or Lib Dem.

Anyway, here’s the list in descending order of media mentions:

Posted in News | Tagged | 2 Comments

Top of the Blogs: The Golden Dozen #28

Welcome to the 28th of our weekly round-ups from the Lib Dem blogosphere, featuring the seven most popular stories according to click-throughs from the Aggregator (26th August – 1st September), together with a hand-picked quintet you might otherwise have missed.

Without further ado:

Posted in Best of the blogs | Leave a comment

Challenge to German’s Welsh leadership likely

According to Wales on Sunday:

LIB Dem AM Peter Black last night gave the strongest hint yet he will challenge Mike German for the party leadership. The party’s social justice spokesman – who called for Mr German to go after May’s Assembly election – indicated he would stand if none of his Assembly colleagues did.

It comes as a second Lib Dem AM publicly called for their leader to quit. Mick Bates, the party’s agriculture spokesman, said it was time for Mr German to move on.

You can read the full story here.

Here’s what Peter told the paper:

“I’m still talking to colleagues

Posted in News | Tagged | 4 Comments

Lib Dems: about to collapse, or on the up?

Two very alternative takes on the party’s fortunes have appeared in the press in the last few days.

For those who like to drink from the glass half-empty, you can sup happily from today’s leader in the Tory-supporting Daily Telegraph:

Liberal Democrat support is quite simply collapsing. The party currently attracts only 14 per cent of voters, compared with 22 per cent in the 2005 general election. If there were a general election tomorrow, the Lib Dems would lose some of their most cherished West Country seats – to the Tories. Admittedly, Gordon Brown would be returned to office with an increased majority, but, for the first time in decades, Britain’s third party would have been reduced to insignificance.

There are several reasons for this state of affairs. When Mr Cameron rebranded the Conservatives as a green party, he pushed the Lib Dems off a patch of the ground that they had occupied, rather smugly, for years. But there is a more significant factor, which can be summed up in two words: Menzies Campbell.

But those who prefer their politics sunny-side-up can opt instead for Bill Jacobs’ upbeat assessment in The Scotsman:

Unexpectedly, Liberal Democrat leader Sir Menzies Campbell has had the most relaxed holiday of the three party chiefs. While Gordon Brown has been desperate to show that as Prime Minister he is just as much in control as he was as Chancellor, and David Cameron has been trying to subdue his unruly Conservative Party, Ming finds himself as ruler of all he surveys. …

As the wheels came off Mr Cameron’s new Tory bandwagon over the early summer and Mr Brown took over from Mr Blair, the Lib Dem leader’s performances at Westminster strengthened and his age ceased to be an issue in the press. The idea of a steady hand on the tiller of the Liberal Democrats as well as in the country took hold and the murmuring in the party subsided. …

Posted in News | Tagged | 37 Comments

Hancock backs EU treaty referendum

Lib Dem MP for Portsmouth South, Mike Hancock, has publicly demanded the Liberal Democrats support a referendum on the EU reform treaty – and says that that many of his Parliamentary colleagues agree.

Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s World at One today, Mike said:

“I believe requires the agreement of the British people – as Prime Minister Blair promised, and as we as a party in the Liberal Democrats promised. … I’m unsure myself, but I would hope that the Lib Dems will stick to their word on this one. I certainly wouldn’t compromise my position on it. I’m adamant,

Posted in News | Tagged | 15 Comments

Lib Dem Blog of the Year awards

As I type, there are just 9 hours and 22 minutes left in which you can make your nominations for the 2007 Liberal Democrat Blog of the Year awards, this year run in conjunction with Lib Dem Voice.

Full details of the categories, judges and rules are available on the party website here. The results will be announced at an awards ceremony at the Lib Dem conference on Sunday, 16th September.

Posted in News | 1 Comment

Good news for Lib Dems in Norfolk South: Charles Clarke has ‘no plans to quit’

According at any rate to the Norfolk Eastern Daily Press:

dismissed suggestions he was ready to throw in the towel and insisted he had no plans to walk away from British politics or his city seat.

“I don’t know where the idea that I am not running in the next election comes from,” Mr Clarke said. “I am absolutely looking forward to being the Labour candidate and hopefully being elected. I am hoping the electors in Norwich South will look at all the candidates and not vote in some kind of tactical way.” …

Simon Wright, Lib Dem candidate for

Posted in News | Tagged and | 1 Comment

How much the Lib Dems spent fighting the Welsh Assembly elections

The Electoral Commission has today published figures showing how much each of the political parties spent contesting May 2007’s Welsh Assembly elections.

In total the Lib Dems spent £407,407 – £239,799 was spent by the party, with a further £167,608 incurred by candidates. This was £33,791 less than the Tories’ total (£441,198) and £10,211 less than Paid Cymru (£417,618).

(Labour figures are not yet available, as the party’s total spending exceeded £250,000, which means they have until 2nd November to file their expenses.)

In 2003, the Welsh Lib Dems spent £372,695, attracting a total of 228,353 votes (combining the …

Posted in News | 12 Comments

Economist praises Clegg’s “impressive” immigration proposals

Earlier in the week, Nick Clegg, the Lib Dems’ shadow home secretary, set out in The Observer his thinking on what a liberal immigration policy should look like. In particular, he tackled head-on the issue of what to do about the estimated 600,000 immigrants living illegally in the UK:

… a route of earned legalisation should be made available to those who have lived here unauthorised for many years. We would set stringent criteria – this is not a blanket amnesty – namely that the applicant should have lived in the UK for many years; should have a clean criminal record; and should show a long-term commitment to the UK. The applicant would be subject to a public interest test and an English language and civics test, and would be required to pay a charge. This would be of economic benefit too, with the exchequer estimated to be losing out on as much as £3.3bn in unpaid tax each year.

Here’s what this week’s Economist has to say about Nick’s proposals:

Posted in Conference and News | 3 Comments

Boris hails a Lib Dem hero

Author, journalist, and occasional politician Boris Johnson has devoted his column in today’s Telegraph to hailing a new hero: Lib Dem peer, Lord Phillips of Sudbury.

Here’s why:

… last week he struck such a blow for freedom and common sense that, if there were any justice, the people of Sudbury would now be organising a subscription to erect his statue in the market place. Because it was in that very market place that Lord Phillips of Sudbury faced a moral dilemma, of a kind that many of us face – without acknowledging it – every day.

In an instant, he decided to defy modern correct thinking. He set an example for us all. He did the right thing.

Posted in News | Tagged | 10 Comments

‘Being Norman Lamb’ in the Staggers

The New Statesman blog devotes a column to the Norman Lamb Facebook saga:

In an unprecedented turn of events, the blogosphere was focused on East Anglia for much of this week. Recent reports of identity thieves finding a rich resource on Facebook were highlighted in the ongoing saga involving the profile on the social networking site of Lib Dem health spokesman Norman Lamb. A brief history of which is covered at Lib Dem Voice.

The same IP address was shown to be responsible for tampering with Lamb’s Wikipedia entry and also uploading an anti-Lib Dem video on YouTube. Various

Posted in News | Tagged , and | Leave a comment

Lib Dems’ Zero-carbon Britain proposals: the media view

As you’d expect, really… lauded by the left-liberal press; ignored by the right-wing…

The Independent

The Liberal Democrats detailed proposals to make Britain a carbon-neutral state by 2050, underlining a long-standing commitment to the environment. … Yesterday’s proposals by the Liberal Democrats highlight how much more there is to do. They have proposed taxes on pollution not people and the introduction of green mortgages. They suggest a vastly improved new North-South high-speed rail line, paid for by road tolls, and a massive boost to Britain’s flood defences.

The Guardian

The Liberal Democrat leadership yesterday outlined a vision

Posted in News | 2 Comments

New poll: should the Lib Dems back an EU treaty referendum?

There’s speculation in today’s Telegraph that the Lib Dems might back calls from the Tories, and from some 120 Labour rebels, for a referendum on the European Union reform treaty:

Sir Menzies Campbell, the Lib Dem leader, refused yesterday to rule out backing a referendum before a Commons scrutiny of the treaty proposals. Even though he said his personal view was that it was not necessary this time, he added: “I don’t think you can make a final decision on that until we see what the final document looks like.”

A senior party source later disclosed that younger Lib Dem MPs

Posted in Voice polls | Tagged | 34 Comments

It’s 2008!, say LDV readers

The results of our latest poll are in, and it seems almost 70% of Lib Dem Voice readers reckon there will be a general election within the next year or so.

We asked: “When do you think the next general election will be?”

You said:
* 2007: 19% (40)
* 2008: 50% (103)
* 2009: 27% (56)
* 2010: 4% (9)
Total Votes: 208

In which case, go back to your constituencies and prepare to campaign.

Posted in Voice polls | 2 Comments

Top of the Blogs: The Golden Ton

‘Tis the season for lists… Below are the top 100 posts by Lib Dem bloggers, in descending order of popularity, for the last year – August 2006 to July 2007, inclusive – according to click-throughs from the Aggregator.

(Profuse thanks to techno-wizard and stat-monkey Ryan Cullen, who runs the Aggregator, for compiling this table.)

Five blogs are responsible for almost half the postings: Lib Dem Voice accounts for 16 of the top 100 postings (we thank you); James Graham’s Quaequam Blog! for 10; Nich Starling’s Norfolk Blogger for 9; Paul Walter’s Liberal Burblings for 7; and Jonathan Calder’s Liberal England for 6.

It’s interesting, too, to note how many of the most popular postings are from recent months – especially to do with the Ealing and Sedgefield by-elections – suggesting that the audience for Lib Dem blogs is growing significantly.

Anyway, enough of the pre-match analysis:

Posted in Best of the blogs | Tagged | 11 Comments

Dear Gordon, Dear Ming

The exchange of letters between Ming Campbell and Gordon Brown over the Labour government’s disastrous Middle East foreign policy has been dominating the headlines all day:

BBC Online;
The Telegraph;
The Independent;
Politics.co.uk.

Ming has responded to the Prime Minister’s reply over at his website – here – witheringly noting that it “simply rehearses the Government line and could have been written by his predecessor”.

Posted in News | 3 Comments

Lembit gets serious (and announces next Presidency bid)

Lembit Öpik, Lib Dem shadow secretary of state for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, has used an interview in the Financial Times to lay out his thinking on his new portfolio – and to confirm he will stand for the presidency of the party when current incumbent Simon Hughes’s term ends next year.

Full story here; here’s the fillet:

Lembit on Lib Dem business policy:

“I think our policies have been reasonably good, and certainly have improved a lot in the last five years.” But he admitted the Lib Dems had a long way to go. “We have a perception problem in

Posted in News | 9 Comments

Top Lib Dem blogger’s £27k donations to party

The South Wales Evening Post has highlighted Lib Dem Welsh Assembly Member (and top Lib Dem blogger) Peter Black’s generosity to party funds in the last four years – totalling an impressive £27,000, which Peter has used to fund his election campaigns:

… the Cwmbwrla ward member on Swansea Council laughed off any suggestions that he was in the millionaire bracket.

‘I only wish I was,’ Peter said. ‘I have made two donations – to fund my election campaigns in 2003 and 2007. The donations were funded by my council allowances. I paid the money into the party. It is for

Posted in News | 3 Comments

Lib Dem peer attacks Lord Offshore Ashcroft

‘Ashcroft’s hold on party raises fears of Tory rift’ shouts the Telegraph headline, re-reporting the (month-old) news that top Tory peer, Michael Ashcroft, is directing and funding the party’s key seats strategy:

Tory concerns at the growing influence of Lord Ashcroft have been heightened by a memo to candidates from the billionaire peer instructing them on how to run their election campaigns. … Lord Ashcroft has moved into a large office in Conservative Campaign Headquarters in London’s Millbank from where he will run the party’s strategy for target seats.

Posted in News | Tagged , and | 4 Comments

Hillary and Dave: separated at re-birth?

Andrew Sullivan draws some interesting parallels, in today’s Sunday Times, between the dilemmas facing US Democratic Presidential hopeful Senator Hillary Clinton, and Tory leader David Cameron:

Cameron has a Hillary problem. Hillary Clinton learnt the hard way what it is to be a Democrat in a Republican era, just as Cameron has had to learn how to be a Tory in a new Labour era. Every time you open your mouth, you fear your opponents will corner you into the old liberal or Tory stereotype.

So you play relentlessly against type, and hedge yourself aggressively against critics, and aim for

Posted in Op-eds | 3 Comments

Top of the Blogs: The Golden Baker’s Dozen #24

Welcome to the 24th of our weekly round-ups from the Lib Dem blogosphere, featuring the seven most popular stories according to click-throughs from the Aggregator (29th July – 4th August), together with a hand-picked sextet you might otherwise have missed.

Here we go, in descending order of popularity:

Posted in Best of the blogs | Leave a comment

How do you solve a problem like PMQs?

Lib Dem MP Lynne Featherstone has posed an interesting question over at her blog – how the demeaning farce which is Prime Minister’s Questions in the House of Commons can be improved:

To me – yes, it’s great theatre and even fun at time but – it’s utterly crap as a way of holding the Prime Minister or Government to account – and I doubt the baying mob moment where everyone (except polite Lib Dems of course!) is cheering or booing does much for the reputation of politics.

After all – what would you think of someone who behaved in a work

Posted in News and PMQs | 4 Comments

Lib Dem peer: let the Royals marry Catholics

This according to the Daily Telegraph:

Lord Lester, the Liberal Democrat peer drafted in by the Prime Minister to advise on constitutional issues, told The Daily Telegraph that the centuries-old ban was “an injustice” that should now go.

The outspoken comments from the respected peer came after it emerged that Peter Phillips, the Queen’s eldest grandson and 10th in line to the throne, might have to surrender his place in the succession. Mr Phillips, 29, the son of the Princess Royal, is now engaged to Autumn Kelly, 31, a Canadian management consultant who was baptised a Catholic. The fact was not

Posted in News | 29 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Tom Bailey
    I’m getting vibes of the film “Being There” when I see Andy Burnham. The premise of the film is that a simple minded gardener, has convinced the elite tha...
  • Matt (Bristol)
    But the Transport House shenannigans do sound fun...
  • Matt (Bristol)
    David, rather than questions of character, I was rather more thinking of the theatricality of the 1880 Midlothian campaign itself, an 'insurgent' campaign from ...
  • David Raw
    Sorry, Matt, I've succumbed to your invitation. Very different, I'm afraid, though both born on Merseyside. William Ewart's Dad a hugely wealthy merchant, slave...
  • Jana
    Changing the captain on a ship is completely pointless unless the new captain is willing to change direction. Changing the party of government in 2024 did not r...